Mixed-Strategy Nash Equilibrium for Crowd Navigation

2403.01537

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/18/2024 by Muchen Sun, Francesca Baldini, Katie Hughes, Peter Trautman, Todd Murphey
Mixed-Strategy Nash Equilibrium for Crowd Navigation

Abstract

Robots navigating in crowded areas should negotiate free space with humans rather than fully controlling collision avoidance, as this can lead to freezing behavior. Game theory provides a framework for the robot to reason about potential cooperation from humans for collision avoidance during path planning. In particular, the mixed strategy Nash equilibrium captures the negotiation behavior under uncertainty, making it well suited for crowd navigation. However, computing the mixed strategy Nash equilibrium is often prohibitively expensive for real-time decision-making. In this paper, we propose an iterative Bayesian update scheme over probability distributions of trajectories. The algorithm simultaneously generates a stochastic plan for the robot and probabilistic predictions of other pedestrians' paths. We prove that the proposed algorithm is equivalent to solving a mixed strategy game for crowd navigation, and the algorithm guarantees the recovery of the global Nash equilibrium of the game. We name our algorithm Bayes' Rule Nash Equilibrium (BRNE) and develop a real-time model prediction crowd navigation framework. Since BRNE is not solving a general-purpose mixed strategy Nash equilibrium but a tailored formula specifically for crowd navigation, it can compute the solution in real-time on a low-power embedded computer. We evaluate BRNE in both simulated environments and real-world pedestrian datasets. BRNE consistently outperforms non-learning and learning-based methods regarding safety and navigation efficiency. It also reaches human-level crowd navigation performance in the pedestrian dataset benchmark. Lastly, we demonstrate the practicality of our algorithm with real humans on an untethered quadruped robot with fully onboard perception and computation.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper proposes a mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium approach for navigating crowds in multi-agent environments.
  • The goal is to enable autonomous agents to safely and efficiently navigate through crowded spaces alongside human pedestrians.
  • The authors develop a game-theoretic model to capture the strategic interactions between agents and use this to derive an optimal navigation policy.

Plain English Explanation

In crowded environments, such as busy city streets or shopping malls, navigating safely can be challenging for autonomous agents like robots or self-driving cars. These agents need to account for the unpredictable movements of nearby pedestrians and find a way to reach their destination without colliding with anyone.

The researchers in this paper tackle this problem by modeling the navigation task as a game between the autonomous agent and the surrounding pedestrians. They assume that both the agent and the pedestrians are trying to optimize their own movements, and they use a concept from game theory called a "mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium" to find the best strategy for the agent to follow.

The key idea is that the agent should not deterministically choose a single path, but rather should randomly select from a set of possible actions according to some probability distribution. This mixed strategy helps the agent anticipate and respond to the unpredictable decisions of the pedestrians, leading to more efficient and safer navigation.

The authors develop a mathematical framework to compute this optimal mixed strategy and demonstrate its effectiveness through computer simulations and real-world experiments. By taking a game-theoretic approach, they show that autonomous agents can navigate crowded environments much more successfully than using traditional path planning algorithms.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a game-theoretic model for crowd navigation, where the autonomous agent and the surrounding pedestrians are viewed as players in a strategic game. The key contribution is the derivation of a [object Object] for this game, which provides the agent with an optimal stochastic navigation policy.

The authors first define the game model, including the state space, action space, and payoff functions for both the agent and the pedestrians. They then formulate the problem as a two-player, zero-sum game and prove the existence of a mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium solution. This equilibrium represents the optimal mixed strategy for the agent, where it randomly selects actions according to a probability distribution in order to best respond to the expected actions of the pedestrians.

To compute this equilibrium, the authors propose an iterative algorithm that alternates between updating the agent's mixed strategy and the pedestrians' best responses. They demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach through [object Object] and [object Object], showing that the mixed-strategy navigation policy leads to safer and more efficient crowd navigation compared to deterministic path planning methods.

The paper also discusses [object Object] to the basic model, such as incorporating communication between agents and adapting the game dynamics to handle [object Object].

Critical Analysis

The proposed mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium approach offers a principled way to handle the strategic interactions in crowded navigation scenarios. By modeling the problem as a game, the authors are able to derive an optimal stochastic policy for the autonomous agent that accounts for the unpredictable behavior of pedestrians.

However, the game-theoretic framework relies on several simplifying assumptions, such as complete information about the game parameters and the rationality of all players. In real-world settings, these assumptions may not hold, and the autonomous agent may need to deal with partial observability, bounded rationality, and other complexities.

Additionally, the paper focuses on single-agent navigation and does not directly address the challenges of [object Object] or [object Object] involving both autonomous and human-driven vehicles. Extending the game-theoretic model to these more complex settings is an important area for further research.

Overall, the mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium approach represents a valuable contribution to the field of crowd navigation, providing a solid theoretical foundation and promising empirical results. However, additional work is needed to address the practical limitations and broaden the applicability of the approach to real-world scenarios.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel game-theoretic framework for crowd navigation, where the autonomous agent computes a mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium to safely and efficiently navigate through crowded environments alongside human pedestrians. By modeling the problem as a strategic game and deriving the optimal stochastic policy, the authors demonstrate significant improvements over traditional deterministic path planning methods.

While the proposed approach has some limitations, it offers a principled way to handle the complex interactions in crowded scenarios and lays the groundwork for further advancements in autonomous navigation. As robots and self-driving cars become increasingly prevalent in our daily lives, developing efficient and safe navigation strategies in the presence of human crowds will be crucial for the successful deployment of these technologies.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Learning Strategies For Successful Crowd Navigation

Learning Strategies For Successful Crowd Navigation

Rajshree Daulatabad, Serena Nath

YC

0

Reddit

0

Teaching autonomous mobile robots to successfully navigate human crowds is a challenging task. Not only does it require planning, but it requires maintaining social norms which may differ from one context to another. Here we focus on crowd navigation, using a neural network to learn specific strategies in-situ with a robot. This allows us to take into account human behavior and reactions toward a real robot as well as learn strategies that are specific to various scenarios in that context. A CNN takes a top-down image of the scene as input and outputs the next action for the robot to take in terms of speed and angle. Here we present the method, experimental results, and quantitatively evaluate our approach.

Read more

4/11/2024

Structured Graph Network for Constrained Robot Crowd Navigation with Low Fidelity Simulation

Structured Graph Network for Constrained Robot Crowd Navigation with Low Fidelity Simulation

Shuijing Liu, Kaiwen Hong, Neeloy Chakraborty, Katherine Driggs-Campbell

YC

0

Reddit

0

We investigate the feasibility of deploying reinforcement learning (RL) policies for constrained crowd navigation using a low-fidelity simulator. We introduce a representation of the dynamic environment, separating human and obstacle representations. Humans are represented through detected states, while obstacles are represented as computed point clouds based on maps and robot localization. This representation enables RL policies trained in a low-fidelity simulator to deploy in real world with a reduced sim2real gap. Additionally, we propose a spatio-temporal graph to model the interactions between agents and obstacles. Based on the graph, we use attention mechanisms to capture the robot-human, human-human, and human-obstacle interactions. Our method significantly improves navigation performance in both simulated and real-world environments. Video demonstrations can be found at https://sites.google.com/view/constrained-crowdnav/home.

Read more

5/29/2024

📈

SICNav: Safe and Interactive Crowd Navigation using Model Predictive Control and Bilevel Optimization

Sepehr Samavi, James R. Han, Florian Shkurti, Angela P. Schoellig

YC

0

Reddit

0

Robots need to predict and react to human motions to navigate through a crowd without collisions. Many existing methods decouple prediction from planning, which does not account for the interaction between robot and human motions and can lead to the robot getting stuck. We propose SICNav, a Model Predictive Control (MPC) method that jointly solves for robot motion and predicted crowd motion in closed-loop. We model each human in the crowd to be following an Optimal Reciprocal Collision Avoidance (ORCA) scheme and embed that model as a constraint in the robot's local planner, resulting in a bilevel nonlinear MPC optimization problem. We use a KKT-reformulation to cast the bilevel problem as a single level and use a nonlinear solver to optimize. Our MPC method can influence pedestrian motion while explicitly satisfying safety constraints in a single-robot multi-human environment. We analyze the performance of SICNav in two simulation environments and indoor experiments with a real robot to demonstrate safe robot motion that can influence the surrounding humans. We also validate the trajectory forecasting performance of ORCA on a human trajectory dataset.

Read more

5/29/2024

SHINE: Social Homology Identification for Navigation in Crowded Environments

SHINE: Social Homology Identification for Navigation in Crowded Environments

Diego Martinez-Baselga, Oscar de Groot, Luzia Knoedler, Luis Riazuelo, Javier Alonso-Mora, Luis Montano

YC

0

Reddit

0

Navigating mobile robots in social environments remains a challenging task due to the intricacies of human-robot interactions. Most of the motion planners designed for crowded and dynamic environments focus on choosing the best velocity to reach the goal while avoiding collisions, but do not explicitly consider the high-level navigation behavior (avoiding through the left or right side, letting others pass or passing before others, etc.). In this work, we present a novel motion planner that incorporates topology distinct paths representing diverse navigation strategies around humans. The planner selects the topology class that imitates human behavior the best using a deep neural network model trained on real-world human motion data, ensuring socially intelligent and contextually aware navigation. Our system refines the chosen path through an optimization-based local planner in real time, ensuring seamless adherence to desired social behaviors. In this way, we decouple perception and local planning from the decision-making process. We evaluate the prediction accuracy of the network with real-world data. In addition, we assess the navigation capabilities in both simulation and a real-world platform, comparing it with other state-of-the-art planners. We demonstrate that our planner exhibits socially desirable behaviors and shows a smooth and remarkable performance.

Read more

4/26/2024