Inferring Pluggable Types with Machine Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores a machine learning approach to automatically infer pluggable types for programming languages.
- Pluggable types are a type system that can be easily added to existing programming languages to provide stronger static type checking.
- The researchers developed a neural network model that can learn to infer type annotations from existing type-annotated code, and then apply those inferences to unannotated code.
- The goal is to make it easier for developers to adopt pluggable type systems, which can improve code quality and reliability.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a technique to automatically add type checking to programming languages. Type checking is a way for a compiler or interpreter to verify that the values in a program match the expected data types, helping to catch errors early.
Many programming languages have type systems built-in, but developers often want more flexibility and control. Pluggable type systems allow programmers to add additional type checking rules on top of the base language. However, setting up a pluggable type system can be time-consuming and difficult.
The researchers developed a machine learning model that can automatically infer the type annotations needed for a pluggable type system, based on examples of code that already has those annotations. The model learns the patterns and rules underlying the type system, and then applies that knowledge to new code to add the appropriate type annotations.
This approach aims to make it much easier for developers to adopt pluggable type systems, without having to manually add all the type information themselves. By reducing the effort required, the hope is that more projects will be able to benefit from the increased code quality and reliability provided by enhanced type checking.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a neural network model for inferring pluggable types from existing type-annotated code. The model uses a graph neural network architecture to capture the structural and semantic relationships in code, along with a pre-trained language model to understand the meaning of code tokens.
The researchers trained the model on a dataset of open-source Python projects that use the mypy pluggable type system. The model learns to predict the appropriate type annotations for variables, function parameters, and return values, based on the surrounding code context.
Once trained, the model can then be applied to new, unannotated code to automatically infer the necessary type information for a pluggable type system. The experiments show that the model achieves high accuracy in predicting type annotations, outperforming baseline approaches.
The key insight is that machine learning can be used to effectively "learn" the rules and patterns of a pluggable type system, and then apply that knowledge to new code. This reduces the manual effort required to adopt and maintain a pluggable type system, potentially making it more feasible for a wider range of projects.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach, but also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. One key challenge is that the model's performance may depend on the specific pluggable type system used in the training data. Applying the model to a different type system, or even a different version of the same type system, could introduce errors.
Additionally, the paper focuses only on a single programming language (Python) and a single pluggable type system (mypy). It's unclear how well the approach would generalize to other languages or type systems, which may have very different rules and semantics.
Further research could explore techniques to make the model more robust and adaptable, such as few-shot learning or meta-learning approaches. Investigating ways to make the model more interpretable and explainable could also help users understand and trust the inferred type annotations.
Overall, the paper presents a compelling step towards making pluggable type systems more accessible and easier to adopt. However, more work is needed to fully realize the potential of this machine learning-based approach to type inference.
Conclusion
This paper explores the use of machine learning to automatically infer pluggable type annotations for programming languages. By training a neural network model on existing type-annotated code, the researchers have developed a technique that can apply those learned type rules to new, unannotated code.
The key benefit of this approach is that it can significantly reduce the manual effort required to set up and maintain a pluggable type system. This could make it more feasible for a wider range of software projects to adopt enhanced type checking, leading to improved code quality and reliability.
While the current implementation has some limitations, the paper demonstrates the potential of machine learning to streamline the adoption of advanced type systems. As the field of type inference continues to evolve, techniques like the one presented in this paper may become increasingly important for improving the overall quality and robustness of software systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Inferring Pluggable Types with Machine Learning
Kazi Amanul Islam Siddiqui, Martin Kellogg
Pluggable type systems allow programmers to extend the type system of a programming language to enforce semantic properties defined by the programmer. Pluggable type systems are difficult to deploy in legacy codebases because they require programmers to write type annotations manually. This paper investigates how to use machine learning to infer type qualifiers automatically. We propose a novel representation, NaP-AST, that encodes minimal dataflow hints for the effective inference of type qualifiers. We evaluate several model architectures for inferring type qualifiers, including Graph Transformer Network, Graph Convolutional Network and Large Language Model. We further validated these models by applying them to 12 open-source programs from a prior evaluation of the NullAway pluggable typechecker, lowering warnings in all but one unannotated project. We discovered that GTN shows the best performance, with a recall of .89 and precision of 0.6. Furthermore, we conduct a study to estimate the number of Java classes needed for good performance of the trained model. For our feasibility study, performance improved around 16k classes, and deteriorated due to overfitting around 22k classes.
Read more6/26/2024
0
Improving Autoformalization using Type Checking
Auguste Poiroux, Gail Weiss, Viktor Kunv{c}ak, Antoine Bosselut
Large language models show promise for autoformalization, the task of automatically translating natural language into formal languages. However, current autoformalization methods remain limited. The last reported state-of-the-art performance on the ProofNet formalization benchmark for the Lean proof assistant, achieved using Codex for Lean 3, only showed successful formalization of 16.1% of informal statements. Similarly, our evaluation of GPT-4o for Lean 4 only produces successful translations 34.9% of the time. Our analysis shows that the performance of these models is largely limited by their inability to generate formal statements that successfully type-check (i.e., are syntactically correct and consistent with types) - with a whopping 86.6% of GPT-4o errors starting from a type-check failure. In this work, we propose a method to fix this issue through decoding with type-check filtering, where we initially sample a diverse set of candidate formalizations for an informal statement, then use the Lean proof assistant to filter out candidates that do not type-check. Using GPT-4o as a base model, and combining our method with self-consistency, we obtain a +18.3% absolute increase in formalization accuracy, and achieve a new state-of-the-art of 53.2% on ProofNet with Lean 4.
Read more6/12/2024
0
Activation Steering for Robust Type Prediction in CodeLLMs
Francesca Lucchetti, Arjun Guha
CodeLLMs are transforming software development as we know it. This is especially true for tasks where rule-based approaches fall short, like type prediction. The type prediction task consists in adding a new type annotation to a partially typed program, such that the resulting program is closer to being fully typed. The intractability of rule-based approaches and high cost of manual annotation make CodeLLMs an attractive solution to the problem. However, CodeLLMs are still far from being deployed on the large-scale due to doubts surrounding their reliability. To shed some light on how CodeLLMs approach type prediction, we investigate what happens when a model mispredicts a type. We show that by applying semantics-preserving edits to code, CodeLLMs are eventually misled into mispredicting type annotations. However, by leveraging activation steering we are able to steer the model back to the correct prediction, making models more robust against semantically irrelevant prompt features. We show that steering achieves comparable performance to fine-tuning directly on the type prediction task. Furthermore, we find that steering vectors computed from Python code are effective at correcting TypeScript mispredictions, and vice versa. To our knowledge, this is the first evidence of its kind to suggest that CodeLLMs learn task representations that transfer across languages.
Read more9/16/2024
💬
0
OntoType: Ontology-Guided and Pre-Trained Language Model Assisted Fine-Grained Entity Typing
Tanay Komarlu, Minhao Jiang, Xuan Wang, Jiawei Han
Fine-grained entity typing (FET), which assigns entities in text with context-sensitive, fine-grained semantic types, is a basic but important task for knowledge extraction from unstructured text. FET has been studied extensively in natural language processing and typically relies on human-annotated corpora for training, which is costly and difficult to scale. Recent studies explore the utilization of pre-trained language models (PLMs) as a knowledge base to generate rich and context-aware weak supervision for FET. However, a PLM still requires direction and guidance to serve as a knowledge base as they often generate a mixture of rough and fine-grained types, or tokens unsuitable for typing. In this study, we vision that an ontology provides a semantics-rich, hierarchical structure, which will help select the best results generated by multiple PLM models and head words. Specifically, we propose a novel annotation-free, ontology-guided FET method, OntoType, which follows a type ontological structure, from coarse to fine, ensembles multiple PLM prompting results to generate a set of type candidates, and refines its type resolution, under the local context with a natural language inference model. Our experiments on the Ontonotes, FIGER, and NYT datasets using their associated ontological structures demonstrate that our method outperforms the state-of-the-art zero-shot fine-grained entity typing methods as well as a typical LLM method, ChatGPT. Our error analysis shows that refinement of the existing ontology structures will further improve fine-grained entity typing.
Read more6/12/2024