A Large-scale Medical Visual Task Adaptation Benchmark
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Presents a new medical visual task adaptation benchmark called Med-VTAB
- Aims to facilitate the development of more robust and generalizable medical image understanding models
- Includes a diverse set of 13 medical image classification and segmentation tasks across various modalities and medical conditions
Plain English Explanation
This research paper introduces a new Med-VTAB: Medical Visual Task Adaptation Benchmark that can be used to evaluate how well machine learning models perform on a variety of medical image understanding tasks. The goal is to create a standardized benchmark that can help researchers and developers build more capable and generalizable models for analyzing medical images.
The benchmark includes 13 different tasks, such as classifying images of various medical conditions or segmenting important anatomical structures in medical scans. These tasks cover a diverse range of medical domains, image modalities (e.g., X-rays, CT scans, MRIs), and disease areas. By evaluating models on this broad set of tasks, the researchers aim to identify models that can adapt well to different medical image analysis challenges, rather than just excel at a single narrow task.
The authors hope this benchmark will spur the development of more robust and versatile medical image understanding models that can be deployed in real-world clinical settings. Having a standardized evaluation framework can make it easier to compare the capabilities of different AI models and accelerate progress in this important field of medical AI.
Technical Explanation
The Med-VTAB benchmark consists of 13 medical image classification and segmentation tasks spanning various modalities, anatomical regions, and disease conditions. The tasks were carefully curated from existing public datasets to create a diverse and representative benchmark.
The classification tasks include identifying diseases like pneumonia, skin cancer, and breast cancer, as well as detecting abnormalities in X-rays, CT scans, and pathology slides. The segmentation tasks involve delineating structures like the brain, lungs, and retina in medical images.
To establish a strong baseline, the authors evaluate several state-of-the-art computer vision models fine-tuned on the Med-VTAB tasks. They find that while these models perform well on individual tasks, their performance degrades when they are asked to adapt to new tasks.
This suggests that developing models that can effectively transfer and adapt their knowledge to diverse medical image understanding challenges is an important area for further research. The Med-VTAB benchmark provides a standardized platform to drive progress in this direction.
Critical Analysis
The Med-VTAB benchmark is a valuable contribution to the field of medical image analysis, as it addresses a critical need for more comprehensive and representative evaluation frameworks. By including a diverse set of tasks spanning multiple modalities and disease areas, the benchmark encourages the development of models that can generalize beyond narrow specializations.
However, the paper does not provide detailed insights into the specific challenges or confounding factors that may be inhibiting the transfer learning performance of existing models. Further analysis of the task characteristics, dataset biases, and model limitations could yield more actionable guidance for future research.
Additionally, while the benchmark covers a broad range of medical domains, it may still not capture the full complexity and heterogeneity of real-world clinical scenarios. Expanding the benchmark to include more task types, such as multi-modal fusion or disease progression prediction, could further strengthen its utility.
Overall, the Med-VTAB benchmark is a valuable contribution that can drive progress in building more robust and adaptable medical image understanding models. Continued refinement and expansion of the benchmark, along with deeper analysis of model performance, can further enhance its impact on the field.
Conclusion
The Med-VTAB benchmark presents a comprehensive and diverse set of medical image understanding tasks that can be used to evaluate the transfer learning capabilities of AI models. By providing a standardized evaluation framework, the benchmark aims to facilitate the development of more generalizable and clinically-relevant medical imaging AI systems.
The strong baseline results obtained with state-of-the-art computer vision models highlight the need for further advancements in transfer learning and domain adaptation techniques for medical image analysis. Continued research and innovation in this area, guided by the insights from the Med-VTAB benchmark, can lead to significant improvements in the robustness and real-world applicability of medical imaging AI.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Large-scale Medical Visual Task Adaptation Benchmark
Shentong Mo, Xufang Luo, Yansen Wang, Dongsheng Li
Visual task adaptation has been demonstrated to be effective in adapting pre-trained Vision Transformers (ViTs) to general downstream visual tasks using specialized learnable layers or tokens. However, there is yet a large-scale benchmark to fully explore the effect of visual task adaptation on the realistic and important medical domain, particularly across diverse medical visual modalities, such as color images, X-ray, and CT. To close this gap, we present Med-VTAB, a large-scale Medical Visual Task Adaptation Benchmark consisting of 1.68 million medical images for diverse organs, modalities, and adaptation approaches. Based on Med-VTAB, we explore the scaling law of medical prompt tuning concerning tunable parameters and the generalizability of medical visual adaptation using non-medical/medical pre-train weights. Besides, we study the impact of patient ID out-of-distribution on medical visual adaptation, which is a real and challenging scenario. Furthermore, results from Med-VTAB indicate that a single pre-trained model falls short in medical task adaptation. Therefore, we introduce GMoE-Adapter, a novel method that combines medical and general pre-training weights through a gated mixture-of-experts adapter, achieving state-of-the-art results in medical visual task adaptation.
Read more4/22/2024
0
Few-shot Adaptation of Medical Vision-Language Models
Fereshteh Shakeri, Yunshi Huang, Julio Silva-Rodr'iguez, Houda Bahig, An Tang, Jose Dolz, Ismail Ben Ayed
Integrating image and text data through multi-modal learning has emerged as a new approach in medical imaging research, following its successful deployment in computer vision. While considerable efforts have been dedicated to establishing medical foundation models and their zero-shot transfer to downstream tasks, the popular few-shot setting remains relatively unexplored. Following on from the currently strong emergence of this setting in computer vision, we introduce the first structured benchmark for adapting medical vision-language models (VLMs) in a strict few-shot regime and investigate various adaptation strategies commonly used in the context of natural images. Furthermore, we evaluate a simple generalization of the linear-probe adaptation baseline, which seeks an optimal blending of the visual prototypes and text embeddings via learnable class-wise multipliers. Surprisingly, such a text-informed linear probe yields competitive performances in comparison to convoluted prompt-learning and adapter-based strategies, while running considerably faster and accommodating the black-box setting. Our extensive experiments span three different medical modalities and specialized foundation models, nine downstream tasks, and several state-of-the-art few-shot adaptation methods. We made our benchmark and code publicly available to trigger further developments in this emergent subject: url{https://github.com/FereshteShakeri/few-shot-MedVLMs}.
Read more9/9/2024
🖼️
0
MeLo: Low-rank Adaptation is Better than Fine-tuning for Medical Image Diagnosis
Yitao Zhu, Zhenrong Shen, Zihao Zhao, Sheng Wang, Xin Wang, Xiangyu Zhao, Dinggang Shen, Qian Wang
The common practice in developing computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) models based on transformer architectures usually involves fine-tuning from ImageNet pre-trained weights. However, with recent advances in large-scale pre-training and the practice of scaling laws, Vision Transformers (ViT) have become much larger and less accessible to medical imaging communities. Additionally, in real-world scenarios, the deployments of multiple CAD models can be troublesome due to problems such as limited storage space and time-consuming model switching. To address these challenges, we propose a new method MeLo (Medical image Low-rank adaptation), which enables the development of a single CAD model for multiple clinical tasks in a lightweight manner. It adopts low-rank adaptation instead of resource-demanding fine-tuning. By fixing the weight of ViT models and only adding small low-rank plug-ins, we achieve competitive results on various diagnosis tasks across different imaging modalities using only a few trainable parameters. Specifically, our proposed method achieves comparable performance to fully fine-tuned ViT models on four distinct medical imaging datasets using about 0.17% trainable parameters. Moreover, MeLo adds only about 0.5MB of storage space and allows for extremely fast model switching in deployment and inference. Our source code and pre-trained weights are available on our website (https://absterzhu.github.io/melo.github.io/).
Read more7/23/2024
0
Knowledge-grounded Adaptation Strategy for Vision-language Models: Building Unique Case-set for Screening Mammograms for Residents Training
Aisha Urooj Khan, John Garrett, Tyler Bradshaw, Lonie Salkowski, Jiwoong Jason Jeong, Amara Tariq, Imon Banerjee
A visual-language model (VLM) pre-trained on natural images and text pairs poses a significant barrier when applied to medical contexts due to domain shift. Yet, adapting or fine-tuning these VLMs for medical use presents considerable hurdles, including domain misalignment, limited access to extensive datasets, and high-class imbalances. Hence, there is a pressing need for strategies to effectively adapt these VLMs to the medical domain, as such adaptations would prove immensely valuable in healthcare applications. In this study, we propose a framework designed to adeptly tailor VLMs to the medical domain, employing selective sampling and hard-negative mining techniques for enhanced performance in retrieval tasks. We validate the efficacy of our proposed approach by implementing it across two distinct VLMs: the in-domain VLM (MedCLIP) and out-of-domain VLMs (ALBEF). We assess the performance of these models both in their original off-the-shelf state and after undergoing our proposed training strategies, using two extensive datasets containing mammograms and their corresponding reports. Our evaluation spans zero-shot, few-shot, and supervised scenarios. Through our approach, we observe a notable enhancement in Recall@K performance for the image-text retrieval task.
Read more5/31/2024