Needle In A Video Haystack: A Scalable Synthetic Framework for Benchmarking Video MLLMs

Overview

• This paper proposes a new benchmark called VideoNIAH for evaluating the video understanding capabilities of large language models (LLMs).
• VideoNIAH generates synthetic videos by inserting unrelated "needles" (images or text) into original videos, and then creates annotations based solely on these inserted needles.
• This approach allows for greater diversity in video sources and query-response pairs, while also rigorously testing the models' temporal understanding abilities by including multiple needles.
• The authors used VideoNIAH to create a benchmark called VNBench, which includes tasks like retrieval, ordering, and counting.
• They evaluated recent video-centric multimodal LLMs, both open-source and proprietary, on VNBench, finding that while proprietary models outperform open-source ones, all existing video models still struggle with long-distance dependency tasks.

Plain English Explanation

Understanding video content is an important next step for large language models (LLMs) that can process text, images, and other modalities. However, creating benchmarks to test this capability is challenging. Existing video benchmarks typically require carefully selecting videos and manually annotating them to match specific capabilities.

The researchers in this paper propose a new approach called VideoNIAH that simplifies the benchmark creation process. Instead of using real videos, VideoNIAH generates synthetic videos by inserting unrelated "needles" (images or text) into original videos. It then creates annotations based solely on these inserted needles, ensuring diversity in video sources and query-response pairs.

By including multiple needles in each video, VideoNIAH also tests the models' ability to understand the temporal relationships between different parts of the video - a key aspect of video understanding. The authors used VideoNIAH to create a benchmark called VNBench, which includes tasks like retrieving relevant information, ordering events, and counting objects in the video.

When the researchers evaluated recent video-centric multimodal LLMs on VNBench, they found that proprietary models outperformed open-source ones. However, all the models still struggled with tasks that require understanding long-distance dependencies in the video content.

Overall, VideoNIAH is a simple yet scalable framework for creating video benchmarks that can efficiently evaluate the fine-grained understanding and spatio-temporal modeling abilities of video models. The researchers hope it will inspire future work in this area, leading to more comprehensive multi-modal video understanding benchmarks and models that can handle extremely long videos.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in this paper is the VideoNIAH benchmark construction framework, which uses synthetic video generation to decouple test video content from their query-response annotations. Instead of carefully selecting and annotating real videos, VideoNIAH inserts unrelated "needles" (images or text) into original videos, and then generates annotations solely based on these inserted needles.

This approach offers several advantages:

1. Diversity: By using a wide range of video sources and generating annotations from the needles, VideoNIAH can create a diverse set of query-response pairs, unlike traditional benchmarks that rely on a limited number of carefully curated videos.
2. Scalability: The synthetic video generation and automated annotation process make VideoNIAH highly scalable, allowing for the creation of large-scale benchmarks.
3. Temporal Understanding: By inserting multiple needles into each video, VideoNIAH tests the models' ability to understand the temporal relationships between different parts of the video, a crucial aspect of video understanding.

Using the VideoNIAH framework, the authors compiled a video benchmark called VNBench, which includes tasks such as retrieval, ordering, and counting. They then evaluated several recent video-centric multimodal LLMs, both open-source and proprietary, on VNBench.

The results showed that proprietary models outperformed open-source models, suggesting that larger datasets and more sophisticated training approaches can lead to better video understanding capabilities. However, the authors found that all the models still struggled with tasks that require understanding long-distance dependencies in the video content, indicating the need for further research and development in this area.

Critical Analysis

The VideoNIAH framework and VNBench benchmark proposed in this paper address an important challenge in video understanding for multimodal LLMs. By decoupling video content from query-response annotations, the authors have created a scalable and efficient way to evaluate the fine-grained understanding and spatio-temporal modeling abilities of video models.

One potential limitation of the approach is that the synthetic videos, while diverse, may not fully capture the complexity and nuance of real-world video content. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that VideoNIAH should be used in conjunction with existing video benchmarks to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of video understanding capabilities.

Additionally, the authors' finding that existing video models struggle with long-distance dependency tasks highlights the need for further research and development in this area. Incorporating long-video understanding and question-answering capabilities into multimodal LLMs could be a fruitful area for future work.

Overall, the VideoNIAH framework and VNBench benchmark represent a significant contribution to the field of video understanding, and the authors' comprehensive evaluation of existing video models provides valuable insights for the development of more robust and capable multimodal LLMs.

Conclusion

This paper proposes a novel benchmark construction framework called VideoNIAH that simplifies the creation of video benchmarks for evaluating the video understanding capabilities of large language models. By generating synthetic videos with inserted "needles" and automating the annotation process, VideoNIAH overcomes the challenges of traditional video benchmarks and allows for the creation of large-scale, diverse, and temporally-aware test sets.

The authors used VideoNIAH to create the VNBench benchmark, which they used to evaluate several recent video-centric multimodal LLMs. While their results showed that proprietary models outperform open-source ones, all the evaluated models still struggle with tasks that require understanding long-distance dependencies in video content.

VideoNIAH is a significant step forward in the development of video understanding benchmarks, and the authors' findings highlight the need for further research and development in this area. As multimodal LLMs continue to advance, tools like VideoNIAH will be crucial for driving progress and ensuring that these models can truly understand and reason about the rich and complex world of video content.