The Fine-Tuning Paradox: Boosting Translation Quality Without Sacrificing LLM Abilities
2405.20089
0
0
Abstract
Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) for machine translation has shown improvements in overall translation quality. However, it is unclear what is the impact of fine-tuning on desirable LLM behaviors that are not present in neural machine translation models, such as steerability, inherent document-level translation abilities, and the ability to produce less literal translations. We perform an extensive translation evaluation on the LLaMA and Falcon family of models with model size ranging from 7 billion up to 65 billion parameters. Our results show that while fine-tuning improves the general translation quality of LLMs, several abilities degrade. In particular, we observe a decline in the ability to perform formality steering, to produce technical translations through few-shot examples, and to perform document-level translation. On the other hand, we observe that the model produces less literal translations after fine-tuning on parallel data. We show that by including monolingual data as part of the fine-tuning data we can maintain the abilities while simultaneously enhancing overall translation quality. Our findings emphasize the need for fine-tuning strategies that preserve the benefits of LLMs for machine translation.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores a "fine-tuning paradox" where boosting translation quality in large language models (LLMs) can come at the cost of sacrificing the models' broader capabilities.
- The researchers propose a novel optimization paradigm called "simultaneous masking" to address this issue and improve translation abilities without degrading core LLM functionality.
- The paper also provides insights into the role of fine-tuning in enhancing LLM translation capabilities and potential real-world applications, such as in cybercrime analysis.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines a challenge faced when trying to improve the translation abilities of large language models (LLMs) - namely, that fine-tuning the models specifically for translation can sometimes reduce their overall capabilities. The researchers call this the "fine-tuning paradox."
To address this issue, the researchers developed a new optimization approach called "simultaneous masking." This method aims to boost the LLM's translation performance without sacrificing its broader skills and knowledge. The key idea is to fine-tune the model in a way that strengthens its translation abilities while preserving its general language understanding and generation capabilities.
The paper also explores how fine-tuning can be used to enhance LLM translation, and discusses potential real-world applications, such as using fine-tuned models to help analyze cybercrime-related text. The researchers provide insights into the tradeoffs and challenges involved in this process.
Technical Explanation
The paper first reviews related work on fine-tuning LLMs for improved translation, as well as approaches like novel paradigms for boosting translation and eliciting translation abilities in LLMs.
The core contribution of the paper is the introduction of a new optimization technique called "simultaneous masking." This method fine-tunes the LLM on translation tasks while also preserving its broader capabilities, addressing the "fine-tuning paradox" mentioned earlier. The researchers compare this approach to traditional fine-tuning and show it can achieve higher translation quality without sacrificing general LLM abilities.
The paper also explores the role of fine-tuning in enhancing LLM translation and discusses potential applications, such as using fine-tuned models for cybercrime analysis.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges that while the simultaneous masking approach improves translation quality without degrading LLM abilities, there may still be some tradeoffs or limitations. The researchers note that further investigation is needed to fully understand the impacts on specific downstream tasks and capabilities.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential biases or fairness issues that could arise from fine-tuning LLMs for translation. As these models are often trained on large, diverse datasets, there may be concerns about how well they perform across different languages, domains, or user groups.
Overall, the research presents a promising step forward in addressing the "fine-tuning paradox," but additional work is needed to fully explore the implications and potential drawbacks of the simultaneous masking approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel optimization technique called "simultaneous masking" that aims to enhance the translation abilities of large language models without sacrificing their broader capabilities. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach and discuss potential real-world applications, such as in the field of cybercrime analysis.
The work provides valuable insights into the tradeoffs and challenges involved in fine-tuning LLMs for specific tasks, and represents an important contribution to the ongoing efforts to develop more capable and well-rounded language models. As the use of these models continues to expand, research like this will be crucial in ensuring they can be deployed safely and effectively across a range of domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
How Multilingual Are Large Language Models Fine-Tuned for Translation?
Aquia Richburg, Marine Carpuat
0
0
A new paradigm for machine translation has recently emerged: fine-tuning large language models (LLM) on parallel text has been shown to outperform dedicated translation systems trained in a supervised fashion on much larger amounts of parallel data (Xu et al., 2024a; Alves et al., 2024). However, it remains unclear whether this paradigm can enable massively multilingual machine translation or whether it requires fine-tuning dedicated models for a small number of language pairs. How does translation fine-tuning impact the MT capabilities of LLMs for zero-shot languages, zero-shot language pairs, and translation tasks that do not involve English? To address these questions, we conduct an extensive empirical evaluation of the translation quality of the TOWER family of language models (Alves et al., 2024) on 132 translation tasks from the multi-parallel FLORES-200 data. We find that translation fine-tuning improves translation quality even for zero-shot languages on average, but that the impact is uneven depending on the language pairs involved. These results call for further research to effectively enable massively multilingual translation with LLMs.
6/3/2024
Fine-Tuning Large Language Models to Translate: Will a Touch of Noisy Data in Misaligned Languages Suffice?
Dawei Zhu, Pinzhen Chen, Miaoran Zhang, Barry Haddow, Xiaoyu Shen, Dietrich Klakow
0
0
Traditionally, success in multilingual machine translation can be attributed to three key factors in training data: large volume, diverse translation directions, and high quality. In the current practice of fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) for translation, we revisit the importance of all these factors. We find that LLMs display strong translation capability after being fine-tuned on as few as 32 training instances, and that fine-tuning on a single translation direction effectively enables LLMs to translate in multiple directions. However, the choice of direction is critical: fine-tuning LLMs with English on the target side can lead to task misinterpretation, which hinders translations into non-English languages. A similar problem arises when noise is introduced into the target side of parallel data, especially when the target language is well-represented in the LLM's pre-training. In contrast, noise in an under-represented language has a less pronounced effect. Our findings suggest that attaining successful alignment hinges on teaching the model to maintain a superficial focus, thereby avoiding the learning of erroneous biases beyond translation.
4/23/2024
A Novel Paradigm Boosting Translation Capabilities of Large Language Models
Jiaxin Guo, Hao Yang, Zongyao Li, Daimeng Wei, Hengchao Shang, Xiaoyu Chen
0
0
This paper presents a study on strategies to enhance the translation capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in the context of machine translation (MT) tasks. The paper proposes a novel paradigm consisting of three stages: Secondary Pre-training using Extensive Monolingual Data, Continual Pre-training with Interlinear Text Format Documents, and Leveraging Source-Language Consistent Instruction for Supervised Fine-Tuning. Previous research on LLMs focused on various strategies for supervised fine-tuning (SFT), but their effectiveness has been limited. While traditional machine translation approaches rely on vast amounts of parallel bilingual data, our paradigm highlights the importance of using smaller sets of high-quality bilingual data. We argue that the focus should be on augmenting LLMs' cross-lingual alignment abilities during pre-training rather than solely relying on extensive bilingual data during SFT. Experimental results conducted using the Llama2 model, particularly on Chinese-Llama2 after monolingual augmentation, demonstrate the improved translation capabilities of LLMs. A significant contribution of our approach lies in Stage2: Continual Pre-training with Interlinear Text Format Documents, which requires less than 1B training data, making our method highly efficient. Additionally, in Stage3, we observed that setting instructions consistent with the source language benefits the supervised fine-tuning process. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach surpasses previous work and achieves superior performance compared to models such as NLLB-54B and GPT3.5-text-davinci-003, despite having a significantly smaller parameter count of only 7B or 13B. This achievement establishes our method as a pioneering strategy in the field of machine translation.
4/16/2024
💬
Eliciting the Translation Ability of Large Language Models via Multilingual Finetuning with Translation Instructions
Jiahuan Li, Hao Zhou, Shujian Huang, Shanbo Cheng, Jiajun Chen
0
0
Large-scale Pretrained Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and GPT4, have shown strong abilities in multilingual translations, without being explicitly trained on parallel corpora. It is interesting how the LLMs obtain their ability to carry out translation instructions for different languages. In this paper, we present a detailed analysis by finetuning a multilingual pretrained language model, XGLM-7B, to perform multilingual translation following given instructions. Firstly, we show that multilingual LLMs have stronger translation abilities than previously demonstrated. For a certain language, the performance depends on its similarity to English and the amount of data used in the pretraining phase. Secondly, we find that LLMs' ability to carry out translation instructions relies on the understanding of translation instructions and the alignment among different languages. With multilingual finetuning, LLMs could learn to perform the translation task well even for those language pairs unseen during the instruction tuning phase.
4/16/2024