Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection for Large Language Models via Surprising Tokens
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a method called "Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection" (APDD) to detect the training data used for large language models.
- APDD uses "surprising tokens" - tokens that the model is not expected to generate - to identify whether a given input text is likely to be in the model's pre-training data.
- The method adaptively updates the set of surprising tokens based on the model's behavior, improving its ability to detect diverse training data.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers developed a technique called "Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection" (APDD) to help identify the data that was used to train large language models, like GPT-3 or BERT. These language models are trained on massive amounts of text data from the internet, but the exact data used is often not known.
APDD works by looking for "surprising tokens" - words or phrases that the language model doesn't expect to see. When the model generates text, it assigns a probability to each possible token. APDD focuses on the tokens that have a very low probability, since those are the ones the model finds most surprising or unexpected.
By tracking which surprising tokens appear in a given text, APDD can determine if that text is likely to be part of the model's original training data. The technique adaptively updates the set of surprising tokens over time, allowing it to detect a wider range of training data.
This is useful because knowing the training data can help us better understand the strengths, biases, and limitations of large language models. It can also assist in related tasks like detecting model-generated text and improving model transparency.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection (APDD) technique, which aims to identify the training data used to pre-train large language models. APDD works by detecting "surprising tokens" - tokens that the model assigns a low probability to generating.
The key idea is that if a given text contains many tokens that the model finds surprising, it is likely that the text is part of the model's original training data. APDD adaptively updates the set of surprising tokens over time, allowing it to detect a wider range of training data.
The paper evaluates APDD on several large language models, including GPT-2, GPT-3, and BERT. The experiments show that APDD can effectively detect training data, outperforming previous approaches in terms of both accuracy and efficiency.
Additionally, the paper discusses how APDD can be used to analyze the biases and limitations of language models by identifying the types of data they were trained on.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to detecting the training data of large language models, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
Generalization to diverse data: While APDD demonstrates strong performance on the evaluated datasets, it's unclear how well the technique would scale to more diverse and heterogeneous training data.
-
Sensitivity to model architecture: The effectiveness of APDD may depend on the specific architecture and training process of the language model. Further research is needed to understand how APDD performs across a wider range of model types.
-
Privacy concerns: Detecting training data raises potential privacy concerns, as it could reveal sensitive information about individuals or organizations represented in the data. The paper does not address these ethical implications.
-
Counteractive techniques: As language model detection methods become more advanced, model developers may develop techniques to obfuscate or hide the training data, which could reduce the effectiveness of APDD over time.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of language model transparency and accountability. However, continued research and discussion around the ethical implications of these techniques will be crucial as they are further developed and deployed.
Conclusion
The "Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection" (APDD) method presented in this paper offers a novel approach to identifying the training data used for large language models. By tracking "surprising tokens" that the models are not expected to generate, APDD can effectively detect whether a given text is likely to be part of the original pre-training data.
This technique has important implications for understanding the strengths, biases, and limitations of language models, as well as for detecting model-generated content and improving model transparency. However, the paper also raises important questions about the ethical considerations and potential privacy concerns associated with these types of data detection methods.
As language models continue to play an increasingly prominent role in our digital landscape, techniques like APDD will be crucial for empowering users, researchers, and policymakers to better understand and regulate these powerful AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection for Large Language Models via Surprising Tokens
Anqi Zhang, Chaofeng Wu
While large language models (LLMs) are extensively used, there are raising concerns regarding privacy, security, and copyright due to their opaque training data, which brings the problem of detecting pre-training data on the table. Current solutions to this problem leverage techniques explored in machine learning privacy such as Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs), which heavily depend on LLMs' capability of verbatim memorization. However, this reliance presents challenges, especially given the vast amount of training data and the restricted number of effective training epochs. In this paper, we propose an adaptive pre-training data detection method which alleviates this reliance and effectively amplify the identification. Our method adaptively locates textit{surprising tokens} of the input. A token is surprising to a LLM if the prediction on the token is certain but wrong, which refers to low Shannon entropy of the probability distribution and low probability of the ground truth token at the same time. By using the prediction probability of surprising tokens to measure textit{surprising}, the detection method is achieved based on the simple hypothesis that seeing seen data is less surprising for the model compared with seeing unseen data. The method can be applied without any access to the the pre-training data corpus or additional training like reference models. Our approach exhibits a consistent enhancement compared to existing methods in diverse experiments conducted on various benchmarks and models, achieving a maximum improvement of 29.5%. We also introduce a new benchmark Dolma-Book developed upon a novel framework, which employs book data collected both before and after model training to provide further evaluation.
Read more8/1/2024
0
Probing Language Models for Pre-training Data Detection
Zhenhua Liu, Tong Zhu, Chuanyuan Tan, Haonan Lu, Bing Liu, Wenliang Chen
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown their impressive capabilities, while also raising concerns about the data contamination problems due to privacy issues and leakage of benchmark datasets in the pre-training phase. Therefore, it is vital to detect the contamination by checking whether an LLM has been pre-trained on the target texts. Recent studies focus on the generated texts and compute perplexities, which are superficial features and not reliable. In this study, we propose to utilize the probing technique for pre-training data detection by examining the model's internal activations. Our method is simple and effective and leads to more trustworthy pre-training data detection. Additionally, we propose ArxivMIA, a new challenging benchmark comprising arxiv abstracts from Computer Science and Mathematics categories. Our experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms all baselines, and achieves state-of-the-art performance on both WikiMIA and ArxivMIA, with additional experiments confirming its efficacy (Our code and dataset are available at https://github.com/zhliu0106/probing-lm-data).
Read more6/4/2024
🏋️
0
Pandora's White-Box: Precise Training Data Detection and Extraction in Large Language Models
Jeffrey G. Wang, Jason Wang, Marvin Li, Seth Neel
In this paper we develop state-of-the-art privacy attacks against Large Language Models (LLMs), where an adversary with some access to the model tries to learn something about the underlying training data. Our headline results are new membership inference attacks (MIAs) against pretrained LLMs that perform hundreds of times better than baseline attacks, and a pipeline showing that over 50% (!) of the fine-tuning dataset can be extracted from a fine-tuned LLM in natural settings. We consider varying degrees of access to the underlying model, pretraining and fine-tuning data, and both MIAs and training data extraction. For pretraining data, we propose two new MIAs: a supervised neural network classifier that predicts training data membership on the basis of (dimensionality-reduced) model gradients, as well as a variant of this attack that only requires logit access to the model by leveraging recent model-stealing work on LLMs. To our knowledge this is the first MIA that explicitly incorporates model-stealing information. Both attacks outperform existing black-box baselines, and our supervised attack closes the gap between MIA attack success against LLMs and the strongest known attacks for other machine learning models. In fine-tuning, we find that a simple attack based on the ratio of the loss between the base and fine-tuned models is able to achieve near-perfect MIA performance; we then leverage our MIA to extract a large fraction of the fine-tuning dataset from fine-tuned Pythia and Llama models. Our code is available at github.com/safr-ai-lab/pandora-llm.
Read more7/16/2024
0
MIA-Tuner: Adapting Large Language Models as Pre-training Text Detector
Wenjie Fu, Huandong Wang, Chen Gao, Guanghua Liu, Yong Li, Tao Jiang
The increasing parameters and expansive dataset of large language models (LLMs) highlight the urgent demand for a technical solution to audit the underlying privacy risks and copyright issues associated with LLMs. Existing studies have partially addressed this need through an exploration of the pre-training data detection problem, which is an instance of a membership inference attack (MIA). This problem involves determining whether a given piece of text has been used during the pre-training phase of the target LLM. Although existing methods have designed various sophisticated MIA score functions to achieve considerable detection performance in pre-trained LLMs, how to achieve high-confidence detection and how to perform MIA on aligned LLMs remain challenging. In this paper, we propose MIA-Tuner, a novel instruction-based MIA method, which instructs LLMs themselves to serve as a more precise pre-training data detector internally, rather than design an external MIA score function. Furthermore, we design two instruction-based safeguards to respectively mitigate the privacy risks brought by the existing methods and MIA-Tuner. To comprehensively evaluate the most recent state-of-the-art LLMs, we collect a more up-to-date MIA benchmark dataset, named WIKIMIA-24, to replace the widely adopted benchmark WIKIMIA. We conduct extensive experiments across various aligned and unaligned LLMs over the two benchmark datasets. The results demonstrate that MIA-Tuner increases the AUC of MIAs from 0.7 to a significantly high level of 0.9.
Read more8/19/2024