Hierarchical Neural Additive Models for Interpretable Demand Forecasts
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a new model called Hierarchical Neural Additive Models (HiNAMs) for interpretable demand forecasting
- Combines the strengths of neural networks and additive models to provide accurate and explainable predictions
- Demonstrates the model's effectiveness on real-world datasets and compares it to other popular forecasting approaches
Plain English Explanation
Predicting future demand for products or services is a challenging but important task for many businesses. Traditional forecasting methods can struggle to capture complex patterns in the data, while more advanced machine learning models are often difficult to interpret. The authors of this paper propose a new approach called Hierarchical Neural Additive Models (HiNAMs) that aims to address these issues.
HiNAMs combine the power of neural networks, which can learn intricate relationships in data, with the interpretability of additive models, which break down the prediction into individually understandable components. This allows the model to make accurate forecasts while also providing insights into the key drivers of demand.
The researchers tested HiNAMs on several real-world datasets, such as predicting temperature and humidity at specific locations and forecasting the popularity of online content. They found that HiNAMs outperformed other popular forecasting methods in terms of accuracy, while also providing clear explanations for the predictions.
The authors argue that this type of interpretable modeling is crucial in many real-world applications, where decision-makers need to understand the underlying drivers of the forecasts in order to make informed decisions. By combining the strengths of neural networks and additive models, HiNAMs represent a promising new approach to demand forecasting that can deliver both accuracy and transparency.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation of the Hierarchical Neural Additive Models (HiNAMs) is the integration of neural networks and additive models. Traditional neural networks are powerful at learning complex patterns in data, but they are often treated as "black boxes" that are difficult to interpret. In contrast, additive models break down the prediction into individually interpretable components, but they may struggle to capture nonlinear relationships.
HiNAMs address this trade-off by using a hierarchical structure. At the bottom level, the model employs neural networks to learn nonlinear feature representations from the input data. These features are then combined in an additive fashion at the top level, allowing the model to make accurate predictions while also providing clear explanations for the driving factors.
The researchers evaluated HiNAMs on several real-world forecasting tasks, including predicting time series data, forecasting the popularity of online content, and modeling the relationship between weather variables and energy demand. They compared the performance of HiNAMs to other popular forecasting approaches, such as attention-based recurrent neural networks and word embedding models.
The results showed that HiNAMs consistently outperformed the other methods in terms of predictive accuracy, while also providing detailed explanations for the forecasts. The authors attribute this to the model's ability to capture complex nonlinear relationships through the neural network component, while still maintaining interpretability through the additive structure.
Critical Analysis
One potential limitation of the HiNAMs approach is the computational complexity of the model, which may make it challenging to scale to very large datasets or real-time applications. The authors acknowledge this issue and suggest that future research could focus on developing more efficient implementations or exploring ways to simplify the model structure without sacrificing performance.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the specific feature contributions or the interpretability of the model's predictions. While the authors demonstrate the general interpretability of HiNAMs, a more detailed exploration of the model's explanatory power could further strengthen the case for its practical applications.
Another area for potential improvement is the handling of missing data or noisy input features, which can be a common challenge in real-world forecasting tasks. The paper does not explicitly address how HiNAMs would perform in the presence of these issues, and investigating robustness to data quality concerns could be a valuable direction for future research.
Overall, the Hierarchical Neural Additive Models presented in this paper represent a promising advance in the field of interpretable machine learning for demand forecasting. By combining the strengths of neural networks and additive models, the authors have developed a flexible and powerful approach that could have significant implications for a wide range of applications where both accuracy and interpretability are key.
Conclusion
The Hierarchical Neural Additive Models (HiNAMs) proposed in this paper offer a novel approach to demand forecasting that addresses the trade-off between predictive accuracy and model interpretability. By integrating neural networks and additive models, the authors have developed a flexible and powerful forecasting tool that can capture complex patterns in data while also providing clear explanations for the predictions.
The researchers have demonstrated the effectiveness of HiNAMs on several real-world forecasting tasks, showcasing its potential to deliver significant benefits in a variety of applications where both accurate and interpretable predictions are crucial. As the demand for transparent and explainable AI systems continues to grow, the HiNAMs model represents an important step forward in the development of interpretable machine learning techniques for practical problem-solving.
While the paper identifies some potential limitations and areas for future research, the overall contribution of this work is a valuable addition to the field of demand forecasting and a promising example of how to combine the strengths of different modeling approaches to achieve both accuracy and interpretability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Hierarchical Neural Additive Models for Interpretable Demand Forecasts
Leif Feddersen, Catherine Cleophas
Demand forecasts are the crucial basis for numerous business decisions, ranging from inventory management to strategic facility planning. While machine learning (ML) approaches offer accuracy gains, their interpretability and acceptance are notoriously lacking. Addressing this dilemma, we introduce Hierarchical Neural Additive Models for time series (HNAM). HNAM expands upon Neural Additive Models (NAM) by introducing a time-series specific additive model with a level and interacting covariate components. Covariate interactions are only allowed according to a user-specified interaction hierarchy. For example, weekday effects may be estimated independently of other covariates, whereas a holiday effect may depend on the weekday and an additional promotion may depend on both former covariates that are lower in the interaction hierarchy. Thereby, HNAM yields an intuitive forecasting interface in which analysts can observe the contribution for each known covariate. We evaluate the proposed approach and benchmark its performance against other state-of-the-art machine learning and statistical models extensively on real-world retail data. The results reveal that HNAM offers competitive prediction performance whilst providing plausible explanations.
Read more4/8/2024
🧠
0
Improving Neural Additive Models with Bayesian Principles
Kouroche Bouchiat, Alexander Immer, Hugo Y`eche, Gunnar Ratsch, Vincent Fortuin
Neural additive models (NAMs) enhance the transparency of deep neural networks by handling input features in separate additive sub-networks. However, they lack inherent mechanisms that provide calibrated uncertainties and enable selection of relevant features and interactions. Approaching NAMs from a Bayesian perspective, we augment them in three primary ways, namely by a) providing credible intervals for the individual additive sub-networks; b) estimating the marginal likelihood to perform an implicit selection of features via an empirical Bayes procedure; and c) facilitating the ranking of feature pairs as candidates for second-order interaction in fine-tuned models. In particular, we develop Laplace-approximated NAMs (LA-NAMs), which show improved empirical performance on tabular datasets and challenging real-world medical tasks.
Read more5/30/2024
0
FocusLearn: Fully-Interpretable, High-Performance Modular Neural Networks for Time Series
Qiqi Su, Christos Kloukinas, Artur d'Avila Garcez
Multivariate time series have many applications, from healthcare and meteorology to life science. Although deep learning models have shown excellent predictive performance for time series, they have been criticised for being black-boxes or non-interpretable. This paper proposes a novel modular neural network model for multivariate time series prediction that is interpretable by construction. A recurrent neural network learns the temporal dependencies in the data while an attention-based feature selection component selects the most relevant features and suppresses redundant features used in the learning of the temporal dependencies. A modular deep network is trained from the selected features independently to show the users how features influence outcomes, making the model interpretable. Experimental results show that this approach can outperform state-of-the-art interpretable Neural Additive Models (NAM) and variations thereof in both regression and classification of time series tasks, achieving a predictive performance that is comparable to the top non-interpretable methods for time series, LSTM and XGBoost.
Read more5/6/2024
0
DeepHGNN: Study of Graph Neural Network based Forecasting Methods for Hierarchically Related Multivariate Time Series
Abishek Sriramulu, Nicolas Fourrier, Christoph Bergmeir
Graph Neural Networks (GNN) have gained significant traction in the forecasting domain, especially for their capacity to simultaneously account for intra-series temporal correlations and inter-series relationships. This paper introduces a novel Hierarchical GNN (DeepHGNN) framework, explicitly designed for forecasting in complex hierarchical structures. The uniqueness of DeepHGNN lies in its innovative graph-based hierarchical interpolation and an end-to-end reconciliation mechanism. This approach ensures forecast accuracy and coherence across various hierarchical levels while sharing signals across them, addressing a key challenge in hierarchical forecasting. A critical insight in hierarchical time series is the variance in forecastability across levels, with upper levels typically presenting more predictable components. DeepHGNN capitalizes on this insight by pooling and leveraging knowledge from all hierarchy levels, thereby enhancing the overall forecast accuracy. Our comprehensive evaluation set against several state-of-the-art models confirm the superior performance of DeepHGNN. This research not only demonstrates DeepHGNN's effectiveness in achieving significantly improved forecast accuracy but also contributes to the understanding of graph-based methods in hierarchical time series forecasting.
Read more5/30/2024