Margin-aware Preference Optimization for Aligning Diffusion Models without Reference

Overview

• This paper focuses on addressing the challenge of aligning recent text-to-image diffusion models, such as Stable Diffusion XL (SDXL), with human preferences.
• Conventional alignment techniques like RLHF and DPO can be limited when there is a clear distributional discrepancy between the preference data and the reference model.
• The authors propose a novel method called Margin-Aware Preference Optimization (MaPO) that does not rely on a reference model and jointly maximizes the likelihood margin between preferred and dispreferred image sets, while also learning general stylistic features and preferences.

Plain English Explanation

Diffusion models, like Stable Diffusion XL, are powerful AI systems that can generate images from text descriptions. However, aligning these models with human preferences can be challenging, especially when there is a mismatch between the reference model and the preference data.

Conventional approaches, such as Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) and Divergent Policy Optimization (DPO), often rely on a reference model to guide the alignment process. But this can be limiting when the reference model and the preference data have very different distributions, like when users prefer a particular artistic style that the reference model doesn't capture well.

To address this issue, the researchers propose a new method called Margin-Aware Preference Optimization (MaPO). Instead of using a reference model, MaPO jointly optimizes the likelihood margin between preferred and dispreferred image sets, while also learning the general stylistic features and preferences. This allows the model to be more flexible and better aligned with human preferences, even when there is a clear distributional mismatch.

The researchers also introduce two new datasets, Pick-Style and Pick-Safety, which simulate diverse scenarios of reference mismatch. Their experiments show that MaPO can significantly improve alignment on these datasets and outperform other existing methods when used with the Pick-a-Pic v2 dataset.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the alignment of recent text-to-image diffusion models, such as Stable Diffusion XL (SDXL), with human preferences. Conventional alignment techniques like RLHF and DPO often rely on divergence regularization relative to a reference model to ensure training stability. However, this approach can limit the flexibility of models during alignment, especially when there is a clear distributional discrepancy between the preference data and the reference model.

To address this challenge, the authors propose a novel and memory-friendly preference alignment method for diffusion models called Margin-Aware Preference Optimization (MaPO). MaPO does not depend on any reference model and instead jointly maximizes the likelihood margin between the preferred and dispreferred image sets, while also learning general stylistic features and preferences.

For evaluation, the researchers introduce two new pairwise preference datasets, Pick-Style and Pick-Safety, which simulate diverse scenarios of reference mismatch. Their experiments show that MaPO can significantly improve alignment on these datasets and outperform other existing methods when used with the Pick-a-Pic v2 dataset.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling solution to the challenge of aligning diffusion models with human preferences, especially when there is a clear distributional discrepancy between the preference data and the reference model. The authors' proposed MaPO method, which doesn't rely on a reference model, is a promising approach that could have broader applications beyond text-to-image generation.

However, the paper does not extensively discuss the potential limitations or caveats of the MaPO method. For instance, it would be interesting to understand how well MaPO performs in scenarios where the preferred and dispreferred image sets are not well-defined or have significant overlap. Additionally, the paper could have explored the potential computational and memory trade-offs of the MaPO approach compared to reference-based methods.

Furthermore, the paper's introduction of the Pick-Style and Pick-Safety datasets is a valuable contribution, as it provides a way to evaluate alignment methods in more realistic scenarios. However, it would be helpful to understand how these datasets were constructed and how they relate to real-world preference alignment challenges.

Overall, the paper presents a well-designed and effective solution to a significant problem in the field of AI alignment. By encouraging readers to think critically about the research and its potential limitations, the authors could further strengthen the impact of their work and inspire future research in this important area.

Conclusion

This paper addresses the challenge of aligning recent text-to-image diffusion models, such as Stable Diffusion XL, with human preferences. The authors propose a novel method called Margin-Aware Preference Optimization (MaPO) that does not rely on a reference model, but instead jointly maximizes the likelihood margin between preferred and dispreferred image sets, while also learning general stylistic features and preferences.

The researchers' experiments demonstrate that MaPO can significantly improve alignment on their newly introduced Pick-Style and Pick-Safety datasets, which simulate diverse scenarios of reference mismatch. When used with the Pick-a-Pic v2 dataset, MaPO also outperforms other existing alignment methods.

This work represents an important step forward in the field of AI alignment, as it addresses a key limitation of conventional approaches and introduces a more flexible and effective way to align diffusion models with human preferences. The insights and techniques presented in this paper could inspire further research and development in this critical area, ultimately leading to AI systems that are better aligned with human values and priorities.