The Future of Large Language Model Pre-training is Federated
2405.10853
0
0
Abstract
Generative pre-trained large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive performance over a wide range of tasks, thanks to the unprecedented amount of data they have been trained on. As established scaling laws indicate, LLMs' future performance improvement depends on the amount of computing and data sources we can leverage for pre-training. Federated learning (FL) has the potential to unleash the majority of the planet's data and computational resources, which are underutilized by the data-center-focused training methodology of current LLM practice. Our work presents a robust, flexible, reproducible FL approach that enables large-scale collaboration across institutions to train LLMs. This would mobilize more computational and data resources while matching or potentially exceeding centralized performance. We further show the effectiveness of the federated training scales with model size and present our approach for training a billion-scale federated LLM using limited resources. This will help data-rich actors to become the protagonists of LLMs pre-training instead of leaving the stage to compute-rich actors alone.
Create account to get full access
The Future of Large Language Model Pre-training is Federated
Overview
- Large language models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly important in AI, with applications in areas like natural language processing and generation.
- Traditional LLM training is done in a centralized way, which can be challenging due to data privacy concerns and computational constraints.
- Federated learning is an approach that allows LLM training to be done in a decentralized way, with potential benefits in terms of privacy, efficiency, and accessibility.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are a type of AI system that can understand and generate human language. These models are becoming very powerful and useful for all kinds of applications, like personalized wireless federated learning for large language models and federated legal large language models.
Traditionally, training these LLMs has been done in a centralized way, where a lot of data is gathered in one place and the model is trained all at once. However, this can be challenging because the data might be sensitive or private, and the computational power required can be very high.
Federated learning is a new approach that allows LLM training to happen in a more decentralized way. Instead of gathering all the data in one place, the training is done on devices or servers that are distributed in different locations. This can help protect privacy and make the training more efficient. It also makes it easier for a wider range of people and organizations to access and use these powerful language models, which is important for conquering communication constraints to enable large pre-training.
Overall, federated learning could be the key to unlocking the full potential of large language models and making them more accessible and useful for a wide range of applications.
Technical Explanation
Traditional LLM training is performed in a centralized way, where a large amount of textual data is aggregated and used to train a single model. This approach has several limitations:
- Data Privacy: The aggregation of data from multiple sources can raise privacy concerns, as sensitive information may be included.
- Computational Constraints: Training LLMs requires significant computational resources, which can be challenging to provision in a centralized setting.
- Accessibility: The high computational and data requirements for LLM training can make it difficult for smaller organizations or individual researchers to develop their own models.
Federated learning has been proposed as a solution to these challenges. In a federated learning approach, the LLM training process is distributed across multiple devices or servers, each with access to a portion of the training data. The model is trained locally on these devices, and the updates are then aggregated to create a shared global model. This approach offers several advantages:
- Improved Privacy: By keeping the data local and only sharing model updates, federated learning can help address data privacy concerns.
- Increased Efficiency: Distributing the training workload can reduce the overall computational requirements and make LLM training more accessible, as described in federated fine-tuning of LLMs at the very edge.
- Customization: Federated learning enables the creation of personalized or specialized LLMs, as demonstrated in the personalized wireless federated learning for large language models and FedEval: Federated Evaluation of Large Language Models papers.
The technical implementation of federated learning for LLM training involves challenges such as conquering communication constraints and ensuring model convergence in a distributed setting. Nonetheless, the potential benefits of federated learning for LLM pre-training make it a promising area of research and development.
Critical Analysis
The research presented in this paper demonstrates the potential benefits of using federated learning for LLM pre-training, such as improved privacy, increased efficiency, and greater accessibility. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research:
-
Communication Constraints: The paper notes that communication constraints, such as limited bandwidth or unreliable connections, can be a significant challenge in federated learning scenarios. More research is needed to develop techniques to overcome these constraints, as highlighted in the conquering communication constraints to enable large pre-training paper.
-
Model Convergence: Ensuring that the federated learning process converges to a high-performing global model can be challenging, particularly when dealing with heterogeneous data and device capabilities. Additional research is needed to improve the robustness and stability of federated learning algorithms.
-
Incentive Mechanisms: Encouraging participation and maintaining the integrity of the federated learning process may require the development of appropriate incentive mechanisms, which are not addressed in depth in this paper.
-
Scalability: While the paper demonstrates the potential of federated learning for LLM pre-training, it does not explore the scalability of this approach to extremely large models or very diverse datasets. Further research is needed to understand the limits and practical considerations of federated learning at scale.
Despite these limitations, the ideas presented in this paper represent an important step towards making LLM training more accessible, efficient, and privacy-preserving. As the field of federated learning continues to evolve, it will be crucial to address these challenges and explore the wider implications of this approach for the future of large language models.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a compelling case for the use of federated learning in the context of large language model (LLM) pre-training. By distributing the training process across multiple devices or servers, federated learning can help address the data privacy, computational, and accessibility challenges associated with traditional centralized LLM training.
The potential benefits of federated learning for LLMs, as demonstrated in this paper and related works, include improved privacy, increased efficiency, and the ability to create personalized or specialized models. While there are still technical hurdles to overcome, such as communication constraints and model convergence, the authors argue that federated learning represents a promising path forward for the future of LLM pre-training.
As the field of AI continues to evolve, the ability to develop and deploy powerful language models in a more accessible and privacy-preserving manner will be crucial. The ideas presented in this paper, and the ongoing research in federated learning for LLMs, could have far-reaching implications for a wide range of applications that rely on these advanced AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
šļø
Worldwide Federated Training of Language Models
Alex Iacob, Lorenzo Sani, Bill Marino, Preslav Aleksandrov, William F. Shen, Nicholas Donald Lane
0
0
The reliance of language model training on massive amounts of computation and vast datasets scraped from potentially low-quality, copyrighted, or sensitive data has come into question practically, legally, and ethically. Federated learning provides a plausible alternative by enabling previously untapped data to be voluntarily gathered from collaborating organizations. However, when scaled globally, federated learning requires collaboration across heterogeneous legal, security, and privacy regimes while accounting for the inherent locality of language data; this further exacerbates the established challenge of federated statistical heterogeneity. We propose a Worldwide Federated Language Model Training~(WorldLM) system based on federations of federations, where each federation has the autonomy to account for factors such as its industry, operating jurisdiction, or competitive environment. WorldLM enables such autonomy in the presence of statistical heterogeneity via partial model localization by allowing sub-federations to attentively aggregate key layers from their constituents. Furthermore, it can adaptively share information across federations via residual layer embeddings. Evaluations of language modeling on naturally heterogeneous datasets show that WorldLM outperforms standard federations by up to $1.91times$, approaches the personalized performance of fully local models, and maintains these advantages under privacy-enhancing techniques.
5/28/2024
Federated Learning driven Large Language Models for Swarm Intelligence: A Survey
Youyang Qu
0
0
Federated learning (FL) offers a compelling framework for training large language models (LLMs) while addressing data privacy and decentralization challenges. This paper surveys recent advancements in the federated learning of large language models, with a particular focus on machine unlearning, a crucial aspect for complying with privacy regulations like the Right to be Forgotten. Machine unlearning in the context of federated LLMs involves systematically and securely removing individual data contributions from the learned model without retraining from scratch. We explore various strategies that enable effective unlearning, such as perturbation techniques, model decomposition, and incremental learning, highlighting their implications for maintaining model performance and data privacy. Furthermore, we examine case studies and experimental results from recent literature to assess the effectiveness and efficiency of these approaches in real-world scenarios. Our survey reveals a growing interest in developing more robust and scalable federated unlearning methods, suggesting a vital area for future research in the intersection of AI ethics and distributed machine learning technologies.
6/17/2024
Federated Fine-Tuning of LLMs on the Very Edge: The Good, the Bad, the Ugly
Herbert Woisetschlager, Alexander Isenko, Shiqiang Wang, Ruben Mayer, Hans-Arno Jacobsen
0
0
Large Language Models (LLM) and foundation models are popular as they offer new opportunities for individuals and businesses to improve natural language processing, interact with data, and retrieve information faster. However, training or fine-tuning LLMs requires a vast amount of data, which can be challenging to access due to legal or technical restrictions and may require private computing resources. Federated Learning (FL) is a solution designed to overcome these challenges and expand data access for deep learning applications. This paper takes a hardware-centric approach to explore how LLMs can be brought to modern edge computing systems. Our study fine-tunes the FLAN-T5 model family, ranging from 80M to 3B parameters, using FL for a text summarization task. We provide a micro-level hardware benchmark, compare the model FLOP utilization to a state-of-the-art data center GPU, and study the network utilization in realistic conditions. Our contribution is twofold: First, we evaluate the current capabilities of edge computing systems and their potential for LLM FL workloads. Second, by comparing these systems with a data-center GPU, we demonstrate the potential for improvement and the next steps toward achieving greater computational efficiency at the edge.
5/3/2024
Synergizing Foundation Models and Federated Learning: A Survey
Shenghui Li, Fanghua Ye, Meng Fang, Jiaxu Zhao, Yun-Hin Chan, Edith C. -H. Ngai, Thiemo Voigt
0
0
The recent development of Foundation Models (FMs), represented by large language models, vision transformers, and multimodal models, has been making a significant impact on both academia and industry. Compared with small-scale models, FMs have a much stronger demand for high-volume data during the pre-training phase. Although general FMs can be pre-trained on data collected from open sources such as the Internet, domain-specific FMs need proprietary data, posing a practical challenge regarding the amount of data available due to privacy concerns. Federated Learning (FL) is a collaborative learning paradigm that breaks the barrier of data availability from different participants. Therefore, it provides a promising solution to customize and adapt FMs to a wide range of domain-specific tasks using distributed datasets whilst preserving privacy. This survey paper discusses the potentials and challenges of synergizing FL and FMs and summarizes core techniques, future directions, and applications. A periodically updated paper collection on FM-FL is available at https://github.com/lishenghui/awesome-fm-fl.
6/19/2024