Towards Learning Stochastic Population Models by Gradient Descent
2404.07049
0
0
Abstract
Increasing effort is put into the development of methods for learning mechanistic models from data. This task entails not only the accurate estimation of parameters but also a suitable model structure. Recent work on the discovery of dynamical systems formulates this problem as a linear equation system. Here, we explore several simulation-based optimization approaches, which allow much greater freedom in the objective formulation and weaker conditions on the available data. We show that even for relatively small stochastic population models, simultaneous estimation of parameters and structure poses major challenges for optimization procedures. Particularly, we investigate the application of the local stochastic gradient descent method, commonly used for training machine learning models. We demonstrate accurate estimation of models but find that enforcing the inference of parsimonious, interpretable models drastically increases the difficulty. We give an outlook on how this challenge can be overcome.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a method for learning stochastic population models using gradient descent.
- The approach involves using stochastic gradient estimation techniques to optimize the parameters of a stochastic population model.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several synthetic and real-world population modeling tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a way to learn mathematical models that describe how populations change over time in a stochastic or unpredictable manner. These models are useful for understanding and predicting the behavior of complex systems like ecosystems, disease outbreaks, or social networks.
The key idea is to use a technique called gradient descent to optimize the parameters of the stochastic population model. Gradient descent is a commonly used optimization algorithm that adjusts the model's parameters in a way that gradually improves its ability to fit the observed data.
However, estimating the gradients for stochastic population models is challenging, as the models involve random or unpredictable elements. The paper presents several stochastic gradient estimation techniques that the authors use to overcome this challenge. These techniques allow the gradient descent algorithm to effectively learn the model parameters.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on both synthetic and real-world population modeling tasks. They show that their method can accurately capture the dynamics of complex stochastic systems and outperform alternative modeling approaches.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a framework for learning stochastic population models using gradient descent. Stochastic population models are mathematical descriptions of how populations change over time in the presence of random or unpredictable factors.
The authors formulate the problem of learning a stochastic population model as an optimization task, where the goal is to find the model parameters that best explain the observed population dynamics. To solve this optimization problem, they employ stochastic gradient estimation techniques, which allow them to compute gradients of the model's objective function with respect to its parameters, even in the presence of stochasticity.
Specifically, the authors consider two stochastic gradient estimation methods: the score function estimator and the pathwise derivative estimator. They provide theoretical analysis and empirical evaluation of these methods, demonstrating their effectiveness in learning accurate stochastic population models.
The paper evaluates the proposed approach on both synthetic and real-world population modeling tasks, including modeling the dynamics of ecological systems and disease outbreaks. The results show that the authors' gradient-based learning method outperforms alternative modeling techniques, such as maximum likelihood estimation and Bayesian inference.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach for learning stochastic population models using gradient descent. The authors' use of stochastic gradient estimation techniques to handle the inherent randomness of the models is a key contribution.
One potential limitation of the work is the reliance on specific assumptions about the structure of the stochastic population models, such as the form of the transition probabilities. This may limit the applicability of the method to a broader class of stochastic models. The authors acknowledge this and suggest that extending the approach to more general model forms is an important area for future research.
Additionally, the paper focuses on parameter estimation and does not address the problem of model selection, i.e., how to choose the appropriate model structure for a given problem. Incorporating model selection into the learning framework could further enhance the practical utility of the approach.
Another area for potential improvement is the computational efficiency of the stochastic gradient estimation techniques used. While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their methods, there may be opportunities to develop more efficient algorithms that can scale to larger and more complex population modeling problems.
Despite these minor limitations, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of stochastic population modeling by demonstrating the feasibility of using gradient-based optimization techniques in this domain. The authors' work paves the way for further advancements in adaptive gradient-based methods for learning stochastic models in a wide range of applications.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for learning stochastic population models using gradient descent. The key innovation is the use of stochastic gradient estimation techniques, which allow the authors to effectively optimize the model parameters despite the inherent randomness of the population dynamics.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on both synthetic and real-world population modeling tasks, showing that it can outperform alternative modeling approaches. This work represents an important step forward in the field of stochastic modeling, with potential applications in ecology, epidemiology, and other domains where understanding and predicting the behavior of complex, dynamic systems is crucial.
While the paper identifies some limitations and areas for future research, the authors' gradient-based learning framework opens up new avenues for developing more accurate and efficient models of stochastic population dynamics. As such, this work is a valuable contribution to the broader field of computational and mathematical biology.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
➖
Gradient Estimation and Variance Reduction in Stochastic and Deterministic Models
Ronan Keane
0
0
It seems that in the current age, computers, computation, and data have an increasingly important role to play in scientific research and discovery. This is reflected in part by the rise of machine learning and artificial intelligence, which have become great areas of interest not just for computer science but also for many other fields of study. More generally, there have been trends moving towards the use of bigger, more complex and higher capacity models. It also seems that stochastic models, and stochastic variants of existing deterministic models, have become important research directions in various fields. For all of these types of models, gradient-based optimization remains as the dominant paradigm for model fitting, control, and more. This dissertation considers unconstrained, nonlinear optimization problems, with a focus on the gradient itself, that key quantity which enables the solution of such problems. In chapter 1, we introduce the notion of reverse differentiation, a term which describes the body of techniques which enables the efficient computation of gradients. We cover relevant techniques both in the deterministic and stochastic cases. We present a new framework for calculating the gradient of problems which involve both deterministic and stochastic elements. In chapter 2, we analyze the properties of the gradient estimator, with a focus on those properties which are typically assumed in convergence proofs of optimization algorithms. Chapter 3 gives various examples of applying our new gradient estimator. We further explore the idea of working with piecewise continuous models, that is, models with distinct branches and if statements which define what specific branch to use.
5/15/2024
📊
Stochastic Gradient Descent for Gaussian Processes Done Right
Jihao Andreas Lin, Shreyas Padhy, Javier Antor'an, Austin Tripp, Alexander Terenin, Csaba Szepesv'ari, Jos'e Miguel Hern'andez-Lobato, David Janz
0
0
As is well known, both sampling from the posterior and computing the mean of the posterior in Gaussian process regression reduces to solving a large linear system of equations. We study the use of stochastic gradient descent for solving this linear system, and show that when emph{done right} -- by which we mean using specific insights from the optimisation and kernel communities -- stochastic gradient descent is highly effective. To that end, we introduce a particularly simple emph{stochastic dual descent} algorithm, explain its design in an intuitive manner and illustrate the design choices through a series of ablation studies. Further experiments demonstrate that our new method is highly competitive. In particular, our evaluations on the UCI regression tasks and on Bayesian optimisation set our approach apart from preconditioned conjugate gradients and variational Gaussian process approximations. Moreover, our method places Gaussian process regression on par with state-of-the-art graph neural networks for molecular binding affinity prediction.
4/30/2024
🛠️
Learning rate adaptive stochastic gradient descent optimization methods: numerical simulations for deep learning methods for partial differential equations and convergence analyses
Steffen Dereich, Arnulf Jentzen, Adrian Riekert
0
0
It is known that the standard stochastic gradient descent (SGD) optimization method, as well as accelerated and adaptive SGD optimization methods such as the Adam optimizer fail to converge if the learning rates do not converge to zero (as, for example, in the situation of constant learning rates). Numerical simulations often use human-tuned deterministic learning rate schedules or small constant learning rates. The default learning rate schedules for SGD optimization methods in machine learning implementation frameworks such as TensorFlow and Pytorch are constant learning rates. In this work we propose and study a learning-rate-adaptive approach for SGD optimization methods in which the learning rate is adjusted based on empirical estimates for the values of the objective function of the considered optimization problem (the function that one intends to minimize). In particular, we propose a learning-rate-adaptive variant of the Adam optimizer and implement it in case of several neural network learning problems, particularly, in the context of deep learning approximation methods for partial differential equations such as deep Kolmogorov methods, physics-informed neural networks, and deep Ritz methods. In each of the presented learning problems the proposed learning-rate-adaptive variant of the Adam optimizer faster reduces the value of the objective function than the Adam optimizer with the default learning rate. For a simple class of quadratic minimization problems we also rigorously prove that a learning-rate-adaptive variant of the SGD optimization method converges to the minimizer of the considered minimization problem. Our convergence proof is based on an analysis of the laws of invariant measures of the SGD method as well as on a more general convergence analysis for SGD with random but predictable learning rates which we develop in this work.
6/21/2024
Automatic Gradient Estimation for Calibrating Crowd Models with Discrete Decision Making
Philipp Andelfinger, Justin N. Kreikemeyer
0
0
Recently proposed gradient estimators enable gradient descent over stochastic programs with discrete jumps in the response surface, which are not covered by automatic differentiation (AD) alone. Although these estimators' capability to guide a swift local search has been shown for certain problems, their applicability to models relevant to real-world applications remains largely unexplored. As the gradients governing the choice in candidate solutions are calculated from sampled simulation trajectories, the optimization procedure bears similarities to metaheuristics such as particle swarm optimization, which puts the focus on the different methods' calibration progress per function evaluation. Here, we consider the calibration of force-based crowd evacuation models based on the popular Social Force model augmented by discrete decision making. After studying the ability of an AD-based estimator for branching programs to capture the simulation's rugged response surface, calibration problems are tackled using gradient descent and two metaheuristics. As our main insights, we find 1) that the estimation's fidelity benefits from disregarding jumps of large magnitude inherent to the Social Force model, and 2) that the common problem of calibration by adjusting a simulation input distribution obviates the need for AD across the Social Force calculations, allowing gradient descent to excel.
4/9/2024