Investigating the Generalizability of Assistive Robots Models over Various Tasks
2405.02492
0
0
Abstract
In the domain of assistive robotics, the significance of effective modeling is well acknowledged. Prior research has primarily focused on enhancing model accuracy or involved the collection of extensive, often impractical amounts of data. While improving individual model accuracy is beneficial, it necessitates constant remodeling for each new task and user interaction. In this paper, we investigate the generalizability of different modeling methods. We focus on constructing the dynamic model of an assistive exoskeleton using six data-driven regression algorithms. Six tasks are considered in our experiments, including horizontal, vertical, diagonal from left leg to the right eye and the opposite, as well as eating and pushing. We constructed thirty-six unique models applying different regression methods to data gathered from each task. Each trained model's performance was evaluated in a cross-validation scenario, utilizing five folds for each dataset. These trained models are then tested on the other tasks that the model is not trained with. Finally the models in our study are assessed in terms of generalizability. Results show the superior generalizability of the task model performed along the horizontal plane, and decision tree based algorithms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates the ability of assistive robot models to generalize across different tasks.
- The researchers explore how well these models can be applied to a variety of real-world scenarios, beyond the specific tasks they were trained on.
- The goal is to assess the broader applicability and flexibility of assistive robot technologies.
Plain English Explanation
Assistive robot models are designed to help people with various tasks, such as fetching objects, opening doors, or navigating around the home. However, it's not always clear how well these models can adapt to different situations beyond their original training. This paper investigates the "generalizability" of assistive robot models - their ability to perform well across a range of tasks, not just the specific ones they were built for.
The researchers wanted to see how these models would fare when applied to new scenarios that may be quite different from the ones they were trained on. By testing the models' performance on a variety of tasks, they can better understand the strengths and limitations of the technology and how it might be improved to be more versatile and useful in the real world.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents an empirical study that evaluates the generalization capabilities of assistive robot models across multiple task domains. The researchers collected data on the models' performance on a diverse set of tasks, including object manipulation, navigation, and interaction with humans.
By analyzing the models' behavior and outcomes on this broad range of tasks, the researchers were able to assess the extent to which the models' learned skills and knowledge could be applied to novel situations. The findings provide insights into the generalizability of assistive robot technologies and identify areas where further development is needed to improve their versatility and real-world applicability.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges several limitations of the study, including the relatively small number of tasks and models evaluated. The researchers also note that the performance of the models may be influenced by factors such as the quality and diversity of the training data, as well as the specific architectural choices and learning algorithms employed.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the underlying reasons for why certain models may generalize better than others. Further research would be needed to uncover the key factors that contribute to the generalizability of assistive robot technologies.
Overall, the study represents an important step in understanding the capabilities and limitations of current assistive robot models, and it highlights the need for continued work to develop more flexible and adaptable systems that can reliably assist humans in a wide range of real-world scenarios.
Conclusion
This paper provides a valuable empirical investigation into the generalization capabilities of assistive robot models across a variety of tasks. The findings suggest that while these models can exhibit impressive performance on specific, well-defined tasks, their ability to generalize to novel situations is still limited in many cases.
The insights gained from this research can help guide the development of more versatile and adaptable assistive robot technologies, which could have significant implications for improving the quality of life and independence of individuals in need of such support. Continued advancements in this area have the potential to greatly enhance the real-world practicality and impact of assistive robotics.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Robustness Testing of Multi-Modal Models in Varied Home Environments for Assistive Robots
Lea Hirlimann, Shengqiang Zhang, Hinrich Schutze, Philipp Wicke
0
0
The development of assistive robotic agents to support household tasks is advancing, yet the underlying models often operate in virtual settings that do not reflect real-world complexity. For assistive care robots to be effective in diverse environments, their models must be robust and integrate multiple modalities. Consider a caretaker needing assistance in a dimly lit room or navigating around a newly installed glass door. Models relying solely on visual input might fail in low light, while those using depth information could avoid the door. This demonstrates the necessity for models that can process various sensory inputs. Our ongoing study evaluates state-of-the-art robotic models in the AI2Thor virtual environment. We introduce disturbances, such as dimmed lighting and mirrored walls, to assess their impact on modalities like movement or vision, and object recognition. Our goal is to gather input from the Geriatronics community to understand and model the challenges faced by practitioners.
6/21/2024
RoboCoder: Robotic Learning from Basic Skills to General Tasks with Large Language Models
Jingyao Li, Pengguang Chen, Sitong Wu, Chuanyang Zheng, Hong Xu, Jiaya Jia
0
0
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has improved the prospects for robotic tasks. However, existing benchmarks are still limited to single tasks with limited generalization capabilities. In this work, we introduce a comprehensive benchmark and an autonomous learning framework, RoboCoder aimed at enhancing the generalization capabilities of robots in complex environments. Unlike traditional methods that focus on single-task learning, our research emphasizes the development of a general-purpose robotic coding algorithm that enables robots to leverage basic skills to tackle increasingly complex tasks. The newly proposed benchmark consists of 80 manually designed tasks across 7 distinct entities, testing the models' ability to learn from minimal initial mastery. Initial testing revealed that even advanced models like GPT-4 could only achieve a 47% pass rate in three-shot scenarios with humanoid entities. To address these limitations, the RoboCoder framework integrates Large Language Models (LLMs) with a dynamic learning system that uses real-time environmental feedback to continuously update and refine action codes. This adaptive method showed a remarkable improvement, achieving a 36% relative improvement. Our codes will be released.
6/7/2024
🌿
What Foundation Models can Bring for Robot Learning in Manipulation : A Survey
Dingzhe Li, Yixiang Jin, Yong A, Hongze Yu, Jun Shi, Xiaoshuai Hao, Peng Hao, Huaping Liu, Fuchun Sun, Bin Fang
0
0
The realization of universal robots is an ultimate goal of researchers. However, a key hurdle in achieving this goal lies in the robots' ability to manipulate objects in their unstructured surrounding environments according to different tasks. The learning-based approach is considered an effective way to address generalization. The impressive performance of foundation models in the fields of computer vision and natural language suggests the potential of embedding foundation models into manipulation tasks as a viable path toward achieving general manipulation capability. However, we believe achieving general manipulation capability requires an overarching framework akin to auto driving. This framework should encompass multiple functional modules, with different foundation models assuming distinct roles in facilitating general manipulation capability. This survey focuses on the contributions of foundation models to robot learning for manipulation. We propose a comprehensive framework and detail how foundation models can address challenges in each module of the framework. What's more, we examine current approaches, outline challenges, suggest future research directions, and identify potential risks associated with integrating foundation models into this domain.
4/30/2024
🗣️
Human Behavior Modeling via Identification of Task Objective and Variability
Sooyung Byeon, Dawei Sun, Inseok Hwang
0
0
Human behavior modeling is important for the design and implementation of human-automation interactive control systems. In this context, human behavior refers to a human's control input to systems. We propose a novel method for human behavior modeling that uses human demonstrations for a given task to infer the unknown task objective and the variability. The task objective represents the human's intent or desire. It can be inferred by the inverse optimal control and improve the understanding of human behavior by providing an explainable objective function behind the given human behavior. Meanwhile, the variability denotes the intrinsic uncertainty in human behavior. It can be described by a Gaussian mixture model and capture the uncertainty in human behavior which cannot be encoded by the task objective. The proposed method can improve the prediction accuracy of human behavior by leveraging both task objective and variability. The proposed method is demonstrated through human-subject experiments using an illustrative quadrotor remote control example.
4/24/2024