Koopman-Based Surrogate Modelling of Turbulent Rayleigh-B'enard Convection

Read original: arXiv:2405.06425 - Published 5/13/2024 by Thorben Markmann, Michiel Straat, Barbara Hammer

Koopman-Based Surrogate Modelling of Turbulent Rayleigh-B'enard Convection

Overview

This paper presents a Koopman-based surrogate modeling approach for simulating turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection, a type of fluid flow driven by temperature differences.
The authors leverage Koopman theory, which provides a framework for analyzing the dynamics of nonlinear systems, to develop a reduced-order model that can accurately capture the complex behavior of the fluid flow.
The proposed method is demonstrated on a numerical simulation of turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection, showing its ability to predict the fluid dynamics with high fidelity while significantly reducing computational costs compared to the full-order model.

Plain English Explanation

Imagine you have a pot of water on the stove, and the bottom of the pot is hotter than the top. As the water heats up, it starts to swirl and move in complex, chaotic patterns - this is called Rayleigh-Bénard convection, and it's a common phenomenon in fluid dynamics.

The researchers in this paper wanted to find a way to simulate and predict this turbulent fluid behavior without having to do a full, computationally intensive simulation. They used a mathematical technique called Koopman theory, which helps analyze the dynamics of nonlinear systems like the swirling water in the pot.

By applying Koopman theory, the researchers were able to create a simplified, "reduced-order" model that could accurately mimic the complex fluid behavior, but with much less computational power required. This type of surrogate model can be very useful in situations where you need to quickly predict or simulate fluid flow, such as in engineering design or weather forecasting.

The researchers demonstrated their Koopman-based approach on a numerical simulation of turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection, showing that it could capture the key features of the fluid dynamics while being much more efficient than the full-scale simulation.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a Koopman-based surrogate modeling approach for simulating turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection, a type of fluid flow driven by temperature differences. Koopman theory provides a framework for analyzing the dynamics of nonlinear systems, and the authors leverage this to develop a reduced-order model that can accurately capture the complex behavior of the fluid flow.

The proposed method involves first performing a full-order simulation of the turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection using computational fluid dynamics (CFD). The resulting data is then used to learn a Koopman operator, which describes the evolution of the system's observables over time. This Koopman operator is used to construct a surrogate model that can predict the fluid dynamics with high fidelity, but at a significantly reduced computational cost compared to the full-order CFD simulation.

The effectiveness of the Koopman-based surrogate model is demonstrated on a numerical simulation of turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection. The results show that the surrogate model can accurately capture the key features of the fluid flow, such as the formation of convection cells and the chaotic, time-dependent behavior of the system. Moreover, the computational cost of the surrogate model is much lower than the full-order CFD simulation, making it a promising approach for applications where rapid fluid flow simulations are required, such as in engineering design or weather forecasting.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach for developing surrogate models of complex, turbulent fluid systems using Koopman theory. The authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their method on a numerical simulation of Rayleigh-Bénard convection, showing that the Koopman-based surrogate model can accurately capture the key features of the fluid dynamics while significantly reducing the computational cost.

However, it is important to note that the paper is focused on a specific fluid system (Rayleigh-Bénard convection) and its applicability to other types of fluid flows or more complex scenarios is not explicitly addressed. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential limitations of the Koopman-based approach, such as the assumptions or constraints that may be required for the method to work effectively.

Further research could explore the generalization of this approach to a wider range of fluid dynamics problems, as well as investigate the robustness of the Koopman-based surrogate models to uncertainties or variations in the underlying system. Nonetheless, the work presented in this paper represents a valuable contribution to the field of reduced-order modeling and the application of Koopman theory to fluid dynamics problems.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a Koopman-based surrogate modeling approach for simulating turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection, a type of fluid flow driven by temperature differences. The authors leverage Koopman theory, which provides a framework for analyzing the dynamics of nonlinear systems, to develop a reduced-order model that can accurately capture the complex behavior of the fluid flow while significantly reducing the computational cost compared to a full-order simulation.

The proposed method is demonstrated on a numerical simulation of turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection, showcasing the ability of the Koopman-based surrogate model to predict the fluid dynamics with high fidelity. This type of surrogate modeling technique has the potential to be widely applicable in engineering design, weather forecasting, and other fields where rapid and accurate fluid flow simulations are required.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Koopman-Based Surrogate Modelling of Turbulent Rayleigh-B'enard Convection

Thorben Markmann, Michiel Straat, Barbara Hammer

Several related works have introduced Koopman-based Machine Learning architectures as a surrogate model for dynamical systems. These architectures aim to learn non-linear measurements (also known as observables) of the system's state that evolve by a linear operator and are, therefore, amenable to model-based linear control techniques. So far, mainly simple systems have been targeted, and Koopman architectures as reduced-order models for more complex dynamics have not been fully explored. Hence, we use a Koopman-inspired architecture called the Linear Recurrent Autoencoder Network (LRAN) for learning reduced-order dynamics in convection flows of a Rayleigh B'enard Convection (RBC) system at different amounts of turbulence. The data is obtained from direct numerical simulations of the RBC system. A traditional fluid dynamics method, the Kernel Dynamic Mode Decomposition (KDMD), is used to compare the LRAN. For both methods, we performed hyperparameter sweeps to identify optimal settings. We used a Normalized Sum of Square Error measure for the quantitative evaluation of the models, and we also studied the model predictions qualitatively. We obtained more accurate predictions with the LRAN than with KDMD in the most turbulent setting. We conjecture that this is due to the LRAN's flexibility in learning complicated observables from data, thereby serving as a viable surrogate model for the main structure of fluid dynamics in turbulent convection settings. In contrast, KDMD was more effective in lower turbulence settings due to the repetitiveness of the convection flow. The feasibility of Koopman-based surrogate models for turbulent fluid flows opens possibilities for efficient model-based control techniques useful in a variety of industrial settings.

5/13/2024

Deep Learning for Koopman Operator Estimation in Idealized Atmospheric Dynamics

David Millard, Arielle Carr, St'ephane Gaudreault

Deep learning is revolutionizing weather forecasting, with new data-driven models achieving accuracy on par with operational physical models for medium-term predictions. However, these models often lack interpretability, making their underlying dynamics difficult to understand and explain. This paper proposes methodologies to estimate the Koopman operator, providing a linear representation of complex nonlinear dynamics to enhance the transparency of data-driven models. Despite its potential, applying the Koopman operator to large-scale problems, such as atmospheric modeling, remains challenging. This study aims to identify the limitations of existing methods, refine these models to overcome various bottlenecks, and introduce novel convolutional neural network architectures that capture simplified dynamics.

9/11/2024

Koopman-based Deep Learning for Nonlinear System Estimation

Zexin Sun, Mingyu Chen, John Baillieul

Nonlinear differential equations are encountered as models of fluid flow, spiking neurons, and many other systems of interest in the real world. Common features of these systems are that their behaviors are difficult to describe exactly and invariably unmodeled dynamics present challenges in making precise predictions. In many cases the models exhibit extremely complicated behavior due to bifurcations and chaotic regimes. In this paper, we present a novel data-driven linear estimator that uses Koopman operator theory to extract finite-dimensional representations of complex nonlinear systems. The extracted model is used together with a deep reinforcement learning network that learns the optimal stepwise actions to predict future states of the original nonlinear system. Our estimator is also adaptive to a diffeomorphic transformation of the nonlinear system which enables transfer learning to compute state estimates of the transformed system without relearning from scratch.

5/2/2024

Model-Based Reinforcement Learning for Control of Strongly-Disturbed Unsteady Aerodynamic Flows

Zhecheng Liu (University of California, Los Angeles), Diederik Beckers (California Institute of Technology), Jeff D. Eldredge (University of California, Los Angeles)

The intrinsic high dimension of fluid dynamics is an inherent challenge to control of aerodynamic flows, and this is further complicated by a flow's nonlinear response to strong disturbances. Deep reinforcement learning, which takes advantage of the exploratory aspects of reinforcement learning (RL) and the rich nonlinearity of a deep neural network, provides a promising approach to discover feasible control strategies. However, the typical model-free approach to reinforcement learning requires a significant amount of interaction between the flow environment and the RL agent during training, and this high training cost impedes its development and application. In this work, we propose a model-based reinforcement learning (MBRL) approach by incorporating a novel reduced-order model as a surrogate for the full environment. The model consists of a physics-augmented autoencoder, which compresses high-dimensional CFD flow field snaphsots into a three-dimensional latent space, and a latent dynamics model that is trained to accurately predict the long-time dynamics of trajectories in the latent space in response to action sequences. The robustness and generalizability of the model is demonstrated in two distinct flow environments, a pitching airfoil in a highly disturbed environment and a vertical-axis wind turbine in a disturbance-free environment. Based on the trained model in the first problem, we realize an MBRL strategy to mitigate lift variation during gust-airfoil encounters. We demonstrate that the policy learned in the reduced-order environment translates to an effective control strategy in the full CFD environment.

8/28/2024