Joint Optimization of Piecewise Linear Ensembles

Overview

• Tree ensembles like Gradient Boosting (GB) and Random Forests (RF) achieve state-of-the-art performance despite being greedily optimized.
• Global Refinement (GR) reduces greediness by jointly and globally optimizing all constant leaves.
• The paper proposes a piecewise-linear extension of GR called Joint Optimization of Piecewise Linear ENsembles (JOPLEN).

Plain English Explanation

Tree-based models like Gradient Boosting and Random Forests are very powerful machine learning techniques. However, they are greedily optimized, meaning they make local decisions that may not lead to the best global solution.

Global Refinement (GR) tries to address this by jointly and globally optimizing all the constant leaves in the trees. This helps reduce the greediness of the models.

The researchers propose a new method called JOPLEN that extends GR to use piecewise-linear functions instead of just constant leaves. This makes the models more flexible and allows them to apply common penalties like promoting sparsity or encouraging smooth, subspace-aligned functions.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces Joint Optimization of Piecewise Linear ENsembles (JOPLEN), a piecewise-linear extension of the Global Refinement (GR) algorithm. Compared to GR, JOPLEN improves model flexibility and can apply common penalties, including sparsity-promoting matrix norms and subspace-norms, to nonlinear prediction.

The authors evaluate JOPLEN with the Frobenius norm, $\ell_{2,1}$ norm, and Laplacian regularization on 146 regression and classification datasets. They find that JOPLEN, combined with GB trees and RF, achieves superior performance in both settings. Additionally, JOPLEN with a nuclear norm penalty empirically learns smooth and subspace-aligned functions.

The paper also extends the Dirty LASSO to perform multitask feature selection with JOPLEN. This JOPLEN Dirty LASSO achieves a superior feature sparsity/performance tradeoff compared to linear and gradient boosted approaches.

Critical Analysis

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the JOPLEN approach, but it does not extensively explore the limitations or potential downsides. For example, the increased model flexibility and added regularization could make JOPLEN more prone to overfitting on smaller datasets or in high-dimensional settings.

Additionally, the computational complexity of the joint optimization process is not discussed in detail. As the number of trees and leaves grows, the optimization may become prohibitively expensive, limiting the scalability of the method.

Further research could investigate the robustness of JOPLEN to noisy or missing data, as well as its performance on a wider range of real-world problems beyond the 146 datasets considered in the paper. Comparisons to other state-of-the-art regularized tree ensemble methods would also help contextualize the contributions of JOPLEN.

Conclusion

The JOPLEN method proposed in this paper represents an interesting and promising extension of the Global Refinement approach for tree ensembles. By incorporating piecewise-linear functions and advanced regularization techniques, JOPLEN can achieve superior performance on both regression and classification tasks compared to traditional tree-based models.

The ability to learn smooth, subspace-aligned functions and perform effective multitask feature selection suggests that JOPLEN could have valuable applications in a variety of fields, from value approximation in differential games to decentralized online learning. Further development and testing of JOPLEN could lead to significant advancements in the performance and interpretability of tree-based machine learning models.