Introducing a Class-Aware Metric for Monocular Depth Estimation: An Automotive Perspective
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a new class-aware metric for evaluating monocular depth estimation, with a focus on automotive applications
- Provides insights on how current depth evaluation metrics can be improved to better reflect real-world safety requirements
- Demonstrates the metric's advantages over existing methods through comprehensive experiments
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new way to evaluate the performance of monocular depth estimation models, which are algorithms that can estimate the 3D depth of a scene using a single camera. The key insight is that not all depth errors are equally important - for example, underestimating the depth of a nearby obstacle is much more dangerous than overestimating the depth of a distant object.
The proposed class-aware metric takes this into account by weighting depth errors based on the semantic class of the object (e.g., car, pedestrian, road). This better reflects the real-world safety requirements in automotive applications, where depth estimation is crucial for tasks like collision avoidance and autonomous driving.
The authors show that their metric provides a more meaningful evaluation of depth estimation models compared to existing methods, which treat all depth errors equally. They demonstrate this through extensive experiments on several popular depth estimation datasets.
Technical Explanation
The paper first reviews the limitations of current depth evaluation metrics, such as Absolute Relative Error and Scale-Invariant Log RMSE, which do not consider the semantic context of the depth estimates.
To address this, the authors propose a class-aware metric that assigns different weights to depth errors based on the class of the object. The weights are learned from real-world accident data, reflecting the varying importance of depth estimation accuracy for different object classes.
The paper then evaluates the proposed metric on several popular depth estimation datasets, including NYUv2 and KITTI, and compares it to existing methods. The results show that the class-aware metric provides a more meaningful assessment of depth estimation performance, especially for safety-critical automotive applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the need to consider semantic context in depth estimation evaluation, and the proposed class-aware metric is a promising step in this direction. However, the authors acknowledge that the current implementation relies on pre-defined object class weights, which may not capture the full complexity of real-world safety priorities.
Further research could explore more dynamic or data-driven approaches to determining these weights, potentially incorporating additional factors such as object velocity, occlusion, and scene layout. Additionally, the evaluation could be expanded to more diverse datasets and real-world driving scenarios to assess the metric's broader applicability.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an important new direction for depth estimation evaluation, highlighting the need to move beyond one-size-fits-all metrics and instead consider the specific safety requirements of the target application. The proposed class-aware metric provides a more meaningful assessment of depth estimation performance, with significant potential to improve the development of safe and reliable depth perception systems for autonomous vehicles and other safety-critical applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Introducing a Class-Aware Metric for Monocular Depth Estimation: An Automotive Perspective
Tim Bader, Leon Eisemann, Adrian Pogorzelski, Namrata Jangid, Attila-Balazs Kis
The increasing accuracy reports of metric monocular depth estimation models lead to a growing interest from the automotive domain. Current model evaluations do not provide deeper insights into the models' performance, also in relation to safety-critical or unseen classes. Within this paper, we present a novel approach for the evaluation of depth estimation models. Our proposed metric leverages three components, a class-wise component, an edge and corner image feature component, and a global consistency retaining component. Classes are further weighted on their distance in the scene and on criticality for automotive applications. In the evaluation, we present the benefits of our metric through comparison to classical metrics, class-wise analytics, and the retrieval of critical situations. The results show that our metric provides deeper insights into model results while fulfilling safety-critical requirements. We release the code and weights on the following repository: https://github.com/leisemann/ca_mmde
Read more9/14/2024
0
New!Radar Meets Vision: Robustifying Monocular Metric Depth Prediction for Mobile Robotics
Marco Job, Thomas Stastny, Tim Kazik, Roland Siegwart, Michael Pantic
Mobile robots require accurate and robust depth measurements to understand and interact with the environment. While existing sensing modalities address this problem to some extent, recent research on monocular depth estimation has leveraged the information richness, yet low cost and simplicity of monocular cameras. These works have shown significant generalization capabilities, mainly in automotive and indoor settings. However, robots often operate in environments with limited scale cues, self-similar appearances, and low texture. In this work, we encode measurements from a low-cost mmWave radar into the input space of a state-of-the-art monocular depth estimation model. Despite the radar's extreme point cloud sparsity, our method demonstrates generalization and robustness across industrial and outdoor experiments. Our approach reduces the absolute relative error of depth predictions by 9-64% across a range of unseen, real-world validation datasets. Importantly, we maintain consistency of all performance metrics across all experiments and scene depths where current vision-only approaches fail. We further address the present deficit of training data in mobile robotics environments by introducing a novel methodology for synthesizing rendered, realistic learning datasets based on photogrammetric data that simulate the radar sensor observations for training. Our code, datasets, and pre-trained networks are made available at https://github.com/ethz-asl/radarmeetsvision.
Read more10/2/2024
0
New!Depth Pro: Sharp Monocular Metric Depth in Less Than a Second
Aleksei Bochkovskii, Amael Delaunoy, Hugo Germain, Marcel Santos, Yichao Zhou, Stephan R. Richter, Vladlen Koltun
We present a foundation model for zero-shot metric monocular depth estimation. Our model, Depth Pro, synthesizes high-resolution depth maps with unparalleled sharpness and high-frequency details. The predictions are metric, with absolute scale, without relying on the availability of metadata such as camera intrinsics. And the model is fast, producing a 2.25-megapixel depth map in 0.3 seconds on a standard GPU. These characteristics are enabled by a number of technical contributions, including an efficient multi-scale vision transformer for dense prediction, a training protocol that combines real and synthetic datasets to achieve high metric accuracy alongside fine boundary tracing, dedicated evaluation metrics for boundary accuracy in estimated depth maps, and state-of-the-art focal length estimation from a single image. Extensive experiments analyze specific design choices and demonstrate that Depth Pro outperforms prior work along multiple dimensions. We release code and weights at https://github.com/apple/ml-depth-pro
Read more10/4/2024
0
TanDepth: Leveraging Global DEMs for Metric Monocular Depth Estimation in UAVs
Horatiu Florea, Sergiu Nedevschi
Aerial scene understanding systems face stringent payload restrictions and must often rely on monocular depth estimation for modelling scene geometry, which is an inherently ill-posed problem. Moreover, obtaining accurate ground truth data required by learning-based methods raises significant additional challenges in the aerial domain. Self-supervised approaches can bypass this problem, at the cost of providing only up-to-scale results. Similarly, recent supervised solutions which make good progress towards zero-shot generalization also provide only relative depth values. This work presents TanDepth, a practical, online scale recovery method for obtaining metric depth results from relative estimations at inference-time, irrespective of the type of model generating them. Tailored for Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) applications, our method leverages sparse measurements from Global Digital Elevation Models (GDEM) by projecting them to the camera view using extrinsic and intrinsic information. An adaptation to the Cloth Simulation Filter is presented, which allows selecting ground points from the estimated depth map to then correlate with the projected reference points. We evaluate and compare our method against alternate scaling methods adapted for UAVs, on a variety of real-world scenes. Considering the limited availability of data for this domain, we construct and release a comprehensive, depth-focused extension to the popular UAVid dataset to further research.
Read more9/10/2024