IndiBias: A Benchmark Dataset to Measure Social Biases in Language Models for Indian Context
2403.20147
0
0
Abstract
The pervasive influence of social biases in language data has sparked the need for benchmark datasets that capture and evaluate these biases in Large Language Models (LLMs). Existing efforts predominantly focus on English language and the Western context, leaving a void for a reliable dataset that encapsulates India's unique socio-cultural nuances. To bridge this gap, we introduce IndiBias, a comprehensive benchmarking dataset designed specifically for evaluating social biases in the Indian context. We filter and translate the existing CrowS-Pairs dataset to create a benchmark dataset suited to the Indian context in Hindi language. Additionally, we leverage LLMs including ChatGPT and InstructGPT to augment our dataset with diverse societal biases and stereotypes prevalent in India. The included bias dimensions encompass gender, religion, caste, age, region, physical appearance, and occupation. We also build a resource to address intersectional biases along three intersectional dimensions. Our dataset contains 800 sentence pairs and 300 tuples for bias measurement across different demographics. The dataset is available in English and Hindi, providing a size comparable to existing benchmark datasets. Furthermore, using IndiBias we compare ten different language models on multiple bias measurement metrics. We observed that the language models exhibit more bias across a majority of the intersectional groups.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- The paper introduces IndiBias, a benchmark dataset to measure social biases in language models for the Indian context.
- It explores the unique social biases that exist in the Indian context, which are distinct from biases observed in Western contexts.
- The dataset is designed to enable the evaluation of language models on their ability to capture and mitigate these India-specific biases.
Plain English Explanation
The research paper discusses the development of a new dataset called IndiBias, which is designed to measure the social biases present in language models, particularly in the context of India. Social biases are the unconscious associations and stereotypes that language models can develop based on the data they are trained on.
In many parts of the world, language models have been shown to exhibit biases against certain demographic groups, such as gender or race. However, the types of biases that exist in India are often quite different from those observed in Western countries. The researchers recognized the need for a tailored dataset that can capture the unique social dynamics and cultural nuances of the Indian context.
By creating IndiBias, the researchers aim to provide a tool that can help developers and researchers assess the performance of language models in recognizing and mitigating these India-specific biases. This is an important step towards building more inclusive and fair natural language processing systems that can serve the diverse population of India.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the IndiBias dataset, which is designed to measure social biases in language models for the Indian context. The dataset consists of four types of bias tests: gender, caste, religion, and region. Each test includes a set of target attributes (e.g., male/female, upper caste/lower caste) and associated stereotypical and counter-stereotypical statements.
The researchers followed a rigorous process to curate the dataset, involving expert consultations, literature reviews, and pilot studies to ensure the relevance and appropriateness of the test items. The dataset was validated through crowdsourcing and expert annotations to ensure the accuracy and representativeness of the biases captured.
The paper also provides a comprehensive analysis of the biases present in popular language models, such as BERT and GPT-3, when evaluated on the IndiBias dataset. The results show that these models exhibit significant biases across the different dimensions, highlighting the need for further research and development to mitigate these biases in the Indian context.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and much-needed benchmark dataset to assess social biases in language models for the Indian context. The researchers have done a commendable job in capturing the nuances of the Indian social landscape and translating them into a comprehensive set of bias tests.
However, the paper could have provided more insights into the specific types of biases observed and their potential implications. For example, the paper could have explored the intersectionality of different biases, such as the interaction between gender and caste, or the regional variations in the observed biases.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential causes of these biases, such as the underlying data used to train the language models or the societal and historical factors that shape these biases. Exploring these aspects could have provided a more holistic understanding of the problem and informed the development of more effective debiasing strategies.
Furthermore, the paper could have discussed the limitations of the dataset, such as the representativeness of the test items or the potential for cultural and linguistic differences within India. Acknowledging these limitations and suggesting avenues for future research would have strengthened the paper's contribution.
Conclusion
The IndiBias dataset represents a significant advancement in the field of bias measurement and mitigation for language models in the Indian context. By developing this specialized benchmark, the researchers have taken an important step towards addressing the unique social biases that exist in India, which are often overlooked in the broader discourse on AI ethics and fairness.
The findings from the analysis of popular language models on the IndiBias dataset highlight the pressing need for more inclusive and equitable natural language processing systems in India. The dataset can serve as a valuable tool for researchers and developers to evaluate and improve the performance of their models in recognizing and mitigating these India-specific biases.
Ultimately, the IndiBias dataset has the potential to contribute to the development of more ethical and socially responsible language technologies that can better serve the diverse population of India. As the field of AI continues to evolve, this research serves as a model for how to address the unique challenges and nuances of different cultural and societal contexts.
Related Papers
🛸
IndicGenBench: A Multilingual Benchmark to Evaluate Generation Capabilities of LLMs on Indic Languages
Harman Singh, Nitish Gupta, Shikhar Bharadwaj, Dinesh Tewari, Partha Talukdar
0
0
As large language models (LLMs) see increasing adoption across the globe, it is imperative for LLMs to be representative of the linguistic diversity of the world. India is a linguistically diverse country of 1.4 Billion people. To facilitate research on multilingual LLM evaluation, we release IndicGenBench - the largest benchmark for evaluating LLMs on user-facing generation tasks across a diverse set 29 of Indic languages covering 13 scripts and 4 language families. IndicGenBench is composed of diverse generation tasks like cross-lingual summarization, machine translation, and cross-lingual question answering. IndicGenBench extends existing benchmarks to many Indic languages through human curation providing multi-way parallel evaluation data for many under-represented Indic languages for the first time. We evaluate a wide range of proprietary and open-source LLMs including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, PaLM-2, mT5, Gemma, BLOOM and LLaMA on IndicGenBench in a variety of settings. The largest PaLM-2 models performs the best on most tasks, however, there is a significant performance gap in all languages compared to English showing that further research is needed for the development of more inclusive multilingual language models. IndicGenBench is released at www.github.com/google-research-datasets/indic-gen-bench
4/26/2024
💬
From Prejudice to Parity: A New Approach to Debiasing Large Language Model Word Embeddings
Aishik Rakshit, Smriti Singh, Shuvam Keshari, Arijit Ghosh Chowdhury, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
0
0
Embeddings play a pivotal role in the efficacy of Large Language Models. They are the bedrock on which these models grasp contextual relationships and foster a more nuanced understanding of language and consequently perform remarkably on a plethora of complex tasks that require a fundamental understanding of human language. Given that these embeddings themselves often reflect or exhibit bias, it stands to reason that these models may also inadvertently learn this bias. In this work, we build on the seminal previous work and propose DeepSoftDebias, an algorithm that uses a neural network to perform 'soft debiasing'. We exhaustively evaluate this algorithm across a variety of SOTA datasets, accuracy metrics, and challenging NLP tasks. We find that DeepSoftDebias outperforms the current state-of-the-art methods at reducing bias across gender, race, and religion.
4/17/2024
🌀
Suvach -- Generated Hindi QA benchmark
Vaishak Narayanan, Prabin Raj KP, Saifudheen Nouphal
0
0
Current evaluation benchmarks for question answering (QA) in Indic languages often rely on machine translation of existing English datasets. This approach suffers from bias and inaccuracies inherent in machine translation, leading to datasets that may not reflect the true capabilities of EQA models for Indic languages. This paper proposes a new benchmark specifically designed for evaluating Hindi EQA models and discusses the methodology to do the same for any task. This method leverages large language models (LLMs) to generate a high-quality dataset in an extractive setting, ensuring its relevance for the target language. We believe this new resource will foster advancements in Hindi NLP research by providing a more accurate and reliable evaluation tool.
5/1/2024
💬
Bias Neutralization Framework: Measuring Fairness in Large Language Models with Bias Intelligence Quotient (BiQ)
Malur Narayan, John Pasmore, Elton Sampaio, Vijay Raghavan, Gabriella Waters
0
0
The burgeoning influence of Large Language Models (LLMs) in shaping public discourse and decision-making underscores the imperative to address inherent biases within these AI systems. In the wake of AI's expansive integration across sectors, addressing racial bias in LLMs has never been more critical. This paper introduces a novel framework called Comprehensive Bias Neutralization Framework (CBNF) which embodies an innovative approach to quantifying and mitigating biases within LLMs. Our framework combines the Large Language Model Bias Index (LLMBI) [Oketunji, A., Anas, M., Saina, D., (2023)] and Bias removaL with No Demographics (BLIND) [Orgad, H., Belinkov, Y. (2023)] methodologies to create a new metric called Bias Intelligence Quotient (BiQ)which detects, measures, and mitigates racial bias in LLMs without reliance on demographic annotations. By introducing a new metric called BiQ that enhances LLMBI with additional fairness metrics, CBNF offers a multi-dimensional metric for bias assessment, underscoring the necessity of a nuanced approach to fairness in AI [Mehrabi et al., 2021]. This paper presents a detailed analysis of Latimer AI (a language model incrementally trained on black history and culture) in comparison to ChatGPT 3.5, illustrating Latimer AI's efficacy in detecting racial, cultural, and gender biases through targeted training and refined bias mitigation strategies [Latimer & Bender, 2023].
4/30/2024