Growing Trees on Sounds: Assessing Strategies for End-to-End Dependency Parsing of Speech
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores strategies for end-to-end dependency parsing of speech, focusing on the challenges of processing spoken language rather than written text.
- The authors investigate different approaches to building parser models that can directly consume audio input, without requiring a separate speech recognition step.
- They evaluate the performance of these models on a range of speech parsing tasks, including adapting pre-trained text-based parser models to the speech domain.
Plain English Explanation
Dependency parsing is the task of analyzing the grammatical structure of a sentence by identifying the relationships between its words. Traditionally, this has been done on written text, but the authors of this paper are interested in applying it to spoken language as well.
One challenge with parsing speech is that it doesn't have the same clear boundaries between words that written text does. The authors explore different strategies for building parser models that can directly process audio input, without first having to transcribe the speech into text.
This allows the parser to leverage information in the speech signal that may be relevant for understanding the sentence structure, rather than relying solely on the text transcript. The authors evaluate the performance of these models on a variety of speech parsing tasks, and also look at how well pre-trained text-based parsers can be adapted to work with speech data.
The goal is to develop end-to-end speech parsing systems that can better handle the messy, continuous nature of spoken language, compared to the more structured format of written text. This could have applications in areas like voice-based interfaces, language learning, and speech-to-text transcription.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates several strategies for end-to-end dependency parsing of speech:
-
Direct Speech Parsing: Models that take raw audio input and directly predict the dependency tree, without an intermediate speech recognition step. This includes models that use tree-structured architectures to better capture the hierarchical nature of syntax.
-
Integrated Speech Recognition and Parsing: Models that perform speech recognition and syntactic parsing jointly, in a multi-task learning setup. This allows the models to share information between the two tasks.
-
Adapting Pre-Trained Text Parsers: Exploring ways to fine-tune pre-trained text-based dependency parsers to work with speech input, leveraging the knowledge captured in the original text models.
The authors evaluate these approaches on several speech parsing benchmarks, including the Switchboard and LibriSpeech datasets. They analyze the models' performance in terms of parsing accuracy, as well as their ability to handle disfluencies, hesitations, and other challenges of spoken language.
The results suggest that direct speech parsing models can achieve competitive performance, and that joint speech recognition and parsing can provide additional benefits. Adapting pre-trained text parsers is also shown to be a viable strategy, though the models may require significant fine-tuning to handle the unique characteristics of speech data.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive evaluation of different strategies for end-to-end speech parsing, highlighting both the potential and the challenges of this task. One limitation noted is the reliance on relatively clean, high-quality speech data in the benchmark datasets used.
In real-world applications, speech data is likely to be much messier, with background noise, overlapping speakers, and other distortions. The performance of the models on such noisy, naturalistic speech data may differ from the results reported in the paper.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the interpretability or explainability of the models' parsing decisions. Understanding why the models make certain predictions could be valuable for real-world use cases, such as language learning or assistive technologies.
Further research could also explore the integration of syntactic patterns or multipath parsing approaches to improve the robustness and flexibility of speech parsing systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a thorough investigation of strategies for end-to-end dependency parsing of speech, a challenging task that has important applications in areas like voice interfaces and language analysis. The authors explore a range of models and approaches, demonstrating the potential for direct speech parsing and the benefits of jointly modeling speech recognition and syntactic analysis.
While the results are promising, the authors also highlight the need for further research to address the unique challenges of spoken language processing, such as handling noisy, disfluent input. Continued advancements in this area could lead to more robust and versatile natural language understanding systems that can work seamlessly with both written and spoken communication.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Growing Trees on Sounds: Assessing Strategies for End-to-End Dependency Parsing of Speech
Adrien Pupier, Maximin Coavoux, J'er^ome Goulian, Benjamin Lecouteux
Direct dependency parsing of the speech signal -- as opposed to parsing speech transcriptions -- has recently been proposed as a task (Pupier et al. 2022), as a way of incorporating prosodic information in the parsing system and bypassing the limitations of a pipeline approach that would consist of using first an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) system and then a syntactic parser. In this article, we report on a set of experiments aiming at assessing the performance of two parsing paradigms (graph-based parsing and sequence labeling based parsing) on speech parsing. We perform this evaluation on a large treebank of spoken French, featuring realistic spontaneous conversations. Our findings show that (i) the graph based approach obtain better results across the board (ii) parsing directly from speech outperforms a pipeline approach, despite having 30% fewer parameters.
Read more6/19/2024
0
Textless Dependency Parsing by Labeled Sequence Prediction
Shunsuke Kando, Yusuke Miyao, Jason Naradowsky, Shinnosuke Takamichi
Traditional spoken language processing involves cascading an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system into text processing models. In contrast, textless methods process speech representations without ASR systems, enabling the direct use of acoustic speech features. Although their effectiveness is shown in capturing acoustic features, it is unclear in capturing lexical knowledge. This paper proposes a textless method for dependency parsing, examining its effectiveness and limitations. Our proposed method predicts a dependency tree from a speech signal without transcribing, representing the tree as a labeled sequence. scading method outperforms the textless method in overall parsing accuracy, the latter excels in instances with important acoustic features. Our findings highlight the importance of fusing word-level representations and sentence-level prosody for enhanced parsing performance. The code and models are made publicly available: https://github.com/mynlp/SpeechParser.
Read more7/16/2024
🌿
0
Revisiting Structured Sentiment Analysis as Latent Dependency Graph Parsing
Chengjie Zhou, Bobo Li, Hao Fei, Fei Li, Chong Teng, Donghong Ji
Structured Sentiment Analysis (SSA) was cast as a problem of bi-lexical dependency graph parsing by prior studies. Multiple formulations have been proposed to construct the graph, which share several intrinsic drawbacks: (1) The internal structures of spans are neglected, thus only the boundary tokens of spans are used for relation prediction and span recognition, thus hindering the model's expressiveness; (2) Long spans occupy a significant proportion in the SSA datasets, which further exacerbates the problem of internal structure neglect. In this paper, we treat the SSA task as a dependency parsing task on partially-observed dependency trees, regarding flat spans without determined tree annotations as latent subtrees to consider internal structures of spans. We propose a two-stage parsing method and leverage TreeCRFs with a novel constrained inside algorithm to model latent structures explicitly, which also takes advantages of joint scoring graph arcs and headed spans for global optimization and inference. Results of extensive experiments on five benchmark datasets reveal that our method performs significantly better than all previous bi-lexical methods, achieving new state-of-the-art.
Read more7/9/2024
0
TreeSeg: Hierarchical Topic Segmentation of Large Transcripts
Dimitrios C. Gklezakos, Timothy Misiak, Diamond Bishop
From organizing recorded videos and meetings into chapters, to breaking down large inputs in order to fit them into the context window of commoditized Large Language Models (LLMs), topic segmentation of large transcripts emerges as a task of increasing significance. Still, accurate segmentation presents many challenges, including (a) the noisy nature of the Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) software typically used to obtain the transcripts, (b) the lack of diverse labeled data and (c) the difficulty in pin-pointing the ground-truth number of segments. In this work we present TreeSeg, an approach that combines off-the-shelf embedding models with divisive clustering, to generate hierarchical, structured segmentations of transcripts in the form of binary trees. Our approach is robust to noise and can handle large transcripts efficiently. We evaluate TreeSeg on the ICSI and AMI corpora, demonstrating that it outperforms all baselines. Finally, we introduce TinyRec, a small-scale corpus of manually annotated transcripts, obtained from self-recorded video sessions.
Read more7/18/2024