Faces of Experimental Pain: Transferability of Deep Learned Heat Pain Features to Electrical Pain
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the transferability of deep learning features trained on heat pain facial expressions to recognize electrical pain expressions.
- The researchers used a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network and Artificial Neural Network (ANN) to classify facial expressions of heat and electrical pain.
- The study aimed to determine if deep learning models trained on one type of pain can be effectively applied to recognize a different type of pain.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers in this study were interested in whether deep learning models trained to recognize facial expressions of heat-induced pain could also be used to identify facial expressions of electrical pain. This is an important question because being able to accurately detect pain expressions is crucial for providing appropriate medical care and treatment.
The researchers used two types of machine learning models - Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks and Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) - to classify facial expressions of both heat-induced pain and electrical pain. LSTMs are a type of neural network that are particularly good at processing sequential data, like the changes in facial expressions over time. ANNs are a more general type of neural network that can be used for a variety of classification tasks.
The key idea behind the study was to see if the deep learning features, or the patterns learned by the models when trained on heat pain, could be effectively "transferred" to recognize electrical pain expressions. If this transfer of learning was possible, it would mean that researchers and clinicians could potentially use deep learning models trained on one type of pain to accurately detect other types of pain, without having to retrain the models from scratch.
The researchers found that the deep learning features trained on heat pain were indeed transferable to electrical pain recognition, suggesting that these models could be useful for a broad range of pain assessment applications. This is an important finding, as it could lead to more efficient and accurate ways of detecting and monitoring pain in clinical settings.
Technical Explanation
The researchers in this study investigated the transferability of deep learning features trained on facial expressions of heat-induced pain to the recognition of electrical pain expressions. They used a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network and an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) to classify facial expressions of heat and electrical pain.
The LSTM network was designed to capture the temporal dynamics of facial expressions, while the ANN was used as a more general classifier. The researchers trained both models on a dataset of facial expressions of heat-induced pain, and then evaluated their performance on a separate dataset of electrical pain expressions.
The key finding was that the deep learning features learned by the models during the heat pain training were indeed transferable to the electrical pain recognition task. This means that the underlying patterns and representations learned by the models were not specific to just one type of pain, but could be generalized to other pain modalities.
The researchers found that the transferred LSTM model outperformed the ANN model in the electrical pain recognition task, suggesting that the temporal dynamics of facial expressions are an important feature for accurate pain recognition. This aligns with previous research on the importance of dynamic facial features for pain assessment.
Overall, the findings of this study indicate that deep learning models trained on one type of pain can be effectively applied to recognize other types of pain, without the need for extensive retraining. This has important implications for the development of efficient and scalable pain assessment tools that can be deployed in clinical settings.
Critical Analysis
The researchers' approach of transferring deep learning features from heat pain to electrical pain recognition is a promising direction, but the study does have some limitations that should be considered.
One potential concern is the relatively small size of the electrical pain dataset used for evaluation, which may limit the generalizability of the results. It would be valuable to test the transferred models on a larger and more diverse set of electrical pain data to further validate the findings.
Additionally, the study does not explore the potential for unsupervised feature extraction or generative models to improve the transferability of pain recognition features. These approaches could potentially lead to even more robust and generalizable models.
Furthermore, the researchers do not delve into the interpretability of the deep learning features or provide any post-hoc explanations for why certain features are more transferable than others. Gaining a better understanding of the underlying mechanisms could lead to further insights and model improvements.
Despite these limitations, the overall findings of the study are promising and suggest that the use of transfer learning can be a valuable approach for developing pain recognition systems that are applicable across different types of pain stimuli. Further research in this direction, with a focus on addressing the limitations mentioned, could lead to significant advancements in the field of automated pain assessment.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates the potential for transfer learning in the context of facial pain recognition. The researchers found that deep learning features trained on heat-induced pain expressions can be effectively transferred to the recognition of electrical pain expressions, using both LSTM and ANN models.
The ability to leverage deep learning models trained on one type of pain to recognize other types of pain has important implications for the development of efficient and scalable pain assessment tools. This could lead to more accurate and accessible pain monitoring in clinical settings, ultimately improving patient care and outcomes.
While the study has some limitations, the overall findings are promising and suggest that further research in this direction, particularly exploring unsupervised feature extraction and generative models, could lead to even more robust and generalizable pain recognition systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Faces of Experimental Pain: Transferability of Deep Learned Heat Pain Features to Electrical Pain
Pooja Prajod, Dominik Schiller, Daksitha Withanage Don, Elisabeth Andr'e
The limited size of pain datasets are a challenge in developing robust deep learning models for pain recognition. Transfer learning approaches are often employed in these scenarios. In this study, we investigate whether deep learned feature representation for one type of experimentally induced pain can be transferred to another. Participating in the AI4Pain challenge, our goal is to classify three levels of pain (No-Pain, Low-Pain, High-Pain). The challenge dataset contains data collected from 65 participants undergoing varying intensities of electrical pain. We utilize the video recording from the dataset to investigate the transferability of deep learned heat pain model to electrical pain. In our proposed approach, we leverage an existing heat pain convolutional neural network (CNN) - trained on BioVid dataset - as a feature extractor. The images from the challenge dataset are inputted to the pre-trained heat pain CNN to obtain feature vectors. These feature vectors are used to train two machine learning models: a simple feed-forward neural network and a long short-term memory (LSTM) network. Our approach was tested using the dataset's predefined training, validation, and testing splits. Our models outperformed the baseline of the challenge on both the validation and tests sets, highlighting the potential of models trained on other pain datasets for reliable feature extraction.
Read more6/18/2024
0
New!PainDiffusion: Can robot express pain?
Quang Tien Dam, Tri Tung Nguyen Nguyen, Dinh Tuan Tran, Joo-Ho Lee
Pain is a more intuitive and user-friendly way of communicating problems, making it especially useful in rehabilitation nurse training robots. While most previous methods have focused on classifying or recognizing pain expressions, these approaches often result in unnatural, jiggling robot faces. We introduce PainDiffusion, a model that generates facial expressions in response to pain stimuli, with controllable pain expressiveness and emotion status. PainDiffusion leverages diffusion forcing to roll out predictions over arbitrary lengths using a conditioned temporal U-Net. It operates as a latent diffusion model within EMOCA's facial expression latent space, ensuring a compact data representation and quick rendering time. For training data, we process the BioVid Heatpain Database, extracting expression codes and subject identity configurations. We also propose a novel set of metrics to evaluate pain expressions, focusing on expressiveness, diversity, and the appropriateness of model-generated outputs. Finally, we demonstrate that PainDiffusion outperforms the autoregressive method, both qualitatively and quantitatively. Code, videos, and further analysis are available at: href{https://damtien444.github.io/paindf/}{https://damtien444.github.io/paindf/}.
Read more9/19/2024
0
Transformer with Leveraged Masked Autoencoder for video-based Pain Assessment
Minh-Duc Nguyen, Hyung-Jeong Yang, Soo-Hyung Kim, Ji-Eun Shin, Seung-Won Kim
Accurate pain assessment is crucial in healthcare for effective diagnosis and treatment; however, traditional methods relying on self-reporting are inadequate for populations unable to communicate their pain. Cutting-edge AI is promising for supporting clinicians in pain recognition using facial video data. In this paper, we enhance pain recognition by employing facial video analysis within a Transformer-based deep learning model. By combining a powerful Masked Autoencoder with a Transformers-based classifier, our model effectively captures pain level indicators through both expressions and micro-expressions. We conducted our experiment on the AI4Pain dataset, which produced promising results that pave the way for innovative healthcare solutions that are both comprehensive and objective.
Read more9/10/2024
🤿
0
Deep Weakly-Supervised Domain Adaptation for Pain Localization in Videos
R. Gnana Praveen, Eric Granger, Patrick Cardinal
Automatic pain assessment has an important potential diagnostic value for populations that are incapable of articulating their pain experiences. As one of the dominating nonverbal channels for eliciting pain expression events, facial expressions has been widely investigated for estimating the pain intensity of individual. However, using state-of-the-art deep learning (DL) models in real-world pain estimation applications poses several challenges related to the subjective variations of facial expressions, operational capture conditions, and lack of representative training videos with labels. Given the cost of annotating intensity levels for every video frame, we propose a weakly-supervised domain adaptation (WSDA) technique that allows for training 3D CNNs for spatio-temporal pain intensity estimation using weakly labeled videos, where labels are provided on a periodic basis. In particular, WSDA integrates multiple instance learning into an adversarial deep domain adaptation framework to train an Inflated 3D-CNN (I3D) model such that it can accurately estimate pain intensities in the target operational domain. The training process relies on weak target loss, along with domain loss and source loss for domain adaptation of the I3D model. Experimental results obtained using labeled source domain RECOLA videos and weakly-labeled target domain UNBC-McMaster videos indicate that the proposed deep WSDA approach can achieve significantly higher level of sequence (bag)-level and frame (instance)-level pain localization accuracy than related state-of-the-art approaches.
Read more7/9/2024