Human-Agent Cooperation in Games under Incomplete Information through Natural Language Communication

Overview

• Developing effective communication between autonomous agents and humans is crucial for successful collaboration under incomplete information.
• The researchers introduce a shared-control game where two players take turns controlling a token to achieve a common objective.
• They propose a communication-based approach to enable an autonomous agent to play this game with a human player, comprising a language module and a planning module.
• The language module translates natural language messages into a compact set of "flags" representing player intents, while the planning module uses these flags to compute a policy.
• The effectiveness of this approach is evaluated in a board game testbed, showing that communication can enhance human-agent cooperation.

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a way for autonomous agents, like AI systems, to effectively communicate and cooperate with human players in a game-like setting where both sides have incomplete information. The key idea is to have the AI system translate the human player's natural language messages into a simplified set of "flags" that represent their intentions. This allows the AI's planning module to understand the human's goals and strategize accordingly.

Imagine a treasure hunt game where you and an AI agent are searching for hidden items together. You might say something like "I think the treasure is to the left," and the AI would translate that into a flag like "EXPLORE_LEFT." The AI can then use this flag, along with other information, to decide its next move in the game to work towards the shared goal more efficiently.

The researchers test this approach in a maze-based game and find that the communication between the human and AI helps narrow the information gap, leading to faster and more effective cooperation. This suggests that such communication-based approaches could be valuable for building AI systems that can work alongside humans in complex, uncertain environments.

Technical Explanation

The paper formulates a policy synthesis problem for an autonomous agent playing a shared-control game with a human player. In this game, the two players take turns controlling a token to collectively achieve a common objective, but they have incomplete information about the game state.

To address this problem, the researchers propose a communication-based approach comprising two key modules:

1. Language Module: This module translates the human player's natural language messages into a finite set of flags, a compact representation designed to capture the player's intents and goals.
2. Planning Module: This module uses the exchanged flags to compute a policy for the autonomous agent, leveraging an asymmetric information-set Monte Carlo tree search with flag exchange algorithm.

The effectiveness of this approach is evaluated in a testbed based on the "Gnomes at Night" board game, a search-and-find maze game. The results of human subject experiments show that communication through the exchange of flags helps to narrow the information gap between the human and agent players, leading to enhanced cooperation efficiency with fewer turns required to achieve the shared objective.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising approach for enabling effective communication and cooperation between autonomous agents and human players in scenarios with incomplete information. The use of a simplified "flag" representation to capture player intents is an interesting solution to the challenge of translating natural language into a format that can be easily processed by the planning module.

However, the paper does not address the potential limitations of this approach. For example, it's unclear how well the language module would perform in handling more complex or ambiguous natural language input, or how the system would handle situations where the human player's intentions are not easily translatable into the predefined set of flags. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the potential for bias or misunderstandings to arise in the communication process, which could undermine the effectiveness of the collaboration.

Further research would be needed to explore the broader applicability of this approach, such as its performance in more open-ended communication scenarios or its scalability to more complex games and domains. Additionally, it would be valuable to investigate the potential for large language models to enhance the communication capabilities of such systems.

Conclusion

The paper presents a novel communication-based approach for enabling effective collaboration between autonomous agents and human players in a shared-control game scenario with incomplete information. By translating natural language messages into a simplified "flag" representation, the system allows the agent to understand and respond to the human player's intents, leading to more efficient cooperation.

The results of the human subject experiments suggest that this approach holds promise for developing AI systems that can work seamlessly alongside humans in complex, uncertain environments. Further research is needed to explore the broader applicability and potential limitations of this communication-based framework, but it represents an important step forward in the quest to build autonomous agents that can effectively engage with and assist human users.