Latent Variable Sequence Identification for Cognitive Models with Neural Bayes Estimation
2406.14742
0
0
Abstract
Extracting time-varying latent variables from computational cognitive models is a key step in model-based neural analysis, which aims to understand the neural correlates of cognitive processes. However, existing methods only allow researchers to infer latent variables that explain subjects' behavior in a relatively small class of cognitive models. For example, a broad class of relevant cognitive models with analytically intractable likelihood is currently out of reach from standard techniques, based on Maximum a Posteriori parameter estimation. Here, we present an approach that extends neural Bayes estimation to learn a direct mapping between experimental data and the targeted latent variable space using recurrent neural networks and simulated datasets. We show that our approach achieves competitive performance in inferring latent variable sequences in both tractable and intractable models. Furthermore, the approach is generalizable across different computational models and is adaptable for both continuous and discrete latent spaces. We then demonstrate its applicability in real world datasets. Our work underscores that combining recurrent neural networks and simulation-based inference to identify latent variable sequences can enable researchers to access a wider class of cognitive models for model-based neural analyses, and thus test a broader set of theories.
Create account to get full access
Overview
ā¢ This paper proposes a novel method for identifying latent variable sequences in cognitive models using neural Bayes estimation.
ā¢ The approach aims to improve the interpretability and performance of cognitive models by explicitly modeling the underlying latent states that drive observed behavioral data.
ā¢ The method is demonstrated on a reinforcement learning task, showing how it can outperform standard approaches in recovering the true latent state sequences.
Plain English Explanation
The human brain is incredibly complex, with many hidden processes and variables at work that shape our thoughts, decisions, and behaviors. Cognitive models are mathematical representations of these mental processes, aiming to capture the key factors that drive our actions.
However, building accurate cognitive models is challenging, as much of the brain's inner workings are not directly observable. This paper proposes a new technique called "neural Bayes estimation" to help address this issue. The core idea is to explicitly model the hidden, or "latent," variables that underlie the observed behavioral data.
By doing so, the method can better recover the true sequence of latent states that led to the observed actions, providing a more interpretable and potentially more accurate representation of the cognitive processes at play. This could enable richer causal inferences about the mechanisms driving behavior.
The authors demonstrate this approach on a reinforcement learning task, where an agent must learn to make decisions to maximize rewards. They show that their neural Bayes method outperforms standard techniques in recovering the hidden states that govern the agent's decision-making. This suggests the method could be a valuable tool for learning discrete concepts from latent hierarchical models and identifying latent state transitions in non-linear dynamical systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel approach for identifying latent variable sequences in cognitive models using a technique called "neural Bayes estimation." The key idea is to build a probabilistic model that can infer the hidden, or latent, states that underlie observed behavioral data.
The method works by defining a generative model that captures the relationship between the latent states and the observed actions. This model is then trained using a neural network to learn the parameters that best explain the data. During inference, the trained model can be used to recover the sequence of latent states that are most likely to have generated the observed behavior.
The authors demonstrate this approach on a reinforcement learning task, where an agent must learn to make decisions to maximize rewards. They show that their neural Bayes method outperforms standard techniques, such as Kalman filters and particle filters, in accurately recovering the true underlying latent state sequences.
One of the key advantages of this approach is that it can provide a more interpretable and potentially more accurate representation of the cognitive processes driving behavior. By explicitly modeling the latent variables, the method can offer insights into the hidden mechanisms shaping our decisions and actions. This could enable richer causal inferences and learning of discrete concepts from latent hierarchical models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach for identifying latent variable sequences in cognitive models, with promising results on the reinforcement learning task. However, it's important to consider some potential limitations and areas for further research.
One concern is the reliance on a specific generative model structure, which may not capture the full complexity of real-world cognitive processes. Identifying latent state transitions in non-linear dynamical systems could require more flexible or adaptive modeling approaches.
Additionally, the paper focuses on a relatively simple task, and it's unclear how well the method would scale to more complex, real-world cognitive scenarios. Further evaluations on a wider range of tasks and domains would be valuable to assess the broader applicability of the approach.
It's also worth considering how the neural Bayes estimation technique might interact with or complement other methods for explaining latent representations in deep generative models. Combining these approaches could lead to even more powerful tools for understanding the underlying cognitive mechanisms.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel neural Bayes estimation method for identifying latent variable sequences in cognitive models. By explicitly modeling the hidden states that drive observed behavior, the approach aims to improve the interpretability and performance of cognitive models.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on a reinforcement learning task, showing how it can outperform standard techniques in recovering the true latent state sequences. This suggests the potential of the approach for providing richer insights into the cognitive processes that shape our thoughts and actions, with implications for a wide range of applications in psychology, neuroscience, and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Deep Latent Variable Modeling of Physiological Signals
Khuong Vo
0
0
A deep latent variable model is a powerful method for capturing complex distributions. These models assume that underlying structures, but unobserved, are present within the data. In this dissertation, we explore high-dimensional problems related to physiological monitoring using latent variable models. First, we present a novel deep state-space model to generate electrical waveforms of the heart using optically obtained signals as inputs. This can bring about clinical diagnoses of heart disease via simple assessment through wearable devices. Second, we present a brain signal modeling scheme that combines the strengths of probabilistic graphical models and deep adversarial learning. The structured representations can provide interpretability and encode inductive biases to reduce the data complexity of neural oscillations. The efficacy of the learned representations is further studied in epilepsy seizure detection formulated as an unsupervised learning problem. Third, we propose a framework for the joint modeling of physiological measures and behavior. Existing methods to combine multiple sources of brain data provided are limited. Direct analysis of the relationship between different types of physiological measures usually does not involve behavioral data. Our method can identify the unique and shared contributions of brain regions to behavior and can be used to discover new functions of brain regions. The success of these innovative computational methods would allow the translation of biomarker findings across species and provide insight into neurocognitive analysis in numerous biological studies and clinical diagnoses, as well as emerging consumer applications.
6/13/2024
Causal Inference with Latent Variables: Recent Advances and Future Prospectives
Yaochen Zhu, Yinhan He, Jing Ma, Mengxuan Hu, Sheng Li, Jundong Li
0
0
Causality lays the foundation for the trajectory of our world. Causal inference (CI), which aims to infer intrinsic causal relations among variables of interest, has emerged as a crucial research topic. Nevertheless, the lack of observation of important variables (e.g., confounders, mediators, exogenous variables, etc.) severely compromises the reliability of CI methods. The issue may arise from the inherent difficulty in measuring the variables. Additionally, in observational studies where variables are passively recorded, certain covariates might be inadvertently omitted by the experimenter. Depending on the type of unobserved variables and the specific CI task, various consequences can be incurred if these latent variables are carelessly handled, such as biased estimation of causal effects, incomplete understanding of causal mechanisms, lack of individual-level causal consideration, etc. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive review of recent developments in CI with latent variables. We start by discussing traditional CI techniques when variables of interest are assumed to be fully observed. Afterward, under the taxonomy of circumvention and inference-based methods, we provide an in-depth discussion of various CI strategies to handle latent variables, covering the tasks of causal effect estimation, mediation analysis, counterfactual reasoning, and causal discovery. Furthermore, we generalize the discussion to graph data where interference among units may exist. Finally, we offer fresh aspects for further advancement of CI with latent variables, especially new opportunities in the era of large language models (LLMs).
6/21/2024
Learning Discrete Concepts in Latent Hierarchical Models
Lingjing Kong, Guangyi Chen, Biwei Huang, Eric P. Xing, Yuejie Chi, Kun Zhang
0
0
Learning concepts from natural high-dimensional data (e.g., images) holds potential in building human-aligned and interpretable machine learning models. Despite its encouraging prospect, formalization and theoretical insights into this crucial task are still lacking. In this work, we formalize concepts as discrete latent causal variables that are related via a hierarchical causal model that encodes different abstraction levels of concepts embedded in high-dimensional data (e.g., a dog breed and its eye shapes in natural images). We formulate conditions to facilitate the identification of the proposed causal model, which reveals when learning such concepts from unsupervised data is possible. Our conditions permit complex causal hierarchical structures beyond latent trees and multi-level directed acyclic graphs in prior work and can handle high-dimensional, continuous observed variables, which is well-suited for unstructured data modalities such as images. We substantiate our theoretical claims with synthetic data experiments. Further, we discuss our theory's implications for understanding the underlying mechanisms of latent diffusion models and provide corresponding empirical evidence for our theoretical insights.
6/4/2024
Inferring stochastic low-rank recurrent neural networks from neural data
Matthijs Pals, A Erdem Sau{g}tekin, Felix Pei, Manuel Gloeckler, Jakob H Macke
0
0
A central aim in computational neuroscience is to relate the activity of large populations of neurons to an underlying dynamical system. Models of these neural dynamics should ideally be both interpretable and fit the observed data well. Low-rank recurrent neural networks (RNNs) exhibit such interpretability by having tractable dynamics. However, it is unclear how to best fit low-rank RNNs to data consisting of noisy observations of an underlying stochastic system. Here, we propose to fit stochastic low-rank RNNs with variational sequential Monte Carlo methods. We validate our method on several datasets consisting of both continuous and spiking neural data, where we obtain lower dimensional latent dynamics than current state of the art methods. Additionally, for low-rank models with piecewise linear nonlinearities, we show how to efficiently identify all fixed points in polynomial rather than exponential cost in the number of units, making analysis of the inferred dynamics tractable for large RNNs. Our method both elucidates the dynamical systems underlying experimental recordings and provides a generative model whose trajectories match observed trial-to-trial variability.
6/26/2024