Fast post-process Bayesian inference with Variational Sparse Bayesian Quadrature

Overview

• Researchers propose a new framework called "post-process Bayesian inference" to quickly approximate Bayesian posterior distributions using existing model evaluations.
• They introduce a specific method called "Variational Sparse Bayesian Quadrature" (VSBQ) that builds a sparse Gaussian process surrogate model of the log posterior and then uses variational inference to approximate the posterior.
• The method allows for fast posterior inference without requiring any additional model evaluations, by reusing optimization traces that may already be available.
• Experiments show VSBQ can produce high-quality posterior approximations on challenging synthetic and real-world problems from computational neuroscience.

Plain English Explanation

In many real-world applications, researchers may have access to a large number of model evaluations from previous optimization runs. However, traditional Bayesian inference techniques often don't take advantage of this existing information. The researchers propose a new framework called "post-process Bayesian inference" to quickly approximate Bayesian posterior distributions using these pre-existing model evaluations.

Within this framework, they introduce a specific method called "Variational Sparse Bayesian Quadrature" (VSBQ). VSBQ works by first building a sparse Gaussian process surrogate model of the log posterior density function, using the available model evaluations. It then leverages sparse Gaussian process Bayesian quadrature combined with variational inference to efficiently approximate the posterior distribution over the surrogate model, without requiring any additional model calls.

The key advantage of VSBQ is that it can produce high-quality posterior approximations by simply post-processing existing optimization traces, rather than having to run the model from scratch. This can save a significant amount of computational time, especially for models with expensive evaluations. The researchers validate their method on challenging synthetic scenarios as well as real-world applications from computational neuroscience, demonstrating its effectiveness.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a framework called "post-process Bayesian inference" to quickly approximate Bayesian posterior distributions using a collection of pre-existing model evaluations, such as from maximum-a-posteriori (MAP) optimization runs. Traditional approximate inference techniques often do not take full advantage of this available information.

Within this framework, the authors introduce a specific method called "Variational Sparse Bayesian Quadrature" (VSBQ). VSBQ first builds a sparse Gaussian process (GP) surrogate model of the log posterior density function, using the existing target density evaluations. It then leverages sparse GP Bayesian quadrature combined with variational inference to efficiently approximate the posterior distribution over the surrogate model.

The key steps of VSBQ are:

1. Construct a sparse GP model of the log posterior using the existing target density evaluations.
2. Utilize sparse GP Bayesian quadrature to compute the posterior moments over the surrogate model.
3. Apply variational inference to obtain a fast approximate posterior distribution.

The authors validate VSBQ on challenging synthetic scenarios as well as real-world applications from computational neuroscience, such as Bayesian inference for spiking neural network models. The experiments demonstrate that VSBQ can build high-quality posterior approximations by post-processing existing optimization traces, without requiring any additional model evaluations.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising framework and method for efficiently approximating Bayesian posteriors using pre-existing model evaluations. One potential limitation is that the quality of the VSBQ posterior approximation may depend on the quality and coverage of the available target density evaluations. If the existing evaluations do not sufficiently explore the parameter space, the resulting GP surrogate model may be inaccurate, leading to poor posterior approximations.

Additionally, while VSBQ avoids the need for additional model calls, it still requires constructing the sparse GP surrogate model and performing variational inference, which may incur significant computational overhead for high-dimensional problems. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that further research is needed to improve the scalability of the method.

Another area for potential exploration is the application of VSBQ to settings with heterogeneous data sources or models with non-Gaussian likelihoods. The current paper focuses on black-box and potentially noisy likelihoods, but extending the method to handle more complex scenarios could broaden its applicability.

Overall, the "post-process Bayesian inference" framework and the VSBQ method represent an interesting and valuable contribution to the field of approximate Bayesian inference. The paper provides a solid foundation for further research and development in this direction.

Conclusion

The researchers propose a new framework called "post-process Bayesian inference" to quickly approximate Bayesian posterior distributions using existing model evaluations. Within this framework, they introduce a specific method called "Variational Sparse Bayesian Quadrature" (VSBQ) that builds a sparse Gaussian process surrogate model of the log posterior and then uses variational inference to approximate the posterior.

VSBQ allows for fast posterior inference without requiring any additional model evaluations, by reusing optimization traces that may already be available. The experiments show that VSBQ can produce high-quality posterior approximations on challenging synthetic and real-world problems from computational neuroscience, demonstrating the potential of this approach to save significant computational time, especially for models with expensive evaluations.

While the method has some limitations and areas for further research, the "post-process Bayesian inference" framework and the VSBQ technique represent an important contribution to the field of approximate Bayesian inference, with promising implications for a wide range of applications.