Finite Groundings for ASP with Functions: A Journey through Consistency
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the problem of finite groundings for Answer Set Programming (ASP) with functions, focusing on the consistency of the resulting grounded programs.
- The authors investigate the challenges and complexities involved in handling functions within the ASP framework, which is a declarative programming paradigm for solving complex problems.
- The paper presents a systematic approach to ensuring the consistency of ASP programs with functions, aiming to address the potential issues that can arise when incorporating functions into the ASP language.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a crucial aspect of Answer Set Programming (ASP), which is a way of solving complex problems by describing the problem in a declarative way rather than writing step-by-step instructions. ASP programs can include functions, which are like special instructions that can be used to calculate or transform data. However, incorporating functions into ASP can be tricky, as it can lead to inconsistencies in the final program.
The authors of this paper explore these consistency issues and propose a systematic approach to handling functions in ASP. They aim to ensure that the resulting ASP programs with functions are logically consistent and can be reliably used to solve real-world problems. The paper delves into the technical details of this challenge, but the key idea is to find a way to incorporate functions into ASP without introducing contradictions or logical errors into the program.
By addressing this issue, the researchers hope to make ASP with functions more robust and practical for a wider range of applications, such as link to cfgs-causality-constrained-counterfactual-explanations-using-goal, link to metric-temporal-equilibrium-logic-over-timed-traces, and link to correspondence-non-flat-assumption-based-argumentation-logic.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the problem of finite groundings for Answer Set Programming (ASP) with functions. ASP is a declarative programming paradigm that allows for the representation and solving of complex problems by describing the problem in terms of logical rules and constraints. The inclusion of functions in ASP programs can provide additional expressive power and flexibility, but it also introduces challenges in ensuring the consistency of the resulting grounded programs.
The authors present a systematic approach to handling functions within the ASP framework, with the goal of ensuring the consistency of the grounded programs. They explore various aspects of this challenge, including the different types of functions that can be used in ASP, the potential sources of inconsistency, and the strategies for addressing these issues.
The paper also discusses the relationship between ASP with functions and other related formalisms, such as link to program-synthesis-using-inductive-logic-programming-abstraction and link to novel-framework-systematic-propositional-formula-simplification-based, and explores the connections and differences between these approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and systematic exploration of the challenges involved in handling functions within the ASP framework. The authors have identified a critical issue that can arise when incorporating functions into ASP programs, and their proposed approach represents a significant step towards addressing this problem.
One potential limitation of the research is that it focuses primarily on the theoretical and technical aspects of the problem, without much discussion of the practical implications or real-world applications of the proposed techniques. It would be valuable to see how the authors' approach performs in the context of specific use cases or benchmarks, and how it compares to other methods for handling functions in ASP.
Additionally, the paper does not address some of the potential pitfalls or edge cases that may arise when dealing with functions in ASP. For example, the authors do not discuss how to handle functions that may produce inconsistent or undefined results, or how to deal with the potential combinatorial explosion of possible function applications.
Despite these minor limitations, the paper represents an important contribution to the field of Answer Set Programming and provides a solid foundation for further research and development in this area. The authors' systematic approach to ensuring the consistency of ASP programs with functions is a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working on complex problem-solving applications.
Conclusion
This paper explores the critical challenge of ensuring the consistency of Answer Set Programming (ASP) programs that incorporate functions. The authors present a systematic approach to handling functions within the ASP framework, with the goal of addressing the potential issues that can arise when combining these two powerful programming paradigms.
The research represents an important step forward in the field of ASP, as it paves the way for the wider adoption and application of this declarative programming technique in real-world problem-solving scenarios. By addressing the consistency challenges associated with functions in ASP, the authors have made a significant contribution to the advancement of this field, which has important implications for areas such as link to cfgs-causality-constrained-counterfactual-explanations-using-goal, link to metric-temporal-equilibrium-logic-over-timed-traces, and link to correspondence-non-flat-assumption-based-argumentation-logic.
The paper's technical depth and systematic approach provide a solid foundation for further research and development in this area, and the authors' insights into the challenges and complexities of handling functions in ASP will be valuable resources for researchers and practitioners working at the intersection of declarative programming and complex problem-solving.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Finite Groundings for ASP with Functions: A Journey through Consistency
Lukas Gerlach (TU Dresden), David Carral (LIRMM, CRISAM, UM, CNRS, BOREAL), Markus Hecher (MIT)
Answer set programming (ASP) is a logic programming formalism used in various areas of artificial intelligence like combinatorial problem solving and knowledge representation and reasoning. It is known that enhancing ASP with function symbols makes basic reasoning problems highly undecidable. However, even in simple cases, state of the art reasoners, specifically those relying on a ground-and-solve approach, fail to produce a result. Therefore, we reconsider consistency as a basic reasoning problem for ASP. We show reductions that give an intuition for the high level of undecidability. These insights allow for a more fine-grained analysis where we characterize ASP programs as frugal and non-proliferous. For such programs, we are not only able to semi-decide consistency but we also propose a grounding procedure that yields finite groundings on more ASP programs with the concept of forbidden facts.
Read more5/28/2024
🌿
0
Static Analysis of Logic Programs via Boolean Networks
Van-Giang Trinh, Belaid Benhamou
Answer Set Programming (ASP) is a declarative problem solving paradigm that can be used to encode a combinatorial problem as a logic program whose stable models correspond to the solutions of the considered problem. ASP has been widely applied to various domains in AI and beyond. The question What can be said about stable models of a logic program from its static information? has been investigated and proved useful in many circumstances. In this work, we dive into this direction more deeply by making the connection between a logic program and a Boolean network, which is a prominent modeling framework with applications to various areas. The proposed connection can bring the existing results in the rich history on static analysis of Boolean networks to explore and prove more theoretical results on ASP, making it become a unified and powerful tool to further study the static analysis of ASP. In particular, the newly obtained insights have the potential to benefit many problems in the field of ASP.
Read more7/15/2024
🤯
0
Quantifying over Optimum Answer Sets
Giuseppe Mazzotta, Francesco Ricca, Mirek Truszczynski
Answer Set Programming with Quantifiers (ASP(Q)) has been introduced to provide a natural extension of ASP modeling to problems in the polynomial hierarchy (PH). However, ASP(Q) lacks a method for encoding in an elegant and compact way problems requiring a polynomial number of calls to an oracle in $Sigma_n^p$ (that is, problems in $Delta_{n+1}^p$). Such problems include, in particular, optimization problems. In this paper we propose an extension of ASP(Q), in which component programs may contain weak constraints. Weak constraints can be used both for expressing local optimization within quantified component programs and for modeling global optimization criteria. We showcase the modeling capabilities of the new formalism through various application scenarios. Further, we study its computational properties obtaining complexity results and unveiling non-obvious characteristics of ASP(Q) programs with weak constraints.
Read more8/15/2024
💬
0
LLASP: Fine-tuning Large Language Models for Answer Set Programming
Erica Coppolillo, Francesco Calimeri, Giuseppe Manco, Simona Perri, Francesco Ricca
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased their potential in various natural language processing tasks, including code generation. However, while significant progress has been made in adapting LLMs to generate code for several imperative programming languages and tasks, there remains a notable gap in their application to declarative formalisms, such as Answer Set Programming (ASP). In this paper, we move a step towards exploring the capabilities of LLMs for ASP code generation. First, we perform a systematic evaluation of several state-of-the-art LLMs. Despite their power in terms of number of parameters, training data and computational resources, empirical results demonstrate inadequate performances in generating correct ASP programs. Therefore, we propose LLASP, a fine-tuned lightweight model specifically trained to encode fundamental ASP program patterns. To this aim, we create an ad-hoc dataset covering a wide variety of fundamental problem specifications that can be encoded in ASP. Our experiments demonstrate that the quality of ASP programs generated by LLASP is remarkable. This holds true not only when compared to the non-fine-tuned counterpart but also when compared to the majority of eager LLM candidates, particularly from a semantic perspective. All the code and data used to perform the experiments are publicly available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/LLASP-D86C/.
Read more7/29/2024