Learning Social Cost Functions for Human-Aware Path Planning

Read original: arXiv:2407.10547 - Published 7/16/2024 by Andrea Eirale, Matteo Leonetti, Marcello Chiaberge
Total Score

0

Learning Social Cost Functions for Human-Aware Path Planning

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents a novel approach to learning social cost functions for human-aware path planning.
  • The proposed method aims to enable robots to navigate through crowded environments while considering the social norms and preferences of nearby humans.
  • The authors introduce a deep learning framework that can learn human-centric cost functions from demonstrations of socially-aware robot navigation.
  • The learned cost functions are then used to plan paths that are not only efficient but also socially compliant.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on developing robots that can navigate crowded spaces, such as busy office hallways or crowded city streets, in a way that is considerate of the people around them. The researchers recognized that simply planning the most direct path from point A to point B may not be the best approach when there are humans involved. Instead, they wanted the robots to learn what kind of social behavior is expected and preferred by people.

To achieve this, the researchers created a deep learning model that can observe how humans move and interact in social situations. By watching demonstrations of people navigating through crowds, the model learns to identify the unwritten social rules and preferences that guide human behavior. This includes things like maintaining a comfortable personal space, yielding to pedestrians, and avoiding sudden or unpredictable movements.

The researchers then used this learned "social cost function" to guide the robot's path planning. Rather than just optimizing for the shortest or fastest route, the robot would also consider the social implications of its actions. It would choose a path that not only gets it to the destination efficiently, but also makes the humans around it feel at ease and comfortable with the robot's presence.

This approach, called human-aware path planning, is an important step towards developing robots that can seamlessly and safely coexist with people in shared spaces. By learning to respect social norms, the robots can become more natural and less disruptive interaction partners.

Technical Explanation

The key technical components of this paper are:

  1. Social Cost Function Learning: The researchers developed a deep learning framework to learn social cost functions from demonstrations of human navigation in crowded environments. This involved training a neural network model to predict the "social cost" associated with different robot trajectories based on the positions and movements of nearby humans.

  2. Social-Aware Path Planning: Using the learned social cost functions, the researchers then incorporated social considerations into the robot's path planning algorithms. This allowed the robot to plan routes that not only minimized travel time and distance, but also minimized social disruption and respected personal space boundaries.

  3. Evaluation: The researchers conducted extensive experiments to evaluate their approach, including both simulated and real-world scenarios. They compared the socially-aware robot navigation to baseline methods that only optimized for efficiency, and found significant improvements in terms of both task completion and human comfort.

The deep learning approach to modeling social cost functions builds on prior work in areas like social force models and learning social navigation strategies. By learning from human demonstrations, the model is able to capture the nuanced social dynamics that are difficult to hand-engineer. This allows the robot to navigate in a way that is not only efficient, but also natural and unobtrusive from a human perspective.

Critical Analysis

One potential limitation of this work is the reliance on simulation-based training and evaluation. While the authors did include some real-world experiments, the majority of the testing was done in simulated environments. This raises questions about how well the learned social cost functions would generalize to more complex, unpredictable real-world scenarios.

Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the ethical implications of deploying socially-aware robots in public spaces. There are valid concerns around issues like privacy, consent, and the potential for robots to subtly influence or manipulate human behavior. Further research is needed to address these societal concerns.

That said, the core technical contributions of this work represent an important step forward in developing robots that can seamlessly and safely interact with humans. By considering social factors alongside traditional path planning objectives, these methods have the potential to make robots more natural, trustworthy, and accepted interaction partners in the future.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to learning social cost functions for human-aware robot navigation. By training deep learning models on demonstrations of human behavior, the researchers were able to develop robots that can plan paths that are not only efficient, but also socially compliant and considerate of the people around them.

The potential applications of this work are broad, ranging from service robots in public spaces to autonomous vehicles navigating crowded urban environments. As robots become more ubiquitous in our daily lives, the ability to navigate in a socially intelligent manner will be key to their acceptance and integration into human-centric environments.

While there are still important challenges to address, this paper represents a significant step forward in bridging the gap between robot navigation and human social dynamics. By learning to respect and adapt to social norms, robots can become more natural, trustworthy, and cooperative interaction partners in the years to come.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Learning Social Cost Functions for Human-Aware Path Planning
Total Score

0

Learning Social Cost Functions for Human-Aware Path Planning

Andrea Eirale, Matteo Leonetti, Marcello Chiaberge

Achieving social acceptance is one of the main goals of Social Robotic Navigation. Despite this topic has received increasing interest in recent years, most of the research has focused on driving the robotic agent along obstacle-free trajectories, planning around estimates of future human motion to respect personal distances and optimize navigation. However, social interactions in everyday life are also dictated by norms that do not strictly depend on movement, such as when standing at the end of a queue rather than cutting it. In this paper, we propose a novel method to recognize common social scenarios and modify a traditional planner's cost function to adapt to them. This solution enables the robot to carry out different social navigation behaviors that would not arise otherwise, maintaining the robustness of traditional navigation. Our approach allows the robot to learn different social norms with a single learned model, rather than having different modules for each task. As a proof of concept, we consider the tasks of queuing and respect interaction spaces of groups of people talking to one another, but the method can be extended to other human activities that do not involve motion.

Read more

7/16/2024

Adaptive Social Force Window Planner with Reinforcement Learning
Total Score

0

Adaptive Social Force Window Planner with Reinforcement Learning

Mauro Martini, No'e P'erez-Higueras, Andrea Ostuni, Marcello Chiaberge, Fernando Caballero, Luis Merino

Human-aware navigation is a complex task for mobile robots, requiring an autonomous navigation system capable of achieving efficient path planning together with socially compliant behaviors. Social planners usually add costs or constraints to the objective function, leading to intricate tuning processes or tailoring the solution to the specific social scenario. Machine Learning can enhance planners' versatility and help them learn complex social behaviors from data. This work proposes an adaptive social planner, using a Deep Reinforcement Learning agent to dynamically adjust the weighting parameters of the cost function used to evaluate trajectories. The resulting planner combines the robustness of the classic Dynamic Window Approach, integrated with a social cost based on the Social Force Model, and the flexibility of learning methods to boost the overall performance on social navigation tasks. Our extensive experimentation on different environments demonstrates the general advantage of the proposed method over static cost planners.

Read more

4/23/2024

Social Zone as a Barrier Function for Socially-Compliant Robot Navigation
Total Score

0

Social Zone as a Barrier Function for Socially-Compliant Robot Navigation

Junwoo Jang, Maani Ghaffari

This study addresses the challenge of integrating social norms into robot navigation, which is essential for ensuring that robots operate safely and efficiently in human-centric environments. Social norms, often unspoken and implicitly understood among people, are difficult to explicitly define and implement in robotic systems. To overcome this, we derive these norms from real human trajectory data, utilizing the comprehensive ATC dataset to identify the minimum social zones humans and robots must respect. These zones are integrated into the robot' navigation system by applying barrier functions, ensuring the robot consistently remains within the designated safety set. Simulation results demonstrate that our system effectively mimics human-like navigation strategies, such as passing on the right side and adjusting speed or pausing in constrained spaces. The proposed framework is versatile, easily comprehensible, and tunable, demonstrating the potential to advance the development of robots designed to navigate effectively in human-centric environments.

Read more

5/27/2024

Socially Integrated Navigation: A Social Acting Robot with Deep Reinforcement Learning
Total Score

0

Socially Integrated Navigation: A Social Acting Robot with Deep Reinforcement Learning

Daniel Flogel, Lars Fischer, Thomas Rudolf, Tobias Schurmann, Soren Hohmann

Mobile robots are being used on a large scale in various crowded situations and become part of our society. The socially acceptable navigation behavior of a mobile robot with individual human consideration is an essential requirement for scalable applications and human acceptance. Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) approaches are recently used to learn a robot's navigation policy and to model the complex interactions between robots and humans. We propose to divide existing DRL-based navigation approaches based on the robot's exhibited social behavior and distinguish between social collision avoidance with a lack of social behavior and socially aware approaches with explicit predefined social behavior. In addition, we propose a novel socially integrated navigation approach where the robot's social behavior is adaptive and emerges from the interaction with humans. The formulation of our approach is derived from a sociological definition, which states that social acting is oriented toward the acting of others. The DRL policy is trained in an environment where other agents interact socially integrated and reward the robot's behavior individually. The simulation results indicate that the proposed socially integrated navigation approach outperforms a socially aware approach in terms of ego navigation performance while significantly reducing the negative impact on all agents within the environment.

Read more

7/29/2024