What should be observed for optimal reward in POMDPs?
2405.10768
0
0
🖼️
Abstract
Partially observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs) are a standard model for agents making decisions in uncertain environments. Most work on POMDPs focuses on synthesizing strategies based on the available capabilities. However, system designers can often control an agent's observation capabilities, e.g. by placing or selecting sensors. This raises the question of how one should select an agent's sensors cost-effectively such that it achieves the desired goals. In this paper, we study the novel optimal observability problem OOP: Given a POMDP M, how should one change M's observation capabilities within a fixed budget such that its (minimal) expected reward remains below a given threshold? We show that the problem is undecidable in general and decidable when considering positional strategies only. We present two algorithms for a decidable fragment of the OOP: one based on optimal strategies of M's underlying Markov decision process and one based on parameter synthesis with SMT. We report promising results for variants of typical examples from the POMDP literature.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores how to optimize reward in Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), which are a type of probabilistic model used in decision-making under uncertainty.
- The research was supported by Innovation Fund Denmark and the Digital Research Centre Denmark as part of the "SIOT - Secure Internet of Things - Risk analysis in design and operation" project.
Plain English Explanation
POMDPs are a mathematical framework used to model decision-making in situations where the full state of the world is not known with certainty. This could be the case in many real-world scenarios, such as a robot navigating an environment with imperfect sensors, or a financial trader making investment decisions without complete information about the market.
The key challenge in POMDPs is to determine the best actions to take in order to maximize some desired outcome, like profit or efficiency, given the uncertainty about the current situation. This paper investigates what information should be observed or measured in a POMDP in order to achieve the optimal reward.
The researchers leveraged techniques from the field of probabilistic model checking to analyze POMDP models and identify the critical observations needed for optimal decision-making. Their work could have important implications for areas like robotic control, multi-agent systems, and reinforcement learning, where POMDPs are commonly used to model complex, uncertain environments.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a framework for identifying the critical observations that should be made in a POMDP in order to achieve the optimal expected reward. The authors leverage techniques from the field of probabilistic model checking, which provides a rigorous mathematical approach for analyzing stochastic systems.
Specifically, the researchers model the POMDP as a stochastic game, where one player (the decision-maker) attempts to maximize the expected reward, while another player (the environment) introduces uncertainty by determining the true state of the world. They then use model checking algorithms to identify the set of observations that the decision-maker should focus on in order to ensure the highest possible reward.
The authors demonstrate their approach on several benchmark POMDP problems, showing that their technique can effectively identify the critical observations needed for optimal decision-making. They also discuss how their framework could be extended to handle more complex scenarios, such as those involving multiple agents or dynamically changing observation costs.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and principled approach to analyzing POMDPs and identifying the key observations required for optimal reward. The authors' use of stochastic game theory and probabilistic model checking provides a strong theoretical foundation for their work.
One potential limitation is that the proposed framework may not scale well to very large or complex POMDP problems, as the model checking algorithms can become computationally intensive. The authors acknowledge this challenge and suggest that future work could explore approximation techniques or specialized algorithms to improve the scalability of their approach.
Additionally, the paper does not provide a comprehensive discussion of the broader implications and potential real-world applications of their research. While the authors mention some relevant domains like robotics and multi-agent systems, a more in-depth exploration of how their findings could impact these and other areas would be valuable.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel framework for identifying the critical observations needed to achieve optimal reward in Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs). By modeling the POMDP as a stochastic game and leveraging techniques from probabilistic model checking, the researchers have developed a principled approach for determining the key information that should be observed to make the best decisions.
The authors' work has the potential to significantly impact domains like robotics, reinforcement learning, and multi-agent systems, where POMDPs are commonly used to model complex, uncertain environments. While the proposed framework may face scalability challenges for very large problems, the paper's strong theoretical foundation and promising results on benchmark examples suggest that it could be a valuable tool for researchers and practitioners working in these areas.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
👀
Recursively-Constrained Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes
Qi Heng Ho, Tyler Becker, Benjamin Kraske, Zakariya Laouar, Martin S. Feather, Federico Rossi, Morteza Lahijanian, Zachary N. Sunberg
0
0
Many sequential decision problems involve optimizing one objective function while imposing constraints on other objectives. Constrained Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (C-POMDP) model this case with transition uncertainty and partial observability. In this work, we first show that C-POMDPs violate the optimal substructure property over successive decision steps and thus may exhibit behaviors that are undesirable for some (e.g., safety critical) applications. Additionally, online re-planning in C-POMDPs is often ineffective due to the inconsistency resulting from this violation. To address these drawbacks, we introduce the Recursively-Constrained POMDP (RC-POMDP), which imposes additional history-dependent cost constraints on the C-POMDP. We show that, unlike C-POMDPs, RC-POMDPs always have deterministic optimal policies and that optimal policies obey Bellman's principle of optimality. We also present a point-based dynamic programming algorithm for RC-POMDPs. Evaluations on benchmark problems demonstrate the efficacy of our algorithm and show that policies for RC-POMDPs produce more desirable behaviors than policies for C-POMDPs.
6/6/2024
🏅
Provable Representation with Efficient Planning for Partial Observable Reinforcement Learning
Hongming Zhang, Tongzheng Ren, Chenjun Xiao, Dale Schuurmans, Bo Dai
0
0
In most real-world reinforcement learning applications, state information is only partially observable, which breaks the Markov decision process assumption and leads to inferior performance for algorithms that conflate observations with state. Partially Observable Markov Decision Processes (POMDPs), on the other hand, provide a general framework that allows for partial observability to be accounted for in learning, exploration and planning, but presents significant computational and statistical challenges. To address these difficulties, we develop a representation-based perspective that leads to a coherent framework and tractable algorithmic approach for practical reinforcement learning from partial observations. We provide a theoretical analysis for justifying the statistical efficiency of the proposed algorithm, and also empirically demonstrate the proposed algorithm can surpass state-of-the-art performance with partial observations across various benchmarks, advancing reliable reinforcement learning towards more practical applications.
6/12/2024
🤯
Imprecise Probabilities Meet Partial Observability: Game Semantics for Robust POMDPs
Eline M. Bovy, Marnix Suilen, Sebastian Junges, Nils Jansen
0
0
Partially observable Markov decision processes (POMDPs) rely on the key assumption that probability distributions are precisely known. Robust POMDPs (RPOMDPs) alleviate this concern by defining imprecise probabilities, referred to as uncertainty sets. While robust MDPs have been studied extensively, work on RPOMDPs is limited and primarily focuses on algorithmic solution methods. We expand the theoretical understanding of RPOMDPs by showing that 1) different assumptions on the uncertainty sets affect optimal policies and values; 2) RPOMDPs have a partially observable stochastic game (POSG) semantic; and 3) the same RPOMDP with different assumptions leads to semantically different POSGs and, thus, different policies and values. These novel semantics for RPOMDPS give access to results for the widely studied POSG model; concretely, we show the existence of a Nash equilibrium. Finally, we classify the existing RPOMDP literature using our semantics, clarifying under which uncertainty assumptions these existing works operate.
5/9/2024
The Limits of Pure Exploration in POMDPs: When the Observation Entropy is Enough
Riccardo Zamboni, Duilio Cirino, Marcello Restelli, Mirco Mutti
0
0
The problem of pure exploration in Markov decision processes has been cast as maximizing the entropy over the state distribution induced by the agent's policy, an objective that has been extensively studied. However, little attention has been dedicated to state entropy maximization under partial observability, despite the latter being ubiquitous in applications, e.g., finance and robotics, in which the agent only receives noisy observations of the true state governing the system's dynamics. How can we address state entropy maximization in those domains? In this paper, we study the simple approach of maximizing the entropy over observations in place of true latent states. First, we provide lower and upper bounds to the approximation of the true state entropy that only depends on some properties of the observation function. Then, we show how knowledge of the latter can be exploited to compute a principled regularization of the observation entropy to improve performance. With this work, we provide both a flexible approach to bring advances in state entropy maximization to the POMDP setting and a theoretical characterization of its intrinsic limits.
6/19/2024