Exploring Human-AI Collaboration in Agile: Customised LLM Meeting Assistants

Overview

• This study investigates the integration of AI assistants in Agile software development meetings, specifically the Daily Scrum and a feature refinement meeting.
• It explores the critical factors for successful AI integration and the impact on team collaboration dynamics.
• The paper provides lessons learned from implementing AI in an industrial context and offers a checklist to assess a team's readiness for AI integration.

Plain English Explanation

This research paper looks at how AI assistants can be used in certain Agile software development meetings. Agile is a way of developing software that focuses on collaboration, flexibility, and quick iterations. The two meetings studied were the Daily Scrum, where the team discusses their progress, and a feature refinement meeting, where the team plans out upcoming features.

The researchers wanted to understand what makes it successful to use AI in these meetings, and how it affects the way the team works together. They tried using AI assistants in these meetings at a company and observed what happened.

The key takeaways from this study are a list of important factors for successfully integrating AI, as well as some lessons learned from doing it in a real-world setting. The researchers also provide a checklist that companies and teams can use to see if they're ready to start using AI in their Agile meetings.

The goal is to give guidance to others who want to try using AI assistants to support their Agile software development processes. The researchers hope this will help teams collaborate better and be more efficient.

Technical Explanation

This action research study investigated the integration of AI assistants in two specific Agile software development meetings: the Daily Scrum and a feature refinement meeting, which is part of the company's in-house Scaled Agile framework.

The researchers collected data through observations, interviews, and document analysis to understand the critical drivers of success for AI integration, as well as the impact on team collaboration dynamics. They used an iterative process to refine the AI assistant's capabilities based on feedback from the teams.

The key insights from the study include a set of lessons learned from implementing AI in an industrial context, as well as a readiness assessment checklist for companies and teams to evaluate their preparedness for AI integration. The researchers highlight factors such as trust, task anticipation, and the ability to adapt the AI assistant as critical for successful AI-human collaboration in Agile settings.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides valuable insights into the practical considerations for integrating AI assistants in Agile software development processes. The researchers acknowledge the limitations of their action research approach, which may limit the generalizability of the findings. Additionally, the study was conducted in a single industrial context, and further research would be needed to understand the broader applicability of the lessons learned.

While the paper highlights several critical success factors, it would be helpful to have a more in-depth discussion of potential challenges or risks associated with AI integration, such as issues around data privacy, transparency, or the impact on team dynamics. A more critical examination of these aspects could provide a more balanced perspective.

Overall, the paper offers a useful roadmap for teams and organizations interested in exploring the integration of AI assistants in their Agile practices. However, readers should consider the context-specific nature of the findings and engage in further research and testing to determine the best approach for their own unique circumstances.

Conclusion

This action research study provides valuable insights into the integration of AI assistants in Agile software development meetings, specifically the Daily Scrum and feature refinement meetings. The researchers identify critical success factors, such as trust, task anticipation, and adaptability, and offer a practical checklist to help teams assess their readiness for AI integration.

The lessons learned from this industrial case study can serve as a guide for other organizations and teams interested in leveraging AI to support their Agile practices. By understanding the potential benefits and challenges of AI integration, teams can make more informed decisions and develop effective strategies to enhance their collaboration and productivity.

Overall, this paper contributes to the growing body of research on the intersection of AI and Agile software development, and offers a blueprint for successfully incorporating AI assistants into these collaborative workflows.