Learning Structure and Knowledge Aware Representation with Large Language Models for Concept Recommendation
2405.12442
0
0
💬
Abstract
Concept recommendation aims to suggest the next concept for learners to study based on their knowledge states and the human knowledge system. While knowledge states can be predicted using knowledge tracing models, previous approaches have not effectively integrated the human knowledge system into the process of designing these educational models. In the era of rapidly evolving Large Language Models (LLMs), many fields have begun using LLMs to generate and encode text, introducing external knowledge. However, integrating LLMs into concept recommendation presents two urgent challenges: 1) How to construct text for concepts that effectively incorporate the human knowledge system? 2) How to adapt non-smooth, anisotropic text encodings effectively for concept recommendation? In this paper, we propose a novel Structure and Knowledge Aware Representation learning framework for concept Recommendation (SKarREC). We leverage factual knowledge from LLMs as well as the precedence and succession relationships between concepts obtained from the knowledge graph to construct textual representations of concepts. Furthermore, we propose a graph-based adapter to adapt anisotropic text embeddings to the concept recommendation task. This adapter is pre-trained through contrastive learning on the knowledge graph to get a smooth and structure-aware concept representation. Then, it's fine-tuned through the recommendation task, forming a text-to-knowledge-to-recommendation adaptation pipeline, which effectively constructs a structure and knowledge-aware concept representation. Our method does a better job than previous adapters in transforming text encodings for application in concept recommendation. Extensive experiments on real-world datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel framework called SKarREC (Structure and Knowledge Aware Representation learning for Concept Recommendation) to improve concept recommendation for learners.
- Concept recommendation aims to suggest the next concept for learners to study based on their knowledge states and the human knowledge system.
- The paper addresses two key challenges in integrating Large Language Models (LLMs) into concept recommendation: 1) how to construct textual representations of concepts that effectively incorporate the human knowledge system, and 2) how to adapt the non-smooth, anisotropic text encodings from LLMs for the concept recommendation task.
Plain English Explanation
When learning new topics, it's helpful for students to be recommended the next concept they should study based on their current understanding and the overall structure of the knowledge domain. This paper introduces a new approach called SKarREC to tackle this problem of concept recommendation.
The key idea is to leverage the wealth of factual knowledge captured in large language models (LLMs) as well as the structured relationships between concepts (like prerequisites and dependencies) to generate more effective textual representations of these concepts. These representations can then be used to make better recommendations about what a student should learn next.
The researchers faced two main challenges in doing this. First, they needed to figure out how to construct the concept text in a way that truly reflects the human knowledge system, not just generic language patterns. Second, they had to find a way to adapt the text embeddings from LLMs, which can be "bumpy" and not well-suited for recommendation tasks, into a smoother, more structured representation.
To address these challenges, the SKarREC framework does two key things: 1) it leverages knowledge graphs to capture the precedence and succession relationships between concepts, and 2) it uses a graph-based adapter to transform the LLM text embeddings into a form that works better for concept recommendation. This adapter is pre-trained on the knowledge graph to learn a smooth, structure-aware representation of the concepts.
Technical Explanation
The SKarREC framework has two key components:
-
Concept Text Construction: The researchers leverage factual knowledge from LLMs as well as the precedence and succession relationships between concepts obtained from a knowledge graph to construct informative textual representations of each concept. This helps capture the human knowledge system in the concept descriptions.
-
Graph-based Adapter: To address the challenge of adapting the non-smooth, anisotropic text embeddings from LLMs for the concept recommendation task, SKarREC employs a graph-based adapter. This adapter is pre-trained through contrastive learning on the knowledge graph to learn a smooth and structure-aware concept representation. It is then fine-tuned through the recommendation task, forming a text-to-knowledge-to-recommendation adaptation pipeline.
The researchers evaluate their approach on real-world datasets and show that SKarREC outperforms previous methods in concept recommendation. The use of LLMs and knowledge graphs together allows the system to better capture the structure and relationships within the human knowledge system, leading to more effective recommendations.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed approach to integrating LLMs and knowledge graphs for concept recommendation. However, a few potential limitations and areas for future research are worth noting:
- The evaluation is limited to certain datasets, so the performance of SKarREC on other educational domains or knowledge bases may vary.
- The paper does not explore the impact of different knowledge graph structures or the tradeoffs between using broader vs. more domain-specific knowledge graphs.
- While the graph-based adapter is an interesting innovation, its effectiveness could be further tested against other techniques for adapting LLM embeddings for recommendation tasks.
- The paper does not address potential biases or inconsistencies that may exist in the factual knowledge or relationships captured in the LLMs and knowledge graphs used.
Overall, the SKarREC framework presents a promising direction for enhancing concept recommendation by leveraging the complementary strengths of LLMs and structured knowledge. However, as with any research, there are opportunities for further exploration and refinement.
Conclusion
This paper introduces SKarREC, a novel framework for concept recommendation that effectively integrates Large Language Models and knowledge graphs to capture the structure and relationships within the human knowledge system. By constructing informative textual representations of concepts and adapting the LLM embeddings to the recommendation task, SKarREC is able to outperform previous approaches.
The key innovations of the SKarREC framework - leveraging factual knowledge and structural information to create concept representations, and using a graph-based adapter to transform text encodings - demonstrate the value of combining large-scale language models with structured knowledge sources for educational applications. As the field of recommender systems continues to evolve with the rise of LLMs, this research provides a promising path forward for enhancing personalized learning and knowledge acquisition.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
Knowledge Adaptation from Large Language Model to Recommendation for Practical Industrial Application
Jian Jia, Yipei Wang, Yan Li, Honggang Chen, Xuehan Bai, Zhaocheng Liu, Jian Liang, Quan Chen, Han Li, Peng Jiang, Kun Gai
0
0
Contemporary recommender systems predominantly rely on collaborative filtering techniques, employing ID-embedding to capture latent associations among users and items. However, this approach overlooks the wealth of semantic information embedded within textual descriptions of items, leading to suboptimal performance in cold-start scenarios and long-tail user recommendations. Leveraging the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) pretrained on massive text corpus presents a promising avenue for enhancing recommender systems by integrating open-world domain knowledge. In this paper, we propose an Llm-driven knowlEdge Adaptive RecommeNdation (LEARN) framework that synergizes open-world knowledge with collaborative knowledge. We address computational complexity concerns by utilizing pretrained LLMs as item encoders and freezing LLM parameters to avoid catastrophic forgetting and preserve open-world knowledge. To bridge the gap between the open-world and collaborative domains, we design a twin-tower structure supervised by the recommendation task and tailored for practical industrial application. Through offline experiments on the large-scale industrial dataset and online experiments on A/B tests, we demonstrate the efficacy of our approach.
5/8/2024
New!Large Language Model Enhanced Knowledge Representation Learning: A Survey
Xin Wang, Zirui Chen, Haofen Wang, Leong Hou U, Zhao Li, Wenbin Guo
0
0
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) with Knowledge Representation Learning (KRL) signifies a pivotal advancement in the field of artificial intelligence, enhancing the ability to capture and utilize complex knowledge structures. This synergy leverages the advanced linguistic and contextual understanding capabilities of LLMs to improve the accuracy, adaptability, and efficacy of KRL, thereby expanding its applications and potential. Despite the increasing volume of research focused on embedding LLMs within the domain of knowledge representation, a thorough review that examines the fundamental components and processes of these enhanced models is conspicuously absent. Our survey addresses this by categorizing these models based on three distinct Transformer architectures, and by analyzing experimental data from various KRL downstream tasks to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each approach. Finally, we identify and explore potential future research directions in this emerging yet underexplored domain, proposing pathways for continued progress.
7/2/2024
Knowledge Graphs and Pre-trained Language Models enhanced Representation Learning for Conversational Recommender Systems
Zhangchi Qiu, Ye Tao, Shirui Pan, Alan Wee-Chung Liew
0
0
Conversational recommender systems (CRS) utilize natural language interactions and dialogue history to infer user preferences and provide accurate recommendations. Due to the limited conversation context and background knowledge, existing CRSs rely on external sources such as knowledge graphs to enrich the context and model entities based on their inter-relations. However, these methods ignore the rich intrinsic information within entities. To address this, we introduce the Knowledge-Enhanced Entity Representation Learning (KERL) framework, which leverages both the knowledge graph and a pre-trained language model to improve the semantic understanding of entities for CRS. In our KERL framework, entity textual descriptions are encoded via a pre-trained language model, while a knowledge graph helps reinforce the representation of these entities. We also employ positional encoding to effectively capture the temporal information of entities in a conversation. The enhanced entity representation is then used to develop a recommender component that fuses both entity and contextual representations for more informed recommendations, as well as a dialogue component that generates informative entity-related information in the response text. A high-quality knowledge graph with aligned entity descriptions is constructed to facilitate our study, namely the Wiki Movie Knowledge Graph (WikiMKG). The experimental results show that KERL achieves state-of-the-art results in both recommendation and response generation tasks.
5/2/2024
💬
A Survey on Large Language Models for Recommendation
Likang Wu, Zhi Zheng, Zhaopeng Qiu, Hao Wang, Hongchao Gu, Tingjia Shen, Chuan Qin, Chen Zhu, Hengshu Zhu, Qi Liu, Hui Xiong, Enhong Chen
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools in the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and have recently gained significant attention in the domain of Recommendation Systems (RS). These models, trained on massive amounts of data using self-supervised learning, have demonstrated remarkable success in learning universal representations and have the potential to enhance various aspects of recommendation systems by some effective transfer techniques such as fine-tuning and prompt tuning, and so on. The crucial aspect of harnessing the power of language models in enhancing recommendation quality is the utilization of their high-quality representations of textual features and their extensive coverage of external knowledge to establish correlations between items and users. To provide a comprehensive understanding of the existing LLM-based recommendation systems, this survey presents a taxonomy that categorizes these models into two major paradigms, respectively Discriminative LLM for Recommendation (DLLM4Rec) and Generative LLM for Recommendation (GLLM4Rec), with the latter being systematically sorted out for the first time. Furthermore, we systematically review and analyze existing LLM-based recommendation systems within each paradigm, providing insights into their methodologies, techniques, and performance. Additionally, we identify key challenges and several valuable findings to provide researchers and practitioners with inspiration. We have also created a GitHub repository to index relevant papers on LLMs for recommendation, https://github.com/WLiK/LLM4Rec.
6/19/2024