The Mirrored Influence Hypothesis: Efficient Data Influence Estimation by Harnessing Forward Passes
2402.08922
0
0
Abstract
Large-scale black-box models have become ubiquitous across numerous applications. Understanding the influence of individual training data sources on predictions made by these models is crucial for improving their trustworthiness. Current influence estimation techniques involve computing gradients for every training point or repeated training on different subsets. These approaches face obvious computational challenges when scaled up to large datasets and models. In this paper, we introduce and explore the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis, highlighting a reciprocal nature of influence between training and test data. Specifically, it suggests that evaluating the influence of training data on test predictions can be reformulated as an equivalent, yet inverse problem: assessing how the predictions for training samples would be altered if the model were trained on specific test samples. Through both empirical and theoretical validations, we demonstrate the wide applicability of our hypothesis. Inspired by this, we introduce a new method for estimating the influence of training data, which requires calculating gradients for specific test samples, paired with a forward pass for each training point. This approach can capitalize on the common asymmetry in scenarios where the number of test samples under concurrent examination is much smaller than the scale of the training dataset, thus gaining a significant improvement in efficiency compared to existing approaches. We demonstrate the applicability of our method across a range of scenarios, including data attribution in diffusion models, data leakage detection, analysis of memorization, mislabeled data detection, and tracing behavior in language models. Our code will be made available at https://github.com/ruoxi-jia-group/Forward-INF.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes the "Mirrored Influence Hypothesis," a novel method for efficiently estimating the influence of training data on model predictions.
- The key idea is to leverage forward passes during training to obtain an estimate of data influence, rather than relying on more computationally expensive techniques like Revisit, Extend, and Enhance Hessian-Free Influence Functions.
- The authors conduct an empirical study to validate their hypothesis and demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach compared to existing methods.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a new way to understand how the data used to train a machine learning model affects the model's predictions. Typically, figuring out the influence of each data point on the model's output is a complex and computationally intensive process. The researchers behind this paper propose a simpler approach called the "Mirrored Influence Hypothesis."
The key idea is to use the information the model generates during its initial training, called "forward passes," to estimate the influence of each data point. This is more efficient than the traditional methods, which often require additional expensive computations. The researchers test their hypothesis through experiments and show that it can provide a good approximation of data influence without all the extra work.
This new approach could be useful for a variety of applications, such as improving deep learning models by analyzing outlier gradients or understanding the factors that drive the predictions of black-box models. By having a faster and more accessible way to estimate data influence, researchers and practitioners can gain deeper insights into their models and potentially make them more robust and reliable.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the "Mirrored Influence Hypothesis," which proposes a more efficient method for estimating the influence of training data on model predictions. The key idea is to leverage the information generated during the forward passes (the computations the model performs to make predictions) to approximate data influence, rather than relying on more computationally expensive techniques like Revisit, Extend, and Enhance Hessian-Free Influence Functions.
The authors conduct an empirical study to validate their hypothesis. They compare the data influence estimates obtained using their proposed method against those from existing approaches, such as Distilled Data Model Reverse Gradient Matching and Revisit, Extend, and Enhance Hessian-Free Influence Functions. The results demonstrate that the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis can provide a good approximation of data influence while being significantly more efficient.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to estimating data influence, but it is important to consider some potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
The authors acknowledge that their method may not capture all the nuances of data influence, as it relies on the information available during forward passes. It would be valuable to explore the accuracy of the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis in more complex model architectures or datasets.
-
The paper focuses on evaluating the method's performance on regression and classification tasks. It would be interesting to see how the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis performs in other domains, such as understanding the influence of training data on GPT models.
-
The authors do not provide a comprehensive analysis of the computational savings achieved by their method compared to existing approaches. A more detailed comparison of the runtime and memory requirements would help quantify the efficiency gains.
Overall, the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis represents an innovative and potentially valuable contribution to the field of data influence estimation. However, further research and validation across a wider range of scenarios would help strengthen the confidence in the method and identify any limitations that require additional consideration.
Conclusion
The paper presents the "Mirrored Influence Hypothesis," a novel approach for efficiently estimating the influence of training data on model predictions. By leveraging the information generated during the forward passes, the proposed method can provide a good approximation of data influence without the computational overhead of more traditional techniques.
The empirical study conducted by the authors demonstrates the effectiveness of the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis, showing that it can outperform existing methods in terms of accuracy and computational efficiency. This research has the potential to enable deeper insights into model behavior and facilitate the development of more robust and reliable machine learning systems.
As the field of machine learning continues to evolve, innovative methods like the Mirrored Influence Hypothesis will be crucial for advancing our understanding of how models learn from data and make predictions. The insights gained from this work can have far-reaching implications for a wide range of applications, from improving deep learning models to enhancing the interpretability of black-box predictions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Distilled Datamodel with Reverse Gradient Matching
Jingwen Ye, Ruonan Yu, Songhua Liu, Xinchao Wang
0
0
The proliferation of large-scale AI models trained on extensive datasets has revolutionized machine learning. With these models taking on increasingly central roles in various applications, the need to understand their behavior and enhance interpretability has become paramount. To investigate the impact of changes in training data on a pre-trained model, a common approach is leave-one-out retraining. This entails systematically altering the training dataset by removing specific samples to observe resulting changes within the model. However, retraining the model for each altered dataset presents a significant computational challenge, given the need to perform this operation for every dataset variation. In this paper, we introduce an efficient framework for assessing data impact, comprising offline training and online evaluation stages. During the offline training phase, we approximate the influence of training data on the target model through a distilled synset, formulated as a reversed gradient matching problem. For online evaluation, we expedite the leave-one-out process using the synset, which is then utilized to compute the attribution matrix based on the evaluation objective. Experimental evaluations, including training data attribution and assessments of data quality, demonstrate that our proposed method achieves comparable model behavior evaluation while significantly speeding up the process compared to the direct retraining method.
4/23/2024
Deeper Understanding of Black-box Predictions via Generalized Influence Functions
Hyeonsu Lyu, Jonggyu Jang, Sehyun Ryu, Hyun Jong Yang
0
0
Influence functions (IFs) elucidate how training data changes model behavior. However, the increasing size and non-convexity in large-scale models make IFs inaccurate. We suspect that the fragility comes from the first-order approximation which may cause nuisance changes in parameters irrelevant to the examined data. However, simply computing influence from the chosen parameters can be misleading, as it fails to nullify the hidden effects of unselected parameters on the analyzed data. Thus, our approach introduces generalized IFs, precisely estimating target parameters' influence while nullifying nuisance gradient changes on fixed parameters. We identify target update parameters closely associated with the input data by the output- and gradient-based parameter selection methods. We verify the generalized IFs with various alternatives of IFs on the class removal and label change tasks. The experiments align with the less is more philosophy, demonstrating that updating only 5% of the model produces more accurate results than other influence functions across all tasks. We believe our proposal works as a foundational tool for optimizing models, conducting data analysis, and enhancing AI interpretability beyond the limitation of IFs. Codes are available at https://github.com/hslyu/GIF.
5/7/2024
Revisit, Extend, and Enhance Hessian-Free Influence Functions
Ziao Yang, Han Yue, Jian Chen, Hongfu Liu
0
0
Influence functions serve as crucial tools for assessing sample influence in model interpretation, subset training set selection, noisy label detection, and more. By employing the first-order Taylor extension, influence functions can estimate sample influence without the need for expensive model retraining. However, applying influence functions directly to deep models presents challenges, primarily due to the non-convex nature of the loss function and the large size of model parameters. This difficulty not only makes computing the inverse of the Hessian matrix costly but also renders it non-existent in some cases. Various approaches, including matrix decomposition, have been explored to expedite and approximate the inversion of the Hessian matrix, with the aim of making influence functions applicable to deep models. In this paper, we revisit a specific, albeit naive, yet effective approximation method known as TracIn. This method substitutes the inverse of the Hessian matrix with an identity matrix. We provide deeper insights into why this simple approximation method performs well. Furthermore, we extend its applications beyond measuring model utility to include considerations of fairness and robustness. Finally, we enhance TracIn through an ensemble strategy. To validate its effectiveness, we conduct experiments on synthetic data and extensive evaluations on noisy label detection, sample selection for large language model fine-tuning, and defense against adversarial attacks.
5/29/2024
On Training Data Influence of GPT Models
Qingyi Liu, Yekun Chai, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun, Qiwei Peng, Keze Wang, Hua Wu
0
0
Amidst the rapid advancements in generative language models, the investigation of how training data shapes the performance of GPT models is still emerging. This paper presents GPTfluence, a novel approach that leverages a featurized simulation to assess the impact of training examples on the training dynamics of GPT models. Our approach not only traces the influence of individual training instances on performance trajectories, such as loss and other key metrics, on targeted test points but also enables a comprehensive comparison with existing methods across various training scenarios in GPT models, ranging from 14 million to 2.8 billion parameters, across a range of downstream tasks. Contrary to earlier methods that struggle with generalization to new data, GPTfluence introduces a parameterized simulation of training dynamics, demonstrating robust generalization capabilities to unseen training data. This adaptability is evident across both fine-tuning and instruction-tuning scenarios, spanning tasks in natural language understanding and generation. We will make our code and data publicly available.
4/17/2024