Interaction as Explanation: A User Interaction-based Method for Explaining Image Classification Models
2404.09828
0
0
Abstract
In computer vision, explainable AI (xAI) methods seek to mitigate the 'black-box' problem by making the decision-making process of deep learning models more interpretable and transparent. Traditional xAI methods concentrate on visualizing input features that influence model predictions, providing insights primarily suited for experts. In this work, we present an interaction-based xAI method that enhances user comprehension of image classification models through their interaction. Thus, we developed a web-based prototype allowing users to modify images via painting and erasing, thereby observing changes in classification results. Our approach enables users to discern critical features influencing the model's decision-making process, aligning their mental models with the model's logic. Experiments conducted with five images demonstrate the potential of the method to reveal feature importance through user interaction. Our work contributes a novel perspective to xAI by centering on end-user engagement and understanding, paving the way for more intuitive and accessible explainability in AI systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new method for explaining image classification models using interactive user interactions.
- The proposed approach, called "Interaction-based xAI", allows users to explore and understand the model's decision-making process by interacting with the input image.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method through user studies and comparisons with existing explainability techniques.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a novel way to explain how image classification models make their decisions. Typically, these models are "black boxes" - it's hard to understand why they classify an image in a certain way. The new "Interaction-based xAI" method gives users a way to interact with the model and see how it is making its decisions.
In this approach, users can click on different parts of the input image, and the model will highlight the relevant features it is using to classify the image. This allows users to explore the model's reasoning step-by-step and gain a better understanding of how it works.
The authors show through user studies that this interactive approach is more effective at helping people understand the model's behavior, compared to existing explainability techniques. By allowing users to actively explore the model's decision-making process, the Interaction-based xAI method makes the "black box" a bit more transparent.
This type of interactive explainability is an important advance, as it can help build trust in AI systems and allow users to better understand how the models they rely on are reaching their conclusions. The work connects to other efforts in the field of explainable AI that aim to make AI systems more interpretable and interactive.
Technical Explanation
The core of the Interaction-based xAI method is an architecture that allows users to interactively explore an image classification model. When a user clicks on a part of the input image, the system highlights the relevant features that the model is using to classify that region.
This is achieved by integrating the classification model with an explanation module that can generate saliency maps - visual heatmaps that indicate the importance of different image regions for the model's predictions. By linking the user's interactions to the generation of these saliency maps, the system provides a way for users to understand the model's decision-making process.
The authors evaluate their approach through user studies, where participants are asked to use the interactive interface to explore image classification models. The results show that users are able to gain a better understanding of the model's behavior compared to traditional static explanation techniques, like feature importance visualizations.
Furthermore, the authors demonstrate that the Interaction-based xAI method can lead to more memorable and incremental understanding of the model, as users can actively explore and build their knowledge over time.
Critical Analysis
The Interaction-based xAI method presented in this paper is a promising approach to making image classification models more interpretable and transparent. By allowing users to directly interact with the model and see how it is making decisions, the technique addresses an important gap in existing explainability methods.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the limitations or potential issues with this approach. For example, the user studies only evaluate the method on a relatively small set of images and models. More research is needed to understand how well the technique scales to more complex models and real-world datasets.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential biases or inaccuracies that could arise in the generated saliency maps, which are a critical component of the interactive explanation. Further evaluation of the explainability attributes and robustness of the saliency maps would help strengthen the claims about the method's effectiveness.
Nevertheless, the Interaction-based xAI approach represents an important step forward in making AI systems more transparent and interpretable. By empowering users to actively explore and understand the model's decision-making, this work contributes to the broader goal of building trust and accountability in AI.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel method called "Interaction-based xAI" that allows users to interactively explore and understand the decision-making process of image classification models. By enabling users to click on parts of the input image and see the relevant features the model is using, the technique provides a more transparent and engaging way to explain the model's behavior.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through user studies, showing that it can lead to better understanding and more memorable explanations compared to traditional static explainability techniques. This work contributes to the growing field of explainable AI, which aims to make machine learning models more interpretable and trustworthy.
As AI systems become increasingly influential in our lives, developing methods like Interaction-based xAI that empower users to understand and engage with these models is crucial. This research represents an important step towards building AI systems that are not only powerful, but also transparent and accountable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Explainable Interfaces for Rapid Gaze-Based Interactions in Mixed Reality
Mengjie Yu, Dustin Harris, Ian Jones, Ting Zhang, Yue Liu, Naveen Sendhilnathan, Narine Kokhlikyan, Fulton Wang, Co Tran, Jordan L. Livingston, Krista E. Taylor, Zhenhong Hu, Mary A. Hood, Hrvoje Benko, Tanya R. Jonker
0
0
Gaze-based interactions offer a potential way for users to naturally engage with mixed reality (XR) interfaces. Black-box machine learning models enabled higher accuracy for gaze-based interactions. However, due to the black-box nature of the model, users might not be able to understand and effectively adapt their gaze behaviour to achieve high quality interaction. We posit that explainable AI (XAI) techniques can facilitate understanding of and interaction with gaze-based model-driven system in XR. To study this, we built a real-time, multi-level XAI interface for gaze-based interaction using a deep learning model, and evaluated it during a visual search task in XR. A between-subjects study revealed that participants who interacted with XAI made more accurate selections compared to those who did not use the XAI system (i.e., F1 score increase of 10.8%). Additionally, participants who used the XAI system adapted their gaze behavior over time to make more effective selections. These findings suggest that XAI can potentially be used to assist users in more effective collaboration with model-driven interactions in XR.
4/23/2024
🛠️
Human-AI Interaction in Industrial Robotics: Design and Empirical Evaluation of a User Interface for Explainable AI-Based Robot Program Optimization
Benjamin Alt, Johannes Zahn, Claudius Kienle, Julia Dvorak, Marvin May, Darko Katic, Rainer Jakel, Tobias Kopp, Michael Beetz, Gisela Lanza
0
0
While recent advances in deep learning have demonstrated its transformative potential, its adoption for real-world manufacturing applications remains limited. We present an Explanation User Interface (XUI) for a state-of-the-art deep learning-based robot program optimizer which provides both naive and expert users with different user experiences depending on their skill level, as well as Explainable AI (XAI) features to facilitate the application of deep learning methods in real-world applications. To evaluate the impact of the XUI on task performance, user satisfaction and cognitive load, we present the results of a preliminary user survey and propose a study design for a large-scale follow-up study.
5/1/2024
Privacy Implications of Explainable AI in Data-Driven Systems
Fatima Ezzeddine
0
0
Machine learning (ML) models, demonstrably powerful, suffer from a lack of interpretability. The absence of transparency, often referred to as the black box nature of ML models, undermines trust and urges the need for efforts to enhance their explainability. Explainable AI (XAI) techniques address this challenge by providing frameworks and methods to explain the internal decision-making processes of these complex models. Techniques like Counterfactual Explanations (CF) and Feature Importance play a crucial role in achieving this goal. Furthermore, high-quality and diverse data remains the foundational element for robust and trustworthy ML applications. In many applications, the data used to train ML and XAI explainers contain sensitive information. In this context, numerous privacy-preserving techniques can be employed to safeguard sensitive information in the data, such as differential privacy. Subsequently, a conflict between XAI and privacy solutions emerges due to their opposing goals. Since XAI techniques provide reasoning for the model behavior, they reveal information relative to ML models, such as their decision boundaries, the values of features, or the gradients of deep learning models when explanations are exposed to a third entity. Attackers can initiate privacy breaching attacks using these explanations, to perform model extraction, inference, and membership attacks. This dilemma underscores the challenge of finding the right equilibrium between understanding ML decision-making and safeguarding privacy.
6/26/2024
The future of human-centric eXplainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) is not post-hoc explanations
Vinitra Swamy, Jibril Frej, Tanja Kaser
0
0
Explainable Artificial Intelligence (XAI) plays a crucial role in enabling human understanding and trust in deep learning systems. As models get larger, more ubiquitous, and pervasive in aspects of daily life, explainability is necessary to minimize adverse effects of model mistakes. Unfortunately, current approaches in human-centric XAI (e.g. predictive tasks in healthcare, education, or personalized ads) tend to rely on a single post-hoc explainer, whereas recent work has identified systematic disagreement between post-hoc explainers when applied to the same instances of underlying black-box models. In this paper, we therefore present a call for action to address the limitations of current state-of-the-art explainers. We propose a shift from post-hoc explainability to designing interpretable neural network architectures. We identify five needs of human-centric XAI (real-time, accurate, actionable, human-interpretable, and consistent) and propose two schemes for interpretable-by-design neural network workflows (adaptive routing with InterpretCC and temporal diagnostics with I2MD). We postulate that the future of human-centric XAI is neither in explaining black-boxes nor in reverting to traditional, interpretable models, but in neural networks that are intrinsically interpretable.
5/29/2024