Learning Mixture-of-Experts for General-Purpose Black-Box Discrete Optimization

Read original: arXiv:2405.18884 - Published 5/30/2024 by Shengcai Liu, Zhiyuan Wang, Yew-Soon Ong, Xin Yao, Ke Tang

🛠️

Overview

This paper introduces MEGO, a novel general-purpose neural optimizer trained using a learning-to-optimize (L2O) approach.
MEGO is designed to solve a wide range of discrete optimization problems, including classic problems and real-world applications in areas like compilers, network analysis, and 3D reconstruction.
MEGO uses a mixture-of-experts architecture that can actively select relevant expert models to generate high-quality solutions for a given problem.
The authors demonstrate that MEGO can outperform widely used general-purpose optimizers and even specialized state-of-the-art methods in some cases.
Additionally, MEGO provides a way to measure problem similarity, which can yield new perspectives on problem classification.

Plain English Explanation

Optimization problems are common in the real world, such as scheduling tasks, designing efficient algorithms, or finding the best configuration for a system. Designing specialized solvers for each of these problems can be challenging and time-consuming, as it often requires deep domain knowledge.

The researchers behind this paper wanted to develop a general-purpose optimizer that could be used as an "off-the-shelf" tool to solve a wide range of optimization problems. They call this optimizer MEGO, which stands for "Mixture-of-Experts General Optimizer."

MEGO works by learning from experiences of solving different optimization problems during a training process. It develops a set of "expert" models, each of which is good at solving certain types of problems. When presented with a new problem, MEGO can actively select the most relevant expert models to generate high-quality solutions.

The researchers tested MEGO on six different problem classes, including classic problems like the Traveling Salesman Problem as well as real-world problems from areas like compilers, network analysis, and 3D reconstruction. They found that MEGO was able to outperform widely used general-purpose optimizers and even specialized solvers in some cases.

Additionally, MEGO can provide a way to measure the similarity between different optimization problems. This could lead to new ways of classifying and understanding optimization problems, which could have applications in fields like machine learning and operations research.

Technical Explanation

The core idea behind MEGO is to use a mixture-of-experts architecture to solve a wide range of discrete optimization problems. The model consists of a set of expert sub-models, each of which is trained to solve a specific type of problem. When presented with a new problem, MEGO can actively select the most relevant expert models to generate high-quality solutions.

The MEGO model is trained using a learning-to-optimize (L2O) approach, where the model learns to optimize by observing and learning from experiences of solving training problems. During training, MEGO learns to associate problem characteristics with the most suitable expert models, allowing it to efficiently solve a wide range of problems.

The researchers evaluated MEGO on six problem classes, including classic problems like the Traveling Salesman Problem and real-world problems from areas like compilers, network analysis, and 3D reconstruction. They found that MEGO was able to significantly outperform widely used general-purpose optimizers, such as genetic algorithms and simulated annealing, in both solution quality and efficiency. In some cases, MEGO even surpassed specialized state-of-the-art optimizers for certain problem classes.

Additionally, the researchers discovered that MEGO can provide a way to measure the similarity between different optimization problems. This is done by looking at the relative importance of each expert model when solving a given problem. Problems that rely on similar expert models are considered more similar, which could lead to new approaches for problem classification and understanding.

Critical Analysis

The researchers have made a significant contribution by developing MEGO, a general-purpose optimizer that can solve a wide range of discrete optimization problems effectively. The use of a mixture-of-experts architecture and the L2O training approach are both novel and well-executed.

However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research that could be considered:

Problem Scope: While MEGO has been tested on a diverse set of problem classes, it is still limited to discrete optimization problems with binary decision variables. Expanding the model to handle continuous or mixed-integer optimization problems could further enhance its generality.
Scalability: The researchers did not explicitly address how MEGO might scale to larger, more complex optimization problems. Investigating the model's performance on larger-scale problems would be an important next step.
Interpretability: While MEGO provides a way to measure problem similarity, the underlying reasons for these similarities are not fully explored. Developing a more interpretable model could yield additional insights into the nature of optimization problems.
Computational Efficiency: The training process for MEGO may be computationally intensive, especially when dealing with a large number of expert models. Exploring ways to improve the training efficiency or reduce the model complexity could make MEGO more practical for real-world applications.

Overall, the MEGO model represents a significant step towards the development of general-purpose optimization solvers. By continuing to build upon this work and addressing the potential limitations, the researchers could further advance the field of optimization and create even more powerful and versatile tools for solving real-world problems.

Conclusion

This paper introduces MEGO, a novel general-purpose neural optimizer trained using a learning-to-optimize approach. MEGO's mixture-of-experts architecture allows it to actively select relevant expert models to solve a wide range of discrete optimization problems, including classic problems and real-world applications in areas like compilers, network analysis, and 3D reconstruction.

The researchers have demonstrated that MEGO can outperform widely used general-purpose optimizers and even specialized state-of-the-art methods in some cases. Additionally, MEGO provides a way to measure problem similarity, which could lead to new perspectives on problem classification and understanding.

While MEGO represents a significant step forward in the pursuit of general-purpose optimization solvers, there are still opportunities for further research and development, such as expanding the problem scope, improving scalability, enhancing interpretability, and increasing computational efficiency. By addressing these areas, the MEGO model could become an even more powerful and versatile tool for solving a wide range of real-world optimization problems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🛠️

Learning Mixture-of-Experts for General-Purpose Black-Box Discrete Optimization

Shengcai Liu, Zhiyuan Wang, Yew-Soon Ong, Xin Yao, Ke Tang

Real-world applications involve various discrete optimization problems. Designing a specialized optimizer for each of these problems is challenging, typically requiring significant domain knowledge and human efforts. Hence, developing general-purpose optimizers as an off-the-shelf tool for a wide range of problems has been a long-standing research target. This article introduces MEGO, a novel general-purpose neural optimizer trained through a fully data-driven learning-to-optimize (L2O) approach. MEGO consists of a mixture-of-experts trained on experiences from solving training problems and can be viewed as a foundation model for optimization problems with binary decision variables. When presented with a problem to solve, MEGO actively selects relevant expert models to generate high-quality solutions. MEGO can be used as a standalone sample-efficient optimizer or in conjunction with existing search methods as an initial solution generator. The generality of MEGO is validated across six problem classes, including three classic problem classes and three problem classes arising from real-world applications in compilers, network analysis, and 3D reconstruction. Trained solely on classic problem classes, MEGO performs very well on all six problem classes, significantly surpassing widely used general-purpose optimizers in both solution quality and efficiency. In some cases, MEGO even surpasses specialized state-of-the-art optimizers. Additionally, MEGO provides a similarity measure between problems, yielding a new perspective for problem classification. In the pursuit of general-purpose optimizers through L2O, MEGO represents an initial yet significant step forward.

5/30/2024

💬

Diversifying the Mixture-of-Experts Representation for Language Models with Orthogonal Optimizer

Boan Liu, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Keqin Peng, Yu Cao, Dazhao Cheng, Dacheng Tao

The Mixture of Experts (MoE) has emerged as a highly successful technique in deep learning, based on the principle of divide-and-conquer to maximize model capacity without significant additional computational cost. Even in the era of large-scale language models (LLMs), MoE continues to play a crucial role, as some researchers have indicated that GPT-4 adopts the MoE structure to ensure diverse inference results. However, MoE is susceptible to performance degeneracy, particularly evident in the issues of imbalance and homogeneous representation among experts. While previous studies have extensively addressed the problem of imbalance, the challenge of homogeneous representation remains unresolved. In this study, we shed light on the homogeneous representation problem, wherein experts in the MoE fail to specialize and lack diversity, leading to frustratingly high similarities in their representations (up to 99% in a well-performed MoE model). This problem restricts the expressive power of the MoE and, we argue, contradicts its original intention. To tackle this issue, we propose a straightforward yet highly effective solution: OMoE, an orthogonal expert optimizer. Additionally, we introduce an alternating training strategy that encourages each expert to update in a direction orthogonal to the subspace spanned by other experts. Our algorithm facilitates MoE training in two key ways: firstly, it explicitly enhances representation diversity, and secondly, it implicitly fosters interaction between experts during orthogonal weights computation. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that our proposed optimization algorithm significantly improves the performance of fine-tuning the MoE model on the GLUE benchmark, SuperGLUE benchmark, question-answering task, and name entity recognition tasks.

9/2/2024

🔍

Omni-SMoLA: Boosting Generalist Multimodal Models with Soft Mixture of Low-rank Experts

Jialin Wu, Xia Hu, Yaqing Wang, Bo Pang, Radu Soricut

Large multi-modal models (LMMs) exhibit remarkable performance across numerous tasks. However, generalist LMMs often suffer from performance degradation when tuned over a large collection of tasks. Recent research suggests that Mixture of Experts (MoE) architectures are useful for instruction tuning, but for LMMs of parameter size around O(50-100B), the prohibitive cost of replicating and storing the expert models severely limits the number of experts we can use. We propose Omni-SMoLA, an architecture that uses the Soft MoE approach to (softly) mix many multimodal low rank experts, and avoids introducing a significant number of new parameters compared to conventional MoE models. The core intuition here is that the large model provides a foundational backbone, while different lightweight experts residually learn specialized knowledge, either per-modality or multimodally. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the SMoLA approach helps improve the generalist performance across a broad range of generative vision-and-language tasks, achieving new SoTA generalist performance that often matches or outperforms single specialized LMM baselines, as well as new SoTA specialist performance.

4/4/2024

GOAL: A Generalist Combinatorial Optimization Agent Learner

Darko Drakulic, Sofia Michel, Jean-Marc Andreoli

Machine Learning-based heuristics have recently shown impressive performance in solving a variety of hard combinatorial optimization problems (COPs). However they generally rely on a separate neural model, specialized and trained for each single problem. Any variation of a problem requires adjustment of its model and re-training from scratch. In this paper, we propose GOAL (for Generalist combinatorial Optimization Agent Learning), a generalist model capable of efficiently solving multiple COPs and which can be fine-tuned to solve new COPs. GOAL consists of a single backbone plus light-weight problem-specific adapters, mostly for input and output processing. The backbone is based on a new form of mixed-attention blocks which allows to handle problems defined on graphs with arbitrary combinations of node, edge and instance-level features. Additionally, problems which involve heterogeneous nodes or edges, such as in multi-partite graphs, are handled through a novel multi-type transformer architecture, where the attention blocks are duplicated to attend only the relevant combination of types while relying on the same shared parameters. We train GOAL on a set of routing, scheduling and classic graph problems and show that it is only slightly inferior to the specialized baselines while being the first multi-task model that solves a variety of COPs. Finally, we showcase the strong transfer learning capacity of GOAL by fine-tuning or learning the adapters for new problems, with only few shots and little data.

6/24/2024