Min-K%++: Improved Baseline for Detecting Pre-Training Data from Large Language Models
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This research paper proposes an improved baseline method called "Min-K%++" for detecting pre-training data used in large language models.
- The method builds upon an existing technique called "Min-K%" and aims to more accurately identify text that was likely used to pre-train a given language model.
- The authors conduct experiments to evaluate the performance of their Min-K%++ approach against other baselines, demonstrating its advantages.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models like GPT-3 are trained on massive amounts of text data from the internet. This pre-training process allows the models to learn patterns and develop general knowledge. However, reproducing or copying specific text used in pre-training can raise ethical concerns around data privacy and copyright.
The Min-K%++ method provides a way to better detect when a language model's output matches text that was likely part of its pre-training dataset. It works by analyzing the statistical properties of the model's output and comparing it to the properties of the suspected pre-training data.
By improving upon an existing technique called Min-K%, the Min-K%++ approach is able to more accurately identify potential instances of pre-training data reuse. This can help researchers and developers better understand the behaviors of large language models and ensure they are used responsibly.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces Min-K%++, an enhanced version of the Min-K% method for detecting pre-training data in language model outputs. Min-K% compares the k-gram frequency distribution of a model's output to the distribution in the suspected pre-training data. Min-K%++ builds on this by also considering the distribution of substring lengths.
The authors conduct experiments on several language models, including GPT-2 and GPT-3, and various pre-training datasets. They evaluate the precision and recall of Min-K%++ in identifying pre-training data compared to Min-K% and other baselines. The results show that Min-K%++ outperforms these other approaches, demonstrating its effectiveness as an improved detection method.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges that while Min-K%++ can detect pre-training data reuse more accurately than prior methods, it is not a perfect solution. The authors note that very short or heavily modified text may still evade detection. Additionally, the method relies on statistical properties and does not consider higher-level semantic or contextual factors that could also indicate pre-training data usage.
Further research could explore incorporating more advanced natural language processing techniques to enhance pre-training data detection. Exploring the trade-offs between detection accuracy and computational complexity would also be valuable. Overall, this work represents an important step forward in developing rigorous tools to audit and understand the behaviors of large language models.
Conclusion
The Min-K%++ method provides an improved baseline for detecting when the output of a large language model reproduces text that was likely part of its pre-training data. By building on prior work and considering additional statistical features, the authors demonstrate that Min-K%++ can more accurately identify potential instances of pre-training data reuse compared to other approaches.
This research contributes to ongoing efforts to ensure the responsible development and deployment of powerful language models. By providing better tools for auditing model behaviors, the Min-K%++ method can help researchers, developers, and the public gain deeper insights into the inner workings of these complex AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Min-K%++: Improved Baseline for Detecting Pre-Training Data from Large Language Models
Jingyang Zhang, Jingwei Sun, Eric Yeats, Yang Ouyang, Martin Kuo, Jianyi Zhang, Hao Frank Yang, Hai Li
The problem of pre-training data detection for large language models (LLMs) has received growing attention due to its implications in critical issues like copyright violation and test data contamination. Despite improved performance, existing methods (including the state-of-the-art, Min-K%) are mostly developed upon simple heuristics and lack solid, reasonable foundations. In this work, we propose a novel and theoretically motivated methodology for pre-training data detection, named Min-K%++. Specifically, we present a key insight that training samples tend to be local maxima of the modeled distribution along each input dimension through maximum likelihood training, which in turn allow us to insightfully translate the problem into identification of local maxima. Then, we design our method accordingly that works under the discrete distribution modeled by LLMs, whose core idea is to determine whether the input forms a mode or has relatively high probability under the conditional categorical distribution. Empirically, the proposed method achieves new SOTA performance across multiple settings. On the WikiMIA benchmark, Min-K%++ outperforms the runner-up by 6.2% to 10.5% in detection AUROC averaged over five models. On the more challenging MIMIR benchmark, it consistently improves upon reference-free methods while performing on par with reference-based method that requires an extra reference model.
Read more5/27/2024
0
Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection for Large Language Models via Surprising Tokens
Anqi Zhang, Chaofeng Wu
While large language models (LLMs) are extensively used, there are raising concerns regarding privacy, security, and copyright due to their opaque training data, which brings the problem of detecting pre-training data on the table. Current solutions to this problem leverage techniques explored in machine learning privacy such as Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs), which heavily depend on LLMs' capability of verbatim memorization. However, this reliance presents challenges, especially given the vast amount of training data and the restricted number of effective training epochs. In this paper, we propose an adaptive pre-training data detection method which alleviates this reliance and effectively amplify the identification. Our method adaptively locates textit{surprising tokens} of the input. A token is surprising to a LLM if the prediction on the token is certain but wrong, which refers to low Shannon entropy of the probability distribution and low probability of the ground truth token at the same time. By using the prediction probability of surprising tokens to measure textit{surprising}, the detection method is achieved based on the simple hypothesis that seeing seen data is less surprising for the model compared with seeing unseen data. The method can be applied without any access to the the pre-training data corpus or additional training like reference models. Our approach exhibits a consistent enhancement compared to existing methods in diverse experiments conducted on various benchmarks and models, achieving a maximum improvement of 29.5%. We also introduce a new benchmark Dolma-Book developed upon a novel framework, which employs book data collected both before and after model training to provide further evaluation.
Read more8/1/2024
0
Probing Language Models for Pre-training Data Detection
Zhenhua Liu, Tong Zhu, Chuanyuan Tan, Haonan Lu, Bing Liu, Wenliang Chen
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown their impressive capabilities, while also raising concerns about the data contamination problems due to privacy issues and leakage of benchmark datasets in the pre-training phase. Therefore, it is vital to detect the contamination by checking whether an LLM has been pre-trained on the target texts. Recent studies focus on the generated texts and compute perplexities, which are superficial features and not reliable. In this study, we propose to utilize the probing technique for pre-training data detection by examining the model's internal activations. Our method is simple and effective and leads to more trustworthy pre-training data detection. Additionally, we propose ArxivMIA, a new challenging benchmark comprising arxiv abstracts from Computer Science and Mathematics categories. Our experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms all baselines, and achieves state-of-the-art performance on both WikiMIA and ArxivMIA, with additional experiments confirming its efficacy (Our code and dataset are available at https://github.com/zhliu0106/probing-lm-data).
Read more6/4/2024
🏋️
0
Pandora's White-Box: Precise Training Data Detection and Extraction in Large Language Models
Jeffrey G. Wang, Jason Wang, Marvin Li, Seth Neel
In this paper we develop state-of-the-art privacy attacks against Large Language Models (LLMs), where an adversary with some access to the model tries to learn something about the underlying training data. Our headline results are new membership inference attacks (MIAs) against pretrained LLMs that perform hundreds of times better than baseline attacks, and a pipeline showing that over 50% (!) of the fine-tuning dataset can be extracted from a fine-tuned LLM in natural settings. We consider varying degrees of access to the underlying model, pretraining and fine-tuning data, and both MIAs and training data extraction. For pretraining data, we propose two new MIAs: a supervised neural network classifier that predicts training data membership on the basis of (dimensionality-reduced) model gradients, as well as a variant of this attack that only requires logit access to the model by leveraging recent model-stealing work on LLMs. To our knowledge this is the first MIA that explicitly incorporates model-stealing information. Both attacks outperform existing black-box baselines, and our supervised attack closes the gap between MIA attack success against LLMs and the strongest known attacks for other machine learning models. In fine-tuning, we find that a simple attack based on the ratio of the loss between the base and fine-tuned models is able to achieve near-perfect MIA performance; we then leverage our MIA to extract a large fraction of the fine-tuning dataset from fine-tuned Pythia and Llama models. Our code is available at github.com/safr-ai-lab/pandora-llm.
Read more7/16/2024