Measuring Spurious Correlation in Classification: 'Clever Hans' in Translationese
0
🤖
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper investigates the problem of 'Clever Hans' behavior in high-performance neural translation classifiers, where the models exploit spurious correlations, particularly topic information, rather than genuine translationese signals.
- Translationese signals are subtle, especially for professional translations, and compete with other signals like genre, style, author, and topic in the data.
- The paper focuses on topic-based spurious correlation and explores two approaches: (i) where no knowledge about spurious topic information is available, and (ii) where some indication of spurious topic correlations is known.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about a problem called 'Clever Hans' behavior in high-performance neural translation classifiers. These classifiers are designed to identify whether a piece of text is a translation or not. However, the researchers found that the classifiers were often relying on spurious correlations, particularly information about the topic of the text, rather than genuine signals of translation.
The subtle differences that indicate a text is a translation (called 'translationese') can be hard to detect, especially for professional-level translations. These translationese signals have to compete with many other signals in the data, such as the genre, style, author, and topic of the text.
The researchers focused on the problem of topic-based spurious correlations. They looked at two different scenarios: (i) when they had no information about the spurious topic correlations in the data, and (ii) when they had some idea of the nature of these spurious topic correlations.
Technical Explanation
In the first scenario (i), where no knowledge about spurious topic information is available, the researchers developed a measure from first principles to capture the alignment of unsupervised topics with the target classification labels. This measure is equivalent to the 'purity' metric used in clustering and serves as an indication of the presence of spurious topic information in the data. The researchers propose this as a 'topic floor,' similar to a 'noise floor,' for classification performance.
In the second scenario (ii), where some information about the spurious topic correlations is known, the researchers investigated the effects of masking or removing these known spurious topic carriers in the classification task. This approach contributes to quantifying and mitigating the impact of spurious correlations.
Critical Analysis
The paper highlights an important issue in machine learning, where models can exploit spurious correlations in the data rather than focusing on the genuine signals they are intended to capture. This is a significant concern, especially in low-resource settings or when the target signals are subtle, as is the case with translationese.
The researchers' approaches, both in the absence and presence of prior knowledge about spurious topic correlations, provide valuable insights and tools for identifying and mitigating the impact of spurious correlations in machine learning models. However, it would be interesting to see how these methods perform in a broader range of applications and data settings.
Conclusion
This paper highlights the importance of understanding and addressing spurious correlations in machine learning, especially when dealing with subtle target signals. The researchers' approaches provide a framework for quantifying and mitigating the impact of topic-based spurious correlations, which can have significant implications for the reliability and robustness of high-performance classifiers in various domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤖
0
Measuring Spurious Correlation in Classification: 'Clever Hans' in Translationese
Angana Borah, Daria Pylypenko, Cristina Espana-Bonet, Josef van Genabith
Recent work has shown evidence of 'Clever Hans' behavior in high-performance neural translationese classifiers, where BERT-based classifiers capitalize on spurious correlations, in particular topic information, between data and target classification labels, rather than genuine translationese signals. Translationese signals are subtle (especially for professional translation) and compete with many other signals in the data such as genre, style, author, and, in particular, topic. This raises the general question of how much of the performance of a classifier is really due to spurious correlations in the data versus the signals actually targeted for by the classifier, especially for subtle target signals and in challenging (low resource) data settings. We focus on topic-based spurious correlation and approach the question from two directions: (i) where we have no knowledge about spurious topic information and its distribution in the data, (ii) where we have some indication about the nature of spurious topic correlations. For (i) we develop a measure from first principles capturing alignment of unsupervised topics with target classification labels as an indication of spurious topic information in the data. We show that our measure is the same as purity in clustering and propose a 'topic floor' (as in a 'noise floor') for classification. For (ii) we investigate masking of known spurious topic carriers in classification. Both (i) and (ii) contribute to quantifying and (ii) to mitigating spurious correlations.
Read more6/13/2024
0
Spuriousness-Aware Meta-Learning for Learning Robust Classifiers
Guangtao Zheng, Wenqian Ye, Aidong Zhang
Spurious correlations are brittle associations between certain attributes of inputs and target variables, such as the correlation between an image background and an object class. Deep image classifiers often leverage them for predictions, leading to poor generalization on the data where the correlations do not hold. Mitigating the impact of spurious correlations is crucial towards robust model generalization, but it often requires annotations of the spurious correlations in data -- a strong assumption in practice. In this paper, we propose a novel learning framework based on meta-learning, termed SPUME -- SPUriousness-aware MEta-learning, to train an image classifier to be robust to spurious correlations. We design the framework to iteratively detect and mitigate the spurious correlations that the classifier excessively relies on for predictions. To achieve this, we first propose to utilize a pre-trained vision-language model to extract text-format attributes from images. These attributes enable us to curate data with various class-attribute correlations, and we formulate a novel metric to measure the degree of these correlations' spuriousness. Then, to mitigate the reliance on spurious correlations, we propose a meta-learning strategy in which the support (training) sets and query (test) sets in tasks are curated with different spurious correlations that have high degrees of spuriousness. By meta-training the classifier on these spuriousness-aware meta-learning tasks, our classifier can learn to be invariant to the spurious correlations. We demonstrate that our method is robust to spurious correlations without knowing them a priori and achieves the best on five benchmark datasets with different robustness measures.
Read more6/18/2024
0
Learning Robust Classifiers with Self-Guided Spurious Correlation Mitigation
Guangtao Zheng, Wenqian Ye, Aidong Zhang
Deep neural classifiers tend to rely on spurious correlations between spurious attributes of inputs and targets to make predictions, which could jeopardize their generalization capability. Training classifiers robust to spurious correlations typically relies on annotations of spurious correlations in data, which are often expensive to get. In this paper, we tackle an annotation-free setting and propose a self-guided spurious correlation mitigation framework. Our framework automatically constructs fine-grained training labels tailored for a classifier obtained with empirical risk minimization to improve its robustness against spurious correlations. The fine-grained training labels are formulated with different prediction behaviors of the classifier identified in a novel spuriousness embedding space. We construct the space with automatically detected conceptual attributes and a novel spuriousness metric which measures how likely a class-attribute correlation is exploited for predictions. We demonstrate that training the classifier to distinguish different prediction behaviors reduces its reliance on spurious correlations without knowing them a priori and outperforms prior methods on five real-world datasets.
Read more5/7/2024
0
Spurious Correlations in Machine Learning: A Survey
Wenqian Ye, Guangtao Zheng, Xu Cao, Yunsheng Ma, Aidong Zhang
Machine learning systems are known to be sensitive to spurious correlations between non-essential features of the inputs (e.g., background, texture, and secondary objects) and the corresponding labels. These features and their correlations with the labels are known as spurious because they tend to change with shifts in real-world data distributions, which can negatively impact the model's generalization and robustness. In this paper, we provide a review of this issue, along with a taxonomy of current state-of-the-art methods for addressing spurious correlations in machine learning models. Additionally, we summarize existing datasets, benchmarks, and metrics to aid future research. The paper concludes with a discussion of the recent advancements and future challenges in this field, aiming to provide valuable insights for researchers in the related domains.
Read more5/20/2024