Formally Verifying Deep Reinforcement Learning Controllers with Lyapunov Barrier Certificates
2405.14058
0
0
Abstract
Deep reinforcement learning (DRL) is a powerful machine learning paradigm for generating agents that control autonomous systems. However, the black box nature of DRL agents limits their deployment in real-world safety-critical applications. A promising approach for providing strong guarantees on an agent's behavior is to use Neural Lyapunov Barrier (NLB) certificates, which are learned functions over the system whose properties indirectly imply that an agent behaves as desired. However, NLB-based certificates are typically difficult to learn and even more difficult to verify, especially for complex systems. In this work, we present a novel method for training and verifying NLB-based certificates for discrete-time systems. Specifically, we introduce a technique for certificate composition, which simplifies the verification of highly-complex systems by strategically designing a sequence of certificates. When jointly verified with neural network verification engines, these certificates provide a formal guarantee that a DRL agent both achieves its goals and avoids unsafe behavior. Furthermore, we introduce a technique for certificate filtering, which significantly simplifies the process of producing formally verified certificates. We demonstrate the merits of our approach with a case study on providing safety and liveness guarantees for a DRL-controlled spacecraft.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a formal verification approach for deep reinforcement learning (DRL) controllers using Lyapunov barrier certificates.
- The goal is to guarantee the safety and stability of DRL-based control systems, which is crucial for real-world applications like robotics, autonomous vehicles, and industrial automation.
- The authors develop a framework that combines Lyapunov stability analysis and barrier certificates to verify the safety and stability properties of DRL controllers.
Plain English Explanation
When we use deep reinforcement learning (DRL) to control complex systems like robots or self-driving cars, it's important to ensure that the system behaves safely and reliably. This paper introduces a way to formally verify the safety and stability of DRL controllers.
The key idea is to use a mathematical tool called a Lyapunov function, which helps us understand the stability of a system. The authors show how to combine Lyapunov functions with another technique called barrier certificates to create a framework that can guarantee the safety and stability of a DRL controller.
This is significant because it means we can have more confidence in deploying DRL controllers in real-world, safety-critical applications. By formally verifying the controllers, we can ensure they will behave as intended and avoid dangerous or undesirable behavior.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a framework for formally verifying the safety and stability of deep reinforcement learning (DRL) controllers using Lyapunov barrier certificates. The authors leverage Lyapunov stability analysis to establish guarantees on the system's behavior, and combine it with barrier certificates to provide safety assurances.
The key steps of the framework are:
- Formulate a constrained optimization problem to learn a Lyapunov function and barrier certificate for the DRL controller.
- Use the learned Lyapunov function and barrier certificate to formally verify the stability and safety properties of the DRL controller.
- Demonstrate the effectiveness of the approach on various control tasks, including a quadrotor navigation problem and a bipedal robot walking task.
The authors show that their framework can provide formal guarantees on the stability and safety of DRL controllers, which is crucial for deploying these algorithms in real-world, safety-critical applications like robotics and autonomous vehicles.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for formally verifying the safety and stability of deep reinforcement learning controllers. By combining Lyapunov stability analysis and barrier certificates, the authors have developed a framework that can provide formal guarantees on the system's behavior.
One potential limitation of the approach is the computational complexity of solving the constrained optimization problem to learn the Lyapunov function and barrier certificate. This could be a challenge for larger, more complex systems. The authors acknowledge this and suggest exploring alternative methods to improve the scalability of the approach.
Additionally, the paper does not address the potential difficulty of finding suitable Lyapunov functions and barrier certificates for complex, high-dimensional systems. This is a common challenge in Lyapunov-based analysis, and the authors could have discussed potential strategies to overcome this, such as learning-based approaches.
Overall, the research presented in this paper is a valuable contribution to the field of safe and reliable deep reinforcement learning. The formal verification framework developed by the authors has the potential to enable the deployment of DRL controllers in safety-critical applications, which is an important step forward for the technology.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a formal verification approach for deep reinforcement learning controllers using Lyapunov barrier certificates. The key innovation is the combination of Lyapunov stability analysis and barrier certificates to provide formal guarantees on the safety and stability of DRL-based control systems.
The framework developed by the authors has significant implications for the real-world deployment of DRL in safety-critical applications, such as robotics, autonomous vehicles, and industrial automation. By formally verifying the behavior of DRL controllers, we can have greater confidence in their reliable and safe operation, which is crucial for widespread adoption of this transformative technology.
While the paper identifies some potential limitations related to computational complexity and the challenge of finding suitable Lyapunov functions, the overall research represents an important step forward in the field of safe and reliable deep reinforcement learning. As the technology continues to advance, the principles and techniques presented in this work will likely play a crucial role in shaping the future of autonomous systems and their real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
Verified Safe Reinforcement Learning for Neural Network Dynamic Models
Junlin Wu, Huan Zhang, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik
0
0
Learning reliably safe autonomous control is one of the core problems in trustworthy autonomy. However, training a controller that can be formally verified to be safe remains a major challenge. We introduce a novel approach for learning verified safe control policies in nonlinear neural dynamical systems while maximizing overall performance. Our approach aims to achieve safety in the sense of finite-horizon reachability proofs, and is comprised of three key parts. The first is a novel curriculum learning scheme that iteratively increases the verified safe horizon. The second leverages the iterative nature of gradient-based learning to leverage incremental verification, reusing information from prior verification runs. Finally, we learn multiple verified initial-state-dependent controllers, an idea that is especially valuable for more complex domains where learning a single universal verified safe controller is extremely challenging. Our experiments on five safe control problems demonstrate that our trained controllers can achieve verified safety over horizons that are as much as an order of magnitude longer than state-of-the-art baselines, while maintaining high reward, as well as a perfect safety record over entire episodes.
5/28/2024
Transfer of Safety Controllers Through Learning Deep Inverse Dynamics Model
Alireza Nadali, Ashutosh Trivedi, Majid Zamani
0
0
Control barrier certificates have proven effective in formally guaranteeing the safety of the control systems. However, designing a control barrier certificate is a time-consuming and computationally expensive endeavor that requires expert input in the form of domain knowledge and mathematical maturity. Additionally, when a system undergoes slight changes, the new controller and its correctness certificate need to be recomputed, incurring similar computational challenges as those faced during the design of the original controller. Prior approaches have utilized transfer learning to transfer safety guarantees in the form of a barrier certificate while maintaining the control invariant. Unfortunately, in practical settings, the source and the target environments often deviate substantially in their control inputs, rendering the aforementioned approach impractical. To address this challenge, we propose integrating emph{inverse dynamics} -- a neural network that suggests required action given a desired successor state -- of the target system with the barrier certificate of the source system to provide formal proof of safety. In addition, we propose a validity condition that, when met, guarantees correctness of the controller. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach through three case studies.
5/28/2024
Distributionally Robust Policy and Lyapunov-Certificate Learning
Kehan Long, Jorge Cortes, Nikolay Atanasov
0
0
This article presents novel methods for synthesizing distributionally robust stabilizing neural controllers and certificates for control systems under model uncertainty. A key challenge in designing controllers with stability guarantees for uncertain systems is the accurate determination of and adaptation to shifts in model parametric uncertainty during online deployment. We tackle this with a novel distributionally robust formulation of the Lyapunov derivative chance constraint ensuring a monotonic decrease of the Lyapunov certificate. To avoid the computational complexity involved in dealing with the space of probability measures, we identify a sufficient condition in the form of deterministic convex constraints that ensures the Lyapunov derivative constraint is satisfied. We integrate this condition into a loss function for training a neural network-based controller and show that, for the resulting closed-loop system, the global asymptotic stability of its equilibrium can be certified with high confidence, even with Out-of-Distribution (OoD) model uncertainties. To demonstrate the efficacy and efficiency of the proposed methodology, we compare it with an uncertainty-agnostic baseline approach and several reinforcement learning approaches in two control problems in simulation.
4/8/2024
Safe Deep Model-Based Reinforcement Learning with Lyapunov Functions
Harry Zhang
0
0
Model-based Reinforcement Learning (MBRL) has shown many desirable properties for intelligent control tasks. However, satisfying safety and stability constraints during training and rollout remains an open question. We propose a new Model-based RL framework to enable efficient policy learning with unknown dynamics based on learning model predictive control (LMPC) framework with mathematically provable guarantees of stability. We introduce and explore a novel method for adding safety constraints for model-based RL during training and policy learning. The new stability-augmented framework consists of a neural-network-based learner that learns to construct a Lyapunov function, and a model-based RL agent to consistently complete the tasks while satisfying user-specified constraints given only sub-optimal demonstrations and sparse-cost feedback. We demonstrate the capability of the proposed framework through simulated experiments.
5/28/2024