Measurement Simplification in rho-POMDP with Performance Guarantees
2309.10701
0
0
Abstract
Decision making under uncertainty is at the heart of any autonomous system acting with imperfect information. The cost of solving the decision making problem is exponential in the action and observation spaces, thus rendering it unfeasible for many online systems. This paper introduces a novel approach to efficient decision-making, by partitioning the high-dimensional observation space. Using the partitioned observation space, we formulate analytical bounds on the expected information-theoretic reward, for general belief distributions. These bounds are then used to plan efficiently while keeping performance guarantees. We show that the bounds are adaptive, computationally efficient, and that they converge to the original solution. We extend the partitioning paradigm and present a hierarchy of partitioned spaces that allows greater efficiency in planning. We then propose a specific variant of these bounds for Gaussian beliefs and show a theoretical performance improvement of at least a factor of 4. Finally, we compare our novel method to other state of the art algorithms in active SLAM scenarios, in simulation and in real experiments. In both cases we show a significant speed-up in planning with performance guarantees.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a method to simplify the measurement process in Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) while maintaining performance guarantees.
- The approach, called Measurement Simplification in Ļ-POMDP, aims to reduce the number of observations required for decision-making without compromising the quality of the resulting policy.
- The research introduces a framework to quantify the tradeoff between measurement complexity and policy performance, and provides theoretical guarantees on the performance of the simplified POMDP.
Plain English Explanation
In many real-world decision-making problems, the system's state is not fully observable - we can only get partial information about it through measurements or observations. Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) are a mathematical framework used to model and solve these types of problems, where the agent must take actions based on incomplete information about the environment.
However, the measurement or observation process in POMDPs can be complex and resource-intensive, requiring a large number of sensors or data sources. This paper proposes a way to simplify the measurement process without sacrificing the quality of the decisions made by the agent.
The key idea is to find a way to reduce the number of observations needed, while still maintaining good performance of the overall decision-making system. The researchers introduce a framework that allows them to quantify the tradeoff between measurement complexity and policy performance, and provide theoretical guarantees on the performance of the simplified POMDP.
This work could be useful in a variety of applications where POMDPs are used, such as robot navigation, healthcare monitoring, or autonomous decision-making. By reducing the measurement complexity, it can make these systems more efficient and practical to deploy in real-world settings.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new framework called Measurement Simplification in Ļ-POMDP, which aims to reduce the number of observations required in a POMDP without compromising the quality of the resulting policy.
The key idea is to define a risk-averse POMDP variant, denoted as Ļ-POMDP, where the agent's objective is to find a policy that maximizes the worst-case expected reward. This formulation allows the researchers to quantify the tradeoff between measurement complexity and policy performance.
The paper then presents an algorithm to solve the Ļ-POMDP with a simplified measurement model, while providing performance guarantees on the quality of the resulting policy compared to the original, fully-observed POMDP. This is done by carefully bounding the loss in performance due to the measurement simplification.
The researchers also show that their approach can be combined with other techniques, such as belief state compression, to further improve the efficiency of the overall decision-making system.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a solid theoretical foundation for the Measurement Simplification in Ļ-POMDP framework and presents encouraging empirical results. However, some potential limitations and areas for further research are:
-
The performance guarantees are derived under certain assumptions, such as the linearity of the reward function and the Lipschitz continuity of the value function. It would be valuable to explore the robustness of the approach to violations of these assumptions.
-
The experiments are conducted on relatively small-scale benchmark problems. It is important to evaluate the scalability of the method to larger, more complex real-world problems.
-
The paper does not address the practical challenges of implementing the proposed approach, such as the computational complexity of the algorithms or the sensitivity to modeling errors in the POMDP parameters.
-
While the risk-averse formulation is a strength of the approach, it may not be appropriate for all applications. It would be interesting to explore extensions that can handle different objective functions or risk preferences.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel framework for simplifying the measurement process in POMDPs while providing performance guarantees on the resulting policy. By introducing the Ļ-POMDP formulation and an associated algorithm, the researchers show how to effectively balance measurement complexity and decision-making quality.
This work could have significant implications for a wide range of applications that rely on POMDPs, from robotics and autonomous systems to healthcare and finance. By reducing the burden of the observation process, it can make these systems more efficient, practical, and accessible, ultimately leading to better decision-making in the face of partial information.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Simplification of Risk Averse POMDPs with Performance Guarantees
Yaacov Pariente, Vadim Indelman
0
0
Risk averse decision making under uncertainty in partially observable domains is a fundamental problem in AI and essential for reliable autonomous agents. In our case, the problem is modeled using partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs), when the value function is the conditional value at risk (CVaR) of the return. Calculating an optimal solution for POMDPs is computationally intractable in general. In this work we develop a simplification framework to speedup the evaluation of the value function, while providing performance guarantees. We consider as simplification a computationally cheaper belief-MDP transition model, that can correspond, e.g., to cheaper observation or transition models. Our contributions include general bounds for CVaR that allow bounding the CVaR of a random variable X, using a random variable Y, by assuming bounds between their cumulative distributions. We then derive bounds for the CVaR value function in a POMDP setting, and show how to bound the value function using the computationally cheaper belief-MDP transition model and without accessing the computationally expensive model in real-time. Then, we provide theoretical performance guarantees for the estimated bounds. Our results apply for a general simplification of a belief-MDP transition model and support simplification of both the observation and state transition models simultaneously.
6/11/2024
No Compromise in Solution Quality: Speeding Up Belief-dependent Continuous POMDPs via Adaptive Multilevel Simplification
Andrey Zhitnikov, Ori Sztyglic, Vadim Indelman
0
0
Continuous POMDPs with general belief-dependent rewards are notoriously difficult to solve online. In this paper, we present a complete provable theory of adaptive multilevel simplification for the setting of a given externally constructed belief tree and MCTS that constructs the belief tree on the fly using an exploration technique. Our theory allows to accelerate POMDP planning with belief-dependent rewards without any sacrifice in the quality of the obtained solution. We rigorously prove each theoretical claim in the proposed unified theory. Using the general theoretical results, we present three algorithms to accelerate continuous POMDP online planning with belief-dependent rewards. Our two algorithms, SITH-BSP and LAZY-SITH-BSP, can be utilized on top of any method that constructs a belief tree externally. The third algorithm, SITH-PFT, is an anytime MCTS method that permits to plug-in any exploration technique. All our methods are guaranteed to return exactly the same optimal action as their unsimplified equivalents. We replace the costly computation of information-theoretic rewards with novel adaptive upper and lower bounds which we derive in this paper, and are of independent interest. We show that they are easy to calculate and can be tightened by the demand of our algorithms. Our approach is general; namely, any bounds that monotonically converge to the reward can be utilized to achieve significant speedup without any loss in performance. Our theory and algorithms support the challenging setting of continuous states, actions, and observations. The beliefs can be parametric or general and represented by weighted particles. We demonstrate in simulation a significant speedup in planning compared to baseline approaches with guaranteed identical performance.
5/24/2024
š
Provable Representation with Efficient Planning for Partial Observable Reinforcement Learning
Hongming Zhang, Tongzheng Ren, Chenjun Xiao, Dale Schuurmans, Bo Dai
0
0
In most real-world reinforcement learning applications, state information is only partially observable, which breaks the Markov decision process assumption and leads to inferior performance for algorithms that conflate observations with state. Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), on the other hand, provide a general framework that allows for partial observability to be accounted for in learning, exploration and planning, but presents significant computational and statistical challenges. To address these difficulties, we develop a representation-based perspective that leads to a coherent framework and tractable algorithmic approach for practical reinforcement learning from partial observations. We provide a theoretical analysis for justifying the statistical efficiency of the proposed algorithm, and also empirically demonstrate the proposed algorithm can surpass state-of-the-art performance with partial observations across various benchmarks, advancing reliable reinforcement learning towards more practical applications.
6/12/2024
š¼ļø
What should be observed for optimal reward in POMDPs?
Alyzia-Maria Konsta, Alberto Lluch Lafuente, Christoph Matheja
0
0
Partially observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) are a standard model for agents making decisions in uncertain environments. Most work on POMDPs focuses on synthesizing strategies based on the available capabilities. However, system designers can often control an agent's observation capabilities, e.g. by placing or selecting sensors. This raises the question of how one should select an agent's sensors cost-effectively such that it achieves the desired goals. In this paper, we study the novel optimal observability problem OOP: Given a POMDP M, how should one change M's observation capabilities within a fixed budget such that its (minimal) expected reward remains below a given threshold? We show that the problem is undecidable in general and decidable when considering positional strategies only. We present two algorithms for a decidable fragment of the OOP: one based on optimal strategies of M's underlying Markov decision process and one based on parameter synthesis with SMT. We report promising results for variants of typical examples from the POMDP literature.
5/20/2024