LLM-assisted Concept Discovery: Automatically Identifying and Explaining Neuron Functions

Overview

• This paper presents a novel approach for automatically identifying and explaining the functions of individual neurons in large language models (LLMs) using natural language processing techniques.
• The proposed method, called LLM-assisted Concept Discovery, aims to bridge the gap between the abstract representations learned by LLMs and the human-interpretable concepts that underlie them.
• The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through experiments on various LLM architectures, showing how it can uncover meaningful neuron functions and provide intuitive explanations for them.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new technique for understanding how large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 work under the hood. LLMs are powerful AI systems that can generate human-like text, but their inner workings are often opaque and difficult for humans to comprehend.

The researchers developed a method called LLM-assisted Concept Discovery that can automatically identify the specific "concepts" or ideas that individual neurons in an LLM are representing. For example, one neuron might specialize in recognizing names of cities, while another might be tuned to detect emotions in text. Previous research has shown that LLMs do learn these kinds of meaningful concepts, but it's been challenging to figure out exactly what each neuron is doing.

The new technique uses natural language processing to analyze the activations of individual neurons and generate plain-English explanations of their functions. This helps make the inner workings of LLMs more transparent and interpretable to researchers and developers. Other work has also explored ways to make neural networks more interpretable, but this paper presents a novel approach tailored specifically for LLMs.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method through experiments on various LLM architectures, showing that it can uncover insightful and meaningful neuron functions. This could have important implications for understanding and improving the capabilities of these powerful language models.

Technical Explanation

The core of the LLM-assisted Concept Discovery approach is to leverage the natural language processing capabilities of LLMs themselves to automatically identify and explain the functions of individual neurons. The method works as follows:

1. The researchers first select a set of "probe" inputs - carefully crafted text prompts designed to activate specific neuron subsets.
2. They then analyze the activations of individual neurons in response to these probe inputs, looking for patterns that suggest the neurons are encoding particular concepts or ideas.
3. Finally, they generate natural language explanations for the identified neuron functions by prompting the LLM to describe what each neuron seems to be representing.

The authors evaluate their approach on several state-of-the-art LLM architectures, including GPT-3 and T5. They show that the technique can uncover a diverse range of meaningful neuron functions, from detecting named entities and sentiment to tracking discourse structure and reasoning about abstract concepts.

Importantly, the explanations provided by the LLM-assisted method are not just lists of keywords or features, but rather natural language descriptions that can be readily understood by human researchers and developers. This represents a significant advance over previous interpretability techniques that rely more on statistical analysis or feature visualization.

Critical Analysis

The LLM-assisted Concept Discovery approach presents a promising step forward in making large language models more transparent and interpretable. By harnessing the language understanding capabilities of the LLMs themselves, the method can provide intuitive explanations of neuron functions that align well with human intuitions.

However, the paper also acknowledges some important limitations and caveats. First, the technique is constrained by the coverage and accuracy of the LLM used to generate the explanations - if the LLM has biases or gaps in its knowledge, these may be reflected in the explanations. There is also the potential for circularity, where the LLM's own internal representations influence the way it describes its own neurons.

Additionally, the paper only explores the identification and explanation of individual neuron functions. While this provides valuable insights, the overall behavior of an LLM ultimately emerges from the complex interactions between many neurons. Techniques for understanding these higher-level, system-wide dynamics remain an important area for future research.

It will also be crucial to further validate the explanations provided by the LLM-assisted method, ensuring they align with human intuitions and can be used to meaningfully improve LLM performance and robustness. User studies and comparisons to other interpretability approaches will be important next steps.

Conclusion

The LLM-assisted Concept Discovery method represents an exciting advancement in the quest to make large language models more transparent and interpretable. By leveraging the natural language processing capabilities of LLMs themselves, the technique can uncover the functions of individual neurons and provide human-understandable explanations of their inner workings.

While the approach has some limitations and areas for further research, it demonstrates the potential for AI systems to help explain their own behaviors and decisions. As LLMs become increasingly influential in our daily lives, techniques like this will be crucial for building trust, accountability, and a deeper understanding of these powerful technologies.