Neural Likelihood Approximation for Integer Valued Time Series Data

Overview

• This paper presents a method for performing inference on stochastic models with discrete state spaces, which are commonly used in the physical and biological sciences.
• Existing simulation-based inference methods for these models are challenging to implement and computationally expensive, as they require generating realizations of the model conditional on the data.
• The authors instead propose a neural likelihood approximation that can be trained using unconditional simulations of the underlying model, which is much simpler.
• The method is demonstrated on several ecological and epidemiological models, showing accurate approximation of the true posterior and significant computational speedups compared to current best methods.

Plain English Explanation

Many processes in the physical and biological sciences can be modeled as stochastic systems with discrete states, such as the dynamics of small populations. Inferring the parameters of these models from observed data is challenging because the mathematical formulas (the "likelihood") are often impossible to calculate exactly.

Current methods try to get around this by simulating the model and using the simulations to approximate the likelihood. However, this can be tricky to set up and computationally expensive.

In this paper, the researchers propose a different approach: they train a neural network to approximate the likelihood directly, using only unconditional simulations of the model, which are much easier to generate. This allows them to do accurate parameter inference much more efficiently than previous methods.

They demonstrate their technique on several real-world examples from ecology and epidemiology, showing that it can accurately capture the true uncertainty in the model parameters while being significantly faster to run.

Technical Explanation

The key idea of the paper is to construct a neural network-based approximation of the likelihood function for stochastic models with discrete state spaces, which can then be used for efficient Bayesian inference.

The authors first observe that while directly calculating the true likelihood is often intractable for these models, it is relatively straightforward to generate unconditional simulations of the model. They then train a neural network, using these unconditional simulations as training data, to learn an approximation of the true likelihood.

The neural likelihood approximation is then used within a Bayesian inference framework to perform parameter estimation. This avoids the need to generate costly conditional simulations, as required by previous simulation-based inference methods.

The authors demonstrate their approach on several ecological and epidemiological case studies, including spatial models, showing that it can accurately capture the true posterior distribution of the model parameters while being significantly faster to run than existing techniques.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge several limitations of their approach. Firstly, the neural network approximation may not be accurate in all cases, particularly for models with complex, high-dimensional state spaces. The quality of the approximation will depend on the expressiveness of the neural network and the amount of training data available.

Additionally, the authors note that their method, like other simulation-based inference techniques, can be sensitive to model misspecification. If the true underlying model differs from the assumed model, the inferred parameters may be biased.

Further research could explore ways to make the neural likelihood approximation more robust, such as by incorporating uncertainty quantification or adapting the network architecture to the problem at hand. Comparisons to other recent advancements in simulation-based inference, such as amortized variational inference, could also provide valuable insights.

Overall, the authors present an interesting and promising approach for efficient Bayesian inference on discrete-state stochastic models, which have important applications across the physical and life sciences.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a neural network-based method for approximating the likelihood function of stochastic models with discrete state spaces, which can significantly improve the efficiency of Bayesian parameter inference compared to existing simulation-based techniques.

By leveraging unconditional model simulations to train the neural approximation, the authors avoid the need for computationally expensive conditional simulations required by prior approaches. This allows for accurate posterior inference with substantial speedups, as demonstrated on several real-world ecological and epidemiological case studies.

While the method has some limitations, it represents an important advancement in the field of simulation-based inference and could have wide-ranging impacts across the physical and biological sciences, where discrete-state stochastic models are ubiquitous.