A Self-explaining Neural Architecture for Generalizable Concept Learning
2405.00349
0
0
Abstract
With the wide proliferation of Deep Neural Networks in high-stake applications, there is a growing demand for explainability behind their decision-making process. Concept learning models attempt to learn high-level 'concepts' - abstract entities that align with human understanding, and thus provide interpretability to DNN architectures. However, in this paper, we demonstrate that present SOTA concept learning approaches suffer from two major problems - lack of concept fidelity wherein the models fail to learn consistent concepts among similar classes and limited concept interoperability wherein the models fail to generalize learned concepts to new domains for the same task. Keeping these in mind, we propose a novel self-explaining architecture for concept learning across domains which - i) incorporates a new concept saliency network for representative concept selection, ii) utilizes contrastive learning to capture representative domain invariant concepts, and iii) uses a novel prototype-based concept grounding regularization to improve concept alignment across domains. We demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed approach over current SOTA concept learning approaches on four widely used real-world datasets. Empirical results show that our method improves both concept fidelity measured through concept overlap and concept interoperability measured through domain adaptation performance.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a self-explaining neural architecture for generalizable concept learning.
- The model aims to learn and explain high-level visual concepts in a more interpretable way than traditional black-box neural networks.
- The approach involves jointly training the neural network to perform a task while also learning to explain the concepts it is using to make predictions.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers have developed a new type of artificial intelligence (AI) model that not only learns to perform a task, but also explains the reasoning behind its decisions. Traditional AI models can be like black boxes - you put data in and get a result out, but it's not always clear how the model arrived at that conclusion.
In contrast, this new model is designed to be more transparent. As it learns, it also builds an understanding of the key visual concepts it is using to make its predictions. For example, if the model is trained to identify different types of animals in images, it will not only learn to accurately classify the animals, but will also be able to point to the specific features it is focusing on (like the shape of an ear or the color of fur) to explain its reasoning.
The researchers believe this type of self-explaining model could be very useful, as it allows us to better understand and trust the decisions made by AI systems. It also has the potential to enable more generalizable concept learning, where the model can apply its learned concepts to new situations, rather than just memorizing specific examples.
Technical Explanation
The core of this approach is a neural network architecture that is trained on two parallel tasks. The first task is the primary objective, such as classifying images of animals. The second task is to learn an interpretable representation of the key visual concepts the model is using to make its predictions.
To achieve this, the model has separate branches - one for the main task and one for the explanation task. The explanation branch learns to generate human-understandable descriptions of the relevant visual concepts, such as "pointy ears", "brown fur", etc. These concept descriptions are then used to provide explanations for the model's decisions on the primary task.
The researchers evaluated this approach on several benchmarks for image classification and visual reasoning. They found that the self-explaining model was able to achieve comparable performance to traditional black-box models, while also providing meaningful explanations for its decisions.
The explanations were validated through both quantitative and qualitative analyses, demonstrating that the model was indeed capturing and communicating the relevant high-level visual concepts, rather than just memorizing low-level features.
Critical Analysis
A key advantage of this self-explaining architecture is the potential for improved model interpretability and increased user trust in AI systems. By making the model's reasoning more transparent, it becomes easier to understand, debug, and validate the decisions it is making.
However, the paper does note some limitations. The approach relies on having a predefined set of visual concepts that the model can learn to recognize and explain. In more open-ended domains, the model may struggle to discover and explain novel, previously unseen concepts.
Additionally, the process of jointly training the model on the primary task and the explanation task could be challenging, and the researchers acknowledge that further work is needed to optimize this training process.
Overall, this self-explaining neural architecture represents an interesting step towards more interpretable and generalizable AI. While there are still some open challenges, the ability to provide human-understandable explanations for model decisions is a valuable capability that could lead to more trustworthy and transparent AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel neural architecture that learns to not only perform a task, but also explain the reasoning behind its decisions. By training the model to simultaneously learn the primary objective and an interpretable representation of the relevant visual concepts, the researchers have developed a self-explaining system that can provide meaningful explanations for its predictions.
The potential benefits of this approach include improved model interpretability, increased user trust, and more generalizable concept learning. While there are still some limitations to address, this work represents an important step towards building AI systems that are not only capable, but also transparent and trustworthy.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
From Neural Activations to Concepts: A Survey on Explaining Concepts in Neural Networks
Jae Hee Lee, Sergio Lanza, Stefan Wermter
0
0
In this paper, we review recent approaches for explaining concepts in neural networks. Concepts can act as a natural link between learning and reasoning: once the concepts are identified that a neural learning system uses, one can integrate those concepts with a reasoning system for inference or use a reasoning system to act upon them to improve or enhance the learning system. On the other hand, knowledge can not only be extracted from neural networks but concept knowledge can also be inserted into neural network architectures. Since integrating learning and reasoning is at the core of neuro-symbolic AI, the insights gained from this survey can serve as an important step towards realizing neuro-symbolic AI based on explainable concepts.
5/6/2024
❗
Advancing Ante-Hoc Explainable Models through Generative Adversarial Networks
Tanmay Garg, Deepika Vemuri, Vineeth N Balasubramanian
0
0
This paper presents a novel concept learning framework for enhancing model interpretability and performance in visual classification tasks. Our approach appends an unsupervised explanation generator to the primary classifier network and makes use of adversarial training. During training, the explanation module is optimized to extract visual concepts from the classifier's latent representations, while the GAN-based module aims to discriminate images generated from concepts, from true images. This joint training scheme enables the model to implicitly align its internally learned concepts with human-interpretable visual properties. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate the robustness of our approach, while producing coherent concept activations. We analyse the learned concepts, showing their semantic concordance with object parts and visual attributes. We also study how perturbations in the adversarial training protocol impact both classification and concept acquisition. In summary, this work presents a significant step towards building inherently interpretable deep vision models with task-aligned concept representations - a key enabler for developing trustworthy AI for real-world perception tasks.
4/4/2024
LLM-assisted Concept Discovery: Automatically Identifying and Explaining Neuron Functions
Nhat Hoang-Xuan, Minh Vu, My T. Thai
0
0
Providing textual concept-based explanations for neurons in deep neural networks (DNNs) is of importance in understanding how a DNN model works. Prior works have associated concepts with neurons based on examples of concepts or a pre-defined set of concepts, thus limiting possible explanations to what the user expects, especially in discovering new concepts. Furthermore, defining the set of concepts requires manual work from the user, either by directly specifying them or collecting examples. To overcome these, we propose to leverage multimodal large language models for automatic and open-ended concept discovery. We show that, without a restricted set of pre-defined concepts, our method gives rise to novel interpretable concepts that are more faithful to the model's behavior. To quantify this, we validate each concept by generating examples and counterexamples and evaluating the neuron's response on this new set of images. Collectively, our method can discover concepts and simultaneously validate them, providing a credible automated tool to explain deep neural networks.
6/14/2024
🚀
Global Concept Explanations for Graphs by Contrastive Learning
Jonas Teufel, Pascal Friederich
0
0
Beyond improving trust and validating model fairness, xAI practices also have the potential to recover valuable scientific insights in application domains where little to no prior human intuition exists. To that end, we propose a method to extract global concept explanations from the predictions of graph neural networks to develop a deeper understanding of the tasks underlying structure-property relationships. We identify concept explanations as dense clusters in the self-explaining Megan models subgraph latent space. For each concept, we optimize a representative prototype graph and optionally use GPT-4 to provide hypotheses about why each structure has a certain effect on the prediction. We conduct computational experiments on synthetic and real-world graph property prediction tasks. For the synthetic tasks we find that our method correctly reproduces the structural rules by which they were created. For real-world molecular property regression and classification tasks, we find that our method rediscovers established rules of thumb. More specifically, our results for molecular mutagenicity prediction indicate more fine-grained resolution of structural details than existing explainability methods, consistent with previous results from chemistry literature. Overall, our results show promising capability to extract the underlying structure-property relationships for complex graph property prediction tasks.
4/26/2024