Granger Causal Inference in Multivariate Hawkes Processes by Minimum Message Length

Overview

• Multivariate Hawkes processes (MHPs) are a versatile tool for modeling real-world phenomena like earthquakes, stock market activity, neuronal activity, and virus propagation.
• This paper focuses on MHPs with exponential decay kernels and estimating the connectivity graphs that represent Granger causal relationships between the components.
• The authors propose an optimization criterion and model selection algorithm based on the minimum message length (MML) principle, which prefers models that provide the most concise explanation of the observed data.
• The MML-based method is shown to outperform other state-of-the-art methods, especially in scenarios with short time horizons, where the latter tend to overfit.

Plain English Explanation

Multivariate Hawkes processes (link) are mathematical models that can be used to study and understand various real-world events, such as earthquakes, stock market activity, brain cell behavior, and the spread of viruses. In this paper, the researchers focus on a specific type of Hawkes process that has an exponential decay pattern.

The main goal of the study is to estimate the relationships, or "connectivity graphs," between the different components of these Hawkes processes. These connectivity graphs represent the Granger causal connections between the variables being modeled. To do this, the researchers propose a new optimization method and model selection algorithm based on the "minimum message length" (MML) principle.

The MML principle states that, even if two models fit the observed data equally well, the simpler model that can be described more concisely is the better one. This is similar to the idea of Occam's razor, where the simplest explanation is often preferred. By using this MML approach, the researchers found that their method outperformed other state-of-the-art techniques, especially when dealing with datasets that cover a relatively short time period, where the other methods tend to overfit the data.

The researchers also applied their MML-based method to analyze government bond data from the G7 countries and were able to identify causal connections that align with expert knowledge in the field.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a method for estimating the connectivity graphs, which represent Granger causal relationships, in the context of multivariate Hawkes processes (MHPs) with exponential decay kernels.

The authors propose an optimization criterion and model selection algorithm based on the minimum message length (MML) principle. MML compares different Granger causal models using the Occam's razor principle - even when models have similar goodness-of-fit to the observed data, the one that provides the most concise explanation of the data is preferred.

The key innovation is that, while most existing state-of-the-art methods using lasso-type penalization tend to overfit in scenarios with short time horizons, the proposed MML-based method is shown to achieve high F1 scores in these settings.

The authors conduct a numerical study comparing their proposed algorithm to other classical and state-of-the-art methods. They find that their MML-based approach achieves the highest F1 scores in specific sparse graph settings.

The method is also illustrated on G7 sovereign bond data, and the obtained causal connections are found to be in agreement with expert knowledge available in the literature.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and thorough study, with a clear focus on addressing the limitations of existing methods, particularly in scenarios with short time horizons. The authors' use of the MML principle as the basis for their optimization and model selection criteria is a novel and promising approach.

One potential area for further research could be to explore the performance of the MML-based method on a wider range of real-world datasets and application domains, beyond the G7 bond data example provided. This would help to further validate the generalizability and robustness of the proposed technique.

Additionally, while the paper provides a comprehensive technical explanation, there may be value in exploring more intuitive analogies or examples to help a general audience better understand the significance and implications of the research (link).

Overall, this paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of Multivariate Hawkes Processes and causal inference, with a novel approach that shows promising results, particularly in challenging data regimes.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a new method for estimating connectivity graphs, representing Granger causal relationships, in the context of multivariate Hawkes processes with exponential decay kernels. The key innovation is the use of a minimum message length (MML) principle-based optimization and model selection approach, which outperforms other state-of-the-art techniques, especially in scenarios with short time horizons.

The proposed MML-based method has the potential to provide valuable insights into a wide range of real-world phenomena, from neuronal activity to virus propagation. The ability to accurately infer causal relationships from limited data could have important implications for fields such as epidemiology, finance, and neuroscience.