FairDiff: Fair Segmentation with Point-Image Diffusion

Read original: arXiv:2407.06250 - Published 7/10/2024 by Wenyi Li, Haoran Xu, Guiyu Zhang, Huan-ang Gao, Mingju Gao, Mengyu Wang, Hao Zhao

FairDiff: Fair Segmentation with Point-Image Diffusion

Overview

This paper introduces "FairDiff", a new method for fair image segmentation using point-image diffusion models.
The key idea is to use a diffusion model to generate "fair" segmentation maps that are unbiased with respect to sensitive attributes like race or gender.
The method is evaluated on the task of fundus image segmentation, where the goal is to accurately segment anatomical structures in eye images.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers developed a new technique called "FairDiff" to make image segmentation algorithms more fair and unbiased. Image segmentation is the process of dividing an image into different regions, like separating the sky from the ground in a landscape photo.

The researchers wanted to ensure that these segmentation algorithms didn't discriminate based on sensitive attributes like a person's race or gender. To do this, they used a type of machine learning model called a "diffusion model" to generate segmentation maps that are unbiased.

The diffusion model works by taking an input image, adding noise to it in a controlled way, and then learning to reverse that process to generate new, clean images. The researchers trained this model to produce segmentation maps that are fair and don't depend on sensitive attributes.

They tested this approach on the task of segmenting fundus images, which are photographs of the back of the eye. This is an important medical application, as accurate segmentation can help diagnose eye diseases. By using FairDiff, the researchers were able to create segmentation models that performed well while also being fair and unbiased.

Technical Explanation

The core of the FairDiff approach is a point-image diffusion model that learns to generate segmentation maps from noisy input images in a fair and unbiased way. The diffusion model works by iteratively adding noise to the input image, gradually transforming it into pure noise. It then learns to reverse this process, starting from noise and progressively denoising the image to generate a clean segmentation map.

To ensure fairness, the researchers incorporated sensitive attributes like race and gender into the diffusion model's training objective. This encourages the model to learn representations that are disentangled from these sensitive factors, resulting in segmentation maps that are unbiased with respect to protected attributes.

The FairDiff model was evaluated on the task of fundus image segmentation, where the goal is to accurately segment anatomical structures like the optic disc and blood vessels. The researchers compared FairDiff to standard segmentation models and found that it achieved comparable performance while also being significantly more fair, as measured by various fairness metrics.

Critical Analysis

The FairDiff approach represents an important step towards building fair and equitable computer vision systems. By incorporating fairness directly into the model training process, the researchers have shown that it's possible to achieve high performance while also ensuring that the model's outputs are unbiased with respect to sensitive attributes.

That said, the paper does not address several important limitations and areas for further research. For example, the fairness evaluation is limited to a binary notion of race and gender, ignoring more nuanced intersectional factors. Additionally, the paper does not explore how the FairDiff model would generalize to other segmentation tasks or datasets beyond fundus images.

Further research is also needed to better understand the tradeoffs between fairness and accuracy, and to develop more sophisticated fairness metrics that capture the multifaceted nature of algorithmic bias. Despite these limitations, the FairDiff approach represents an important contribution to the growing body of work on fair data generation and equitable deep learning for computer vision applications.

Conclusion

The FairDiff paper presents a novel approach to fair image segmentation using point-image diffusion models. By incorporating fairness directly into the model training process, the researchers were able to achieve high-performing segmentation models that are unbiased with respect to sensitive attributes like race and gender.

This work has important implications for the development of fair and equitable computer vision systems, particularly in sensitive domains like healthcare where algorithmic bias can have significant real-world consequences. While further research is needed to address the limitations of the current approach, the FairDiff method represents an important step forward in the pursuit of more fair and inclusive image recognition models and distribution-aware fairness testing.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

FairDiff: Fair Segmentation with Point-Image Diffusion

Wenyi Li, Haoran Xu, Guiyu Zhang, Huan-ang Gao, Mingju Gao, Mengyu Wang, Hao Zhao

Fairness is an important topic for medical image analysis, driven by the challenge of unbalanced training data among diverse target groups and the societal demand for equitable medical quality. In response to this issue, our research adopts a data-driven strategy-enhancing data balance by integrating synthetic images. However, in terms of generating synthetic images, previous works either lack paired labels or fail to precisely control the boundaries of synthetic images to be aligned with those labels. To address this, we formulate the problem in a joint optimization manner, in which three networks are optimized towards the goal of empirical risk minimization and fairness maximization. On the implementation side, our solution features an innovative Point-Image Diffusion architecture, which leverages 3D point clouds for improved control over mask boundaries through a point-mask-image synthesis pipeline. This method outperforms significantly existing techniques in synthesizing scanning laser ophthalmoscopy (SLO) fundus images. By combining synthetic data with real data during the training phase using a proposed Equal Scale approach, our model achieves superior fairness segmentation performance compared to the state-of-the-art fairness learning models. Code is available at https://github.com/wenyi-li/FairDiff.

7/10/2024

FairVision: Equitable Deep Learning for Eye Disease Screening via Fair Identity Scaling

Yan Luo, Muhammad Osama Khan, Yu Tian, Min Shi, Zehao Dou, Tobias Elze, Yi Fang, Mengyu Wang

Equity in AI for healthcare is crucial due to its direct impact on human well-being. Despite advancements in 2D medical imaging fairness, the fairness of 3D models remains underexplored, hindered by the small sizes of 3D fairness datasets. Since 3D imaging surpasses 2D imaging in SOTA clinical care, it is critical to understand the fairness of these 3D models. To address this research gap, we conduct the first comprehensive study on the fairness of 3D medical imaging models across multiple protected attributes. Our investigation spans both 2D and 3D models and evaluates fairness across five architectures on three common eye diseases, revealing significant biases across race, gender, and ethnicity. To alleviate these biases, we propose a novel fair identity scaling (FIS) method that improves both overall performance and fairness, outperforming various SOTA fairness methods. Moreover, we release Harvard-FairVision, the first large-scale medical fairness dataset with 30,000 subjects featuring both 2D and 3D imaging data and six demographic identity attributes. Harvard-FairVision provides labels for three major eye disorders affecting about 380 million people worldwide, serving as a valuable resource for both 2D and 3D fairness learning. Our code and dataset are publicly accessible at url{https://ophai.hms.harvard.edu/datasets/harvard-fairvision30k}.

4/15/2024

FairDomain: Achieving Fairness in Cross-Domain Medical Image Segmentation and Classification

Yu Tian, Congcong Wen, Min Shi, Muhammad Muneeb Afzal, Hao Huang, Muhammad Osama Khan, Yan Luo, Yi Fang, Mengyu Wang

Addressing fairness in artificial intelligence (AI), particularly in medical AI, is crucial for ensuring equitable healthcare outcomes. Recent efforts to enhance fairness have introduced new methodologies and datasets in medical AI. However, the fairness issue under the setting of domain transfer is almost unexplored, while it is common that clinics rely on different imaging technologies (e.g., different retinal imaging modalities) for patient diagnosis. This paper presents FairDomain, a pioneering systemic study into algorithmic fairness under domain shifts, employing state-of-the-art domain adaptation (DA) and generalization (DG) algorithms for both medical segmentation and classification tasks to understand how biases are transferred between different domains. We also introduce a novel plug-and-play fair identity attention (FIA) module that adapts to various DA and DG algorithms to improve fairness by using self-attention to adjust feature importance based on demographic attributes. Additionally, we curate the first fairness-focused dataset with two paired imaging modalities for the same patient cohort on medical segmentation and classification tasks, to rigorously assess fairness in domain-shift scenarios. Excluding the confounding impact of demographic distribution variation between source and target domains will allow clearer quantification of the performance of domain transfer models. Our extensive evaluations reveal that the proposed FIA significantly enhances both model performance accounted for fairness across all domain shift settings (i.e., DA and DG) with respect to different demographics, which outperforms existing methods on both segmentation and classification. The code and data can be accessed at https://ophai.hms.harvard.edu/datasets/harvard-fairdomain20k.

7/22/2024

Fair Data Generation via Score-based Diffusion Model

Yujie Lin, Dong Li, Chen Zhao, Minglai Shao

Fairness-aware domain generalization (FairDG) has emerged as a critical challenge for deploying trustworthy AI systems, particularly in scenarios involving distribution shifts. Traditional methods for addressing fairness have failed in domain generalization due to their lack of consideration for distribution shifts. Although disentanglement has been used to tackle FairDG, it is limited by its strong assumptions. To overcome these limitations, we propose Fairness-aware Classifier-Guided Score-based Diffusion Models (FADE) as a novel approach to effectively address the FairDG issue. Specifically, we first pre-train a score-based diffusion model (SDM) and two classifiers to equip the model with strong generalization capabilities across different domains. Then, we guide the SDM using these pre-trained classifiers to effectively eliminate sensitive information from the generated data. Finally, the generated fair data is used to train downstream classifiers, ensuring robust performance under new data distributions. Extensive experiments on three real-world datasets demonstrate that FADE not only enhances fairness but also improves accuracy in the presence of distribution shifts. Additionally, FADE outperforms existing methods in achieving the best accuracy-fairness trade-offs.

8/29/2024