A Huber Loss Minimization Approach to Mean Estimation under User-level Differential Privacy
2405.13453
0
0
👨🏫
Abstract
Privacy protection of users' entire contribution of samples is important in distributed systems. The most effective approach is the two-stage scheme, which finds a small interval first and then gets a refined estimate by clipping samples into the interval. However, the clipping operation induces bias, which is serious if the sample distribution is heavy-tailed. Besides, users with large local sample sizes can make the sensitivity much larger, thus the method is not suitable for imbalanced users. Motivated by these challenges, we propose a Huber loss minimization approach to mean estimation under user-level differential privacy. The connecting points of Huber loss can be adaptively adjusted to deal with imbalanced users. Moreover, it avoids the clipping operation, thus significantly reducing the bias compared with the two-stage approach. We provide a theoretical analysis of our approach, which gives the noise strength needed for privacy protection, as well as the bound of mean squared error. The result shows that the new method is much less sensitive to the imbalance of user-wise sample sizes and the tail of sample distributions. Finally, we perform numerical experiments to validate our theoretical analysis.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper addresses the challenge of protecting the privacy of user data in distributed systems, where users contribute samples that are aggregated to estimate a mean value.
- The authors propose a Huber loss minimization approach to mean estimation under user-level differential privacy, which is designed to be less sensitive to imbalances in user-wise sample sizes and heavy-tailed sample distributions.
- The paper provides a theoretical analysis of the proposed method, including the noise strength needed for privacy protection and the bound on mean squared error.
- Numerical experiments are used to validate the theoretical analysis and demonstrate the benefits of the new method compared to previous approaches.
Plain English Explanation
In distributed systems, users may contribute samples of data that are then combined to estimate an overall average or mean value. Protecting the privacy of each user's contribution is important, but can be challenging. A previous approach used a two-stage scheme to find a small interval first and then refine the estimate by "clipping" samples into that interval. However, this clipping operation can introduce bias, especially if the sample distribution has heavy tails (i.e., lots of outliers).
The new method proposed in this paper uses a Huber loss function, which can adaptively adjust the clipping points to deal with imbalances in the amount of data contributed by different users. This helps avoid the bias issues of the previous clipping-based approach. The authors also provide a mathematical analysis to understand the privacy guarantees and accuracy of their new method.
The key benefits of this new approach are that it is less sensitive to imbalances in user-wise sample sizes and can handle heavy-tailed distributions better than prior methods. This makes it a more robust and practical solution for privacy-preserving distributed data aggregation.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a Huber loss minimization approach for mean estimation under user-level differential privacy. The Huber loss function combines the L1 and L2 norms, allowing it to be more robust to outliers than standard least squares.
The authors show that their method can adaptively adjust the "clipping" thresholds of the Huber loss based on the local sample sizes of each user. This helps address the issue with the previous two-stage clipping approach, where users with large local samples could dominate the sensitivity and lead to excessive noise addition.
The theoretical analysis provides bounds on the noise strength needed for user-level differential privacy, as well as the mean squared error of the Huber loss estimator. These results demonstrate that the new method is much less sensitive to imbalances in user-wise sample sizes and heavy-tailed distributions compared to prior work.
The numerical experiments validate the theoretical findings and show the advantages of the Huber loss approach over alternatives like the two-stage clipping method and differentially private mean estimation based on distributionally robust optimization.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical analysis of the proposed Huber loss minimization approach, which is a strength. However, the practical implications and limitations of the method are not fully explored.
For example, the paper does not discuss how the Huber loss function's parameters would be tuned in a real-world setting, or how sensitive the performance is to these hyperparameters. Additionally, the numerical experiments are conducted on synthetic data, so the behavior on realistic, high-dimensional datasets is unclear.
Another potential concern is the computational overhead of the Huber loss optimization, especially compared to simpler clipping-based approaches. The scalability of the method to large-scale distributed systems with many users is an area that could benefit from further investigation.
Overall, the research represents an interesting and promising direction for privacy-preserving distributed data aggregation. However, more work may be needed to fully understand the practical implications and limitations of the Huber loss approach, particularly in comparison to other differential privacy techniques and distributed DP methods.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new Huber loss minimization approach for mean estimation under user-level differential privacy in distributed systems. The method is designed to be less sensitive to imbalances in user-wise sample sizes and heavy-tailed sample distributions, which are limitations of previous clipping-based techniques.
The theoretical analysis and numerical experiments demonstrate the potential benefits of the Huber loss approach, including improved privacy-accuracy trade-offs compared to alternative methods. This research represents an important contribution to the field of privacy-preserving distributed data analysis, and the insights could have significant implications for the design of secure and robust distributed systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🚀
Private Mean Estimation with Person-Level Differential Privacy
Sushant Agarwal, Gautam Kamath, Mahbod Majid, Argyris Mouzakis, Rose Silver, Jonathan Ullman
0
0
We study differentially private (DP) mean estimation in the case where each person holds multiple samples. Commonly referred to as the user-level setting, DP here requires the usual notion of distributional stability when all of a person's datapoints can be modified. Informally, if $n$ people each have $m$ samples from an unknown $d$-dimensional distribution with bounded $k$-th moments, we show that [n = tilde Thetaleft(frac{d}{alpha^2 m} + frac{d }{ alpha m^{1/2} varepsilon} + frac{d}{alpha^{k/(k-1)} m varepsilon} + frac{d}{varepsilon}right)] people are necessary and sufficient to estimate the mean up to distance $alpha$ in $ell_2$-norm under $varepsilon$-differential privacy (and its common relaxations). In the multivariate setting, we give computationally efficient algorithms under approximate DP (with slightly degraded sample complexity) and computationally inefficient algorithms under pure DP, and our nearly matching lower bounds hold for the most permissive case of approximate DP. Our computationally efficient estimators are based on the well known noisy-clipped-mean approach, but the analysis for our setting requires new bounds on the tails of sums of independent, vector-valued, bounded-moments random variables, and a new argument for bounding the bias introduced by clipping.
6/3/2024
Learning with User-Level Local Differential Privacy
Puning Zhao, Li Shen, Rongfei Fan, Qingming Li, Huiwen Wu, Jiafei Wu, Zhe Liu
0
0
User-level privacy is important in distributed systems. Previous research primarily focuses on the central model, while the local models have received much less attention. Under the central model, user-level DP is strictly stronger than the item-level one. However, under the local model, the relationship between user-level and item-level LDP becomes more complex, thus the analysis is crucially different. In this paper, we first analyze the mean estimation problem and then apply it to stochastic optimization, classification, and regression. In particular, we propose adaptive strategies to achieve optimal performance at all privacy levels. Moreover, we also obtain information-theoretic lower bounds, which show that the proposed methods are minimax optimal up to logarithmic factors. Unlike the central DP model, where user-level DP always leads to slower convergence, our result shows that under the local model, the convergence rates are nearly the same between user-level and item-level cases for distributions with bounded support. For heavy-tailed distributions, the user-level rate is even faster than the item-level one.
5/28/2024
🎲
Robustness Implies Privacy in Statistical Estimation
Samuel B. Hopkins, Gautam Kamath, Mahbod Majid, Shyam Narayanan
0
0
We study the relationship between adversarial robustness and differential privacy in high-dimensional algorithmic statistics. We give the first black-box reduction from privacy to robustness which can produce private estimators with optimal tradeoffs among sample complexity, accuracy, and privacy for a wide range of fundamental high-dimensional parameter estimation problems, including mean and covariance estimation. We show that this reduction can be implemented in polynomial time in some important special cases. In particular, using nearly-optimal polynomial-time robust estimators for the mean and covariance of high-dimensional Gaussians which are based on the Sum-of-Squares method, we design the first polynomial-time private estimators for these problems with nearly-optimal samples-accuracy-privacy tradeoffs. Our algorithms are also robust to a nearly optimal fraction of adversarially-corrupted samples.
6/18/2024
Improved Communication-Privacy Trade-offs in $L_2$ Mean Estimation under Streaming Differential Privacy
Wei-Ning Chen, Berivan Isik, Peter Kairouz, Albert No, Sewoong Oh, Zheng Xu
0
0
We study $L_2$ mean estimation under central differential privacy and communication constraints, and address two key challenges: firstly, existing mean estimation schemes that simultaneously handle both constraints are usually optimized for $L_infty$ geometry and rely on random rotation or Kashin's representation to adapt to $L_2$ geometry, resulting in suboptimal leading constants in mean square errors (MSEs); secondly, schemes achieving order-optimal communication-privacy trade-offs do not extend seamlessly to streaming differential privacy (DP) settings (e.g., tree aggregation or matrix factorization), rendering them incompatible with DP-FTRL type optimizers. In this work, we tackle these issues by introducing a novel privacy accounting method for the sparsified Gaussian mechanism that incorporates the randomness inherent in sparsification into the DP noise. Unlike previous approaches, our accounting algorithm directly operates in $L_2$ geometry, yielding MSEs that fast converge to those of the uncompressed Gaussian mechanism. Additionally, we extend the sparsification scheme to the matrix factorization framework under streaming DP and provide a precise accountant tailored for DP-FTRL type optimizers. Empirically, our method demonstrates at least a 100x improvement of compression for DP-SGD across various FL tasks.
5/7/2024