On the Identification of Temporally Causal Representation with Instantaneous Dependence
2405.15325
0
0
Abstract
Temporally causal representation learning aims to identify the latent causal process from time series observations, but most methods require the assumption that the latent causal processes do not have instantaneous relations. Although some recent methods achieve identifiability in the instantaneous causality case, they require either interventions on the latent variables or grouping of the observations, which are in general difficult to obtain in real-world scenarios. To fill this gap, we propose an textbf{ID}entification framework for instantanetextbf{O}us textbf{L}atent dynamics (textbf{IDOL}) by imposing a sparse influence constraint that the latent causal processes have sparse time-delayed and instantaneous relations. Specifically, we establish identifiability results of the latent causal process based on sufficient variability and the sparse influence constraint by employing contextual information of time series data. Based on these theories, we incorporate a temporally variational inference architecture to estimate the latent variables and a gradient-based sparsity regularization to identify the latent causal process. Experimental results on simulation datasets illustrate that our method can identify the latent causal process. Furthermore, evaluations on multiple human motion forecasting benchmarks with instantaneous dependencies indicate the effectiveness of our method in real-world settings.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel approach for identifying temporally causal representations with instantaneous dependence in dynamical systems.
- It addresses the challenge of learning interpretable and causal representations from time-series data, which is crucial for understanding and modeling complex real-world phenomena.
- The proposed method leverages a combination of techniques from causal representation learning and dynamical systems theory to uncover the underlying causal structure and dynamics.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a fundamental problem in machine learning and data analysis: how to extract meaningful, interpretable, and causally-relevant information from complex, time-varying data.
The key idea is to go beyond simply finding patterns in the data, and instead uncover the underlying causal mechanisms that drive the observed dynamics. This is important because it allows us to better understand the system, make more accurate predictions, and potentially intervene in the system to achieve desired outcomes.
The authors propose a new method that combines techniques from causal representation learning and dynamical systems theory. Causal representation learning aims to identify the latent variables that are truly driving the system, rather than just capturing spurious correlations. Dynamical systems theory provides a mathematical framework for modeling how these latent variables evolve over time and interact with each other.
By integrating these two approaches, the method can uncover the causal structure of the system and learn an interpretable dynamical model that captures the key causal relationships. This is a significant advance over traditional "black box" models that may fit the data well but provide little insight into the underlying mechanisms.
The proposed approach has important applications in fields like economics, neuroscience, and climate science, where understanding causal relationships is crucial for making reliable predictions, designing effective interventions, and gaining deeper scientific insights.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel approach for identifying temporally causal representations with instantaneous dependence, building on the causal representation learning and dynamical systems literature.
The key technical contributions are:
- A formulation of the problem that captures both the temporal and instantaneous causal relationships in the data-generating process.
- An algorithm that learns a latent state-space model with interpretable causal structure, using a combination of causal discovery and dynamical systems techniques.
- Theoretical analysis of the identifiability conditions and convergence properties of the proposed method.
- Extensive experiments on both synthetic and real-world datasets, demonstrating the effectiveness of the approach in recovering the true causal structure and dynamics.
The core idea is to jointly learn the latent representation and the underlying dynamical system that governs the evolution of these latent variables over time. This allows the model to uncover not only the temporal causal relationships, but also the instantaneous dependencies that may exist between the latent factors.
The authors show that under certain assumptions, their method is able to recover the true causal structure and dynamics, even in the presence of instantaneous dependence, which is a common challenge in many real-world systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for causal representation learning in dynamical systems, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for future research:
-
The identifiability conditions required by the method may not always be satisfied in practice, particularly for high-dimensional or complex systems. Further work is needed to relax these assumptions.
-
The proposed algorithm relies on several hyperparameters and design choices, such as the specific causal discovery and state-space modeling techniques used. The sensitivity of the method to these choices is not fully explored.
-
The experiments are primarily conducted on relatively simple synthetic datasets and a few real-world benchmarks. Scaling the approach to larger, more realistic systems with noisy, incomplete, or heterogeneous data remains an open challenge.
-
The paper does not address the issue of model interpretability beyond the recovered causal structure. Developing more intuitive visualizations or explanations of the learned dynamical models could further enhance the practical utility of the method.
-
The theoretical analysis focuses on asymptotic guarantees, while the finite-sample performance and robustness to various practical constraints (e.g., limited data, model misspecification) deserve further investigation.
Despite these limitations, the core ideas presented in the paper represent an important step forward in the field of causal representation learning for dynamical systems. Addressing the identified challenges could lead to significant advancements in our ability to understand and model complex real-world phenomena.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach for identifying temporally causal representations with instantaneous dependence in dynamical systems. By combining techniques from causal representation learning and dynamical systems theory, the proposed method can uncover the underlying causal structure and dynamics that govern complex, time-varying data.
The key contributions of the work include a formal problem formulation, a practical algorithm, theoretical analysis, and experimental validation on both synthetic and real-world datasets. The approach represents an important step forward in our ability to extract interpretable, causal insights from high-dimensional, time-series data, with potential applications in fields like economics, neuroscience, and climate science.
While the method has several limitations that require further research, the core ideas presented in this paper lay the groundwork for advancing the state of the art in causal representation learning for dynamical systems, and ultimately, enhancing our understanding of the complex, interconnected phenomena that shape our world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
On the Recoverability of Causal Relations from Temporally Aggregated I.I.D. Data
Shunxing Fan, Mingming Gong, Kun Zhang
0
0
We consider the effect of temporal aggregation on instantaneous (non-temporal) causal discovery in general setting. This is motivated by the observation that the true causal time lag is often considerably shorter than the observational interval. This discrepancy leads to high aggregation, causing time-delay causality to vanish and instantaneous dependence to manifest. Although we expect such instantaneous dependence has consistency with the true causal relation in certain sense to make the discovery results meaningful, it remains unclear what type of consistency we need and when will such consistency be satisfied. We proposed functional consistency and conditional independence consistency in formal way correspond functional causal model-based methods and conditional independence-based methods respectively and provide the conditions under which these consistencies will hold. We show theoretically and experimentally that causal discovery results may be seriously distorted by aggregation especially in complete nonlinear case and we also find causal relationship still recoverable from aggregated data if we have partial linearity or appropriate prior. Our findings suggest community should take a cautious and meticulous approach when interpreting causal discovery results from such data and show why and when aggregation will distort the performance of causal discovery methods.
6/12/2024
CaRiNG: Learning Temporal Causal Representation under Non-Invertible Generation Process
Guangyi Chen, Yifan Shen, Zhenhao Chen, Xiangchen Song, Yuewen Sun, Weiran Yao, Xiao Liu, Kun Zhang
0
0
Identifying the underlying time-delayed latent causal processes in sequential data is vital for grasping temporal dynamics and making downstream reasoning. While some recent methods can robustly identify these latent causal variables, they rely on strict assumptions about the invertible generation process from latent variables to observed data. However, these assumptions are often hard to satisfy in real-world applications containing information loss. For instance, the visual perception process translates a 3D space into 2D images, or the phenomenon of persistence of vision incorporates historical data into current perceptions. To address this challenge, we establish an identifiability theory that allows for the recovery of independent latent components even when they come from a nonlinear and non-invertible mix. Using this theory as a foundation, we propose a principled approach, CaRiNG, to learn the CAusal RepresentatIon of Non-invertible Generative temporal data with identifiability guarantees. Specifically, we utilize temporal context to recover lost latent information and apply the conditions in our theory to guide the training process. Through experiments conducted on synthetic datasets, we validate that our CaRiNG method reliably identifies the causal process, even when the generation process is non-invertible. Moreover, we demonstrate that our approach considerably improves temporal understanding and reasoning in practical applications.
5/31/2024
A Sparsity Principle for Partially Observable Causal Representation Learning
Danru Xu, Dingling Yao, S'ebastien Lachapelle, Perouz Taslakian, Julius von Kugelgen, Francesco Locatello, Sara Magliacane
0
0
Causal representation learning aims at identifying high-level causal variables from perceptual data. Most methods assume that all latent causal variables are captured in the high-dimensional observations. We instead consider a partially observed setting, in which each measurement only provides information about a subset of the underlying causal state. Prior work has studied this setting with multiple domains or views, each depending on a fixed subset of latents. Here, we focus on learning from unpaired observations from a dataset with an instance-dependent partial observability pattern. Our main contribution is to establish two identifiability results for this setting: one for linear mixing functions without parametric assumptions on the underlying causal model, and one for piecewise linear mixing functions with Gaussian latent causal variables. Based on these insights, we propose two methods for estimating the underlying causal variables by enforcing sparsity in the inferred representation. Experiments on different simulated datasets and established benchmarks highlight the effectiveness of our approach in recovering the ground-truth latents.
6/18/2024
👀
Marrying Causal Representation Learning with Dynamical Systems for Science
Dingling Yao, Caroline Muller, Francesco Locatello
0
0
Causal representation learning promises to extend causal models to hidden causal variables from raw entangled measurements. However, most progress has focused on proving identifiability results in different settings, and we are not aware of any successful real-world application. At the same time, the field of dynamical systems benefited from deep learning and scaled to countless applications but does not allow parameter identification. In this paper, we draw a clear connection between the two and their key assumptions, allowing us to apply identifiable methods developed in causal representation learning to dynamical systems. At the same time, we can leverage scalable differentiable solvers developed for differential equations to build models that are both identifiable and practical. Overall, we learn explicitly controllable models that isolate the trajectory-specific parameters for further downstream tasks such as out-of-distribution classification or treatment effect estimation. We experiment with a wind simulator with partially known factors of variation. We also apply the resulting model to real-world climate data and successfully answer downstream causal questions in line with existing literature on climate change.
5/24/2024