Explore then Determine: A GNN-LLM Synergy Framework for Reasoning over Knowledge Graph
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This paper presents a framework called "Explore then Determine" that combines Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) and Large Language Models (LLMs) to improve reasoning over knowledge graphs.
• The key idea is to use the GNN to first explore the relevant parts of the knowledge graph, and then use the LLM to determine the final answer.
Plain English Explanation
• Knowledge graphs are structured databases that store information about the world in the form of entities (things) and the relationships between them.
• Reasoning over knowledge graphs, such as answering questions, can be challenging because it requires understanding the complex connections between entities.
• The authors of this paper propose a new approach that combines the strengths of two powerful AI techniques - GNNs and LLMs.
• GNNs are good at exploring and understanding the structure of knowledge graphs, while LLMs are adept at natural language processing and generating coherent responses.
• By first using the GNN to identify the relevant parts of the knowledge graph, and then using the LLM to determine the final answer, the framework can leverage the complementary capabilities of these two technologies.
• This synergistic approach, called "Explore then Determine", aims to improve the accuracy and efficiency of reasoning over knowledge graphs compared to using either GNNs or LLMs alone.
Technical Explanation
• The framework consists of two main components: a GNN-based module and an LLM-based module.
• The GNN-based module takes the knowledge graph and the input query as input, and outputs a set of relevant entities and their relationships. This helps to focus the reasoning process on the most important parts of the knowledge graph.
• The LLM-based module then takes the output of the GNN-based module, as well as the original query, and generates the final answer.
• The authors evaluate their framework on several knowledge graph reasoning benchmarks and show that it outperforms both standalone GNN and LLM models, as well as other state-of-the-art approaches.
Critical Analysis
• The paper does not address potential concerns about the scalability of the framework, particularly as knowledge graphs and queries become more complex.
• The authors also do not discuss the computational and memory requirements of the framework, which could be an important consideration for real-world applications.
• Additionally, the paper does not explore the robustness of the framework to noisy or incomplete knowledge graphs, which is a common challenge in real-world settings.
• Further research could investigate the framework's performance on a wider range of tasks and datasets, as well as explore ways to improve its efficiency and scalability.
Conclusion
• The "Explore then Determine" framework presents a promising approach for leveraging the complementary strengths of GNNs and LLMs to improve reasoning over knowledge graphs.
• By first using the GNN to explore the relevant parts of the knowledge graph and then using the LLM to determine the final answer, the framework can achieve better performance than either technology alone.
• While the paper highlights the potential of this synergistic approach, further research is needed to address the framework's scalability, efficiency, and robustness to real-world challenges.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Explore then Determine: A GNN-LLM Synergy Framework for Reasoning over Knowledge Graph
Guangyi Liu, Yongqi Zhang, Yong Li, Quanming Yao
The task of reasoning over Knowledge Graphs (KGs) poses a significant challenge for Large Language Models (LLMs) due to the complex structure and large amounts of irrelevant information. Existing LLM reasoning methods overlook the importance of compositional learning on KG to supply with precise knowledge. Besides, the fine-tuning and frequent interaction with LLMs incur substantial time and resource costs. This paper focuses on the Question Answering over Knowledge Graph (KGQA) task and proposes an Explore-then-Determine (EtD) framework that synergizes LLMs with graph neural networks (GNNs) for reasoning over KGs. The Explore stage employs a lightweight GNN to explore promising candidates and relevant fine-grained knowledge to the questions, while the Determine stage utilizes the explored information to construct a knowledge-enhanced multiple-choice prompt, guiding a frozen LLM to determine the final answer. Extensive experiments on three benchmark KGQA datasets demonstrate that EtD achieves state-of-the-art performance and generates faithful reasoning results.
Read more6/4/2024
🌀
0
An Enhanced Prompt-Based LLM Reasoning Scheme via Knowledge Graph-Integrated Collaboration
Yihao Li, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu
While Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional performance in a multitude of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, they encounter challenges in practical applications, including issues with hallucinations, inadequate knowledge updating, and limited transparency in the reasoning process. To overcome these limitations, this study innovatively proposes a collaborative training-free reasoning scheme involving tight cooperation between Knowledge Graph (KG) and LLMs. This scheme first involves using LLMs to iteratively explore KG, selectively retrieving a task-relevant knowledge subgraph to support reasoning. The LLMs are then guided to further combine inherent implicit knowledge to reason on the subgraph while explicitly elucidating the reasoning process. Through such a cooperative approach, our scheme achieves more reliable knowledge-based reasoning and facilitates the tracing of the reasoning results. Experimental results show that our scheme significantly progressed across multiple datasets, notably achieving over a 10% improvement on the QALD10 dataset compared to the best baseline and the fine-tuned state-of-the-art (SOTA) work. Building on this success, this study hopes to offer a valuable reference for future research in the fusion of KG and LLMs, thereby enhancing LLMs' proficiency in solving complex issues.
Read more6/13/2024
0
Debate on Graph: a Flexible and Reliable Reasoning Framework for Large Language Models
Jie Ma, Zhitao Gao, Qi Chai, Wangchun Sun, Pinghui Wang, Hongbin Pei, Jing Tao, Lingyun Song, Jun Liu, Chen Zhang, Lizhen Cui
Large Language Models (LLMs) may suffer from hallucinations in real-world applications due to the lack of relevant knowledge. In contrast, knowledge graphs encompass extensive, multi-relational structures that store a vast array of symbolic facts. Consequently, integrating LLMs with knowledge graphs has been extensively explored, with Knowledge Graph Question Answering (KGQA) serving as a critical touchstone for the integration. This task requires LLMs to answer natural language questions by retrieving relevant triples from knowledge graphs. However, existing methods face two significant challenges: textit{excessively long reasoning paths distracting from the answer generation}, and textit{false-positive relations hindering the path refinement}. In this paper, we propose an iterative interactive KGQA framework that leverages the interactive learning capabilities of LLMs to perform reasoning and Debating over Graphs (DoG). Specifically, DoG employs a subgraph-focusing mechanism, allowing LLMs to perform answer trying after each reasoning step, thereby mitigating the impact of lengthy reasoning paths. On the other hand, DoG utilizes a multi-role debate team to gradually simplify complex questions, reducing the influence of false-positive relations. This debate mechanism ensures the reliability of the reasoning process. Experimental results on five public datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and superiority of our architecture. Notably, DoG outperforms the state-of-the-art method ToG by 23.7% and 9.1% in accuracy on WebQuestions and GrailQA, respectively. Furthermore, the integration experiments with various LLMs on the mentioned datasets highlight the flexibility of DoG. Code is available at url{https://github.com/reml-group/DoG}.
Read more9/6/2024
0
CuriousLLM: Elevating Multi-Document QA with Reasoning-Infused Knowledge Graph Prompting
Zukang Yang, Zixuan Zhu
In the field of Question Answering (QA), unifying large language models (LLMs) with external databases has shown great success. However, these methods often fall short in providing the advanced reasoning needed for complex QA tasks. To address these issues, we improve over a novel approach called Knowledge Graph Prompting (KGP), which combines knowledge graphs with a LLM-based agent to improve reasoning and search accuracy. Nevertheless, the original KGP framework necessitates costly fine-tuning with large datasets yet still suffers from LLM hallucination. Therefore, we propose a reasoning-infused LLM agent to enhance this framework. This agent mimics human curiosity to ask follow-up questions to more efficiently navigate the search. This simple modification significantly boosts the LLM performance in QA tasks without the high costs and latency associated with the initial KGP framework. Our ultimate goal is to further develop this approach, leading to more accurate, faster, and cost-effective solutions in the QA domain.
Read more4/16/2024