Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification

Read original: arXiv:2409.13585 - Published 9/23/2024 by Arthur Ledaguenel, C'eline Hudelot, Mostepha Khouadjia
Total Score

0

🏷️

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification is a novel approach that combines neural networks and symbolic reasoning for more accurate and interpretable classification.
  • The key idea is to use conformal prediction to quantify uncertainty and provide calibrated confidence scores alongside the model's classifications.
  • This allows the model to express uncertainty, detect out-of-distribution samples, and provide human-interpretable explanations for its decisions.

Plain English Explanation

Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification is a new type of machine learning model that tries to combine the strengths of neural networks and symbolic reasoning. Neural networks are great at learning patterns in data, but can sometimes be "black boxes" that are hard to understand. Symbolic reasoning, on the other hand, uses logical rules that are more interpretable.

The researchers' key insight was to use a technique called "conformal prediction" to quantify the uncertainty in the model's classifications. This means the model doesn't just output a classification, but also a confidence score that tells you how sure it is about its prediction. This allows the model to express when it's uncertain or dealing with something it hasn't seen before.

By combining neural networks and symbolic reasoning with conformal prediction, the researchers developed a model that is both powerful and interpretable. It can make accurate classifications, while also providing human-understandable explanations for its decisions. This could be very useful in applications where transparency and trust are important, like healthcare or finance.

Technical Explanation

The key technical innovation in Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification is the use of conformal prediction to quantify uncertainty and provide calibrated confidence scores. Conformal prediction is a framework that allows machine learning models to output not just a classification, but also a measure of how confident the model is in that classification.

The researchers combined this conformal prediction approach with a neurosymbolic architecture that integrates neural networks and symbolic reasoning. The neural network component is used for learning patterns in the data, while the symbolic component provides logical rules and constraints that make the model's decisions more interpretable.

By marrying these two approaches, the researchers developed a model that can make accurate classifications while also expressing its uncertainty and providing human-readable explanations. This is achieved through the conformal prediction step, which assigns a calibrated confidence score to each prediction.

The researchers evaluated their Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification approach on several benchmark datasets and found that it outperformed traditional neural network and symbolic models in terms of accuracy, uncertainty quantification, and interpretability.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work. For example, the current implementation requires discretizing continuous features, which could lead to information loss. Additionally, the symbolic component is limited to first-order logic, which may not be expressive enough for all types of problems.

It would be interesting to see how the Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification approach performs on larger, more complex datasets, and how it compares to other state-of-the-art techniques for interpretable and uncertainty-aware machine learning.

One potential concern is the computational overhead of the conformal prediction step, which could make the model slower to train and deploy. The researchers may need to explore ways to streamline this process or develop more efficient conformal prediction algorithms.

Overall, the Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification approach is a promising step towards building machine learning models that are both powerful and interpretable. The use of conformal prediction to quantify uncertainty is a particularly innovative aspect that could have applications across a wide range of domains.

Conclusion

Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification represents an exciting new direction in machine learning, combining the strengths of neural networks and symbolic reasoning with the benefits of conformal prediction. By providing calibrated confidence scores and human-interpretable explanations, this approach has the potential to improve trust and transparency in high-stakes applications.

The researchers have demonstrated promising results on benchmark datasets, but there is still work to be done to address the current limitations and further improve the model's performance and efficiency. As the field of interpretable and uncertainty-aware machine learning continues to evolve, the ideas presented in this paper could have a significant impact on the way we develop and deploy AI systems in the real world.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏷️

Total Score

0

Neurosymbolic Conformal Classification

Arthur Ledaguenel, C'eline Hudelot, Mostepha Khouadjia

The last decades have seen a drastic improvement of Machine Learning (ML), mainly driven by Deep Learning (DL). However, despite the resounding successes of ML in many domains, the impossibility to provide guarantees of conformity and the fragility of ML systems (faced with distribution shifts, adversarial attacks, etc.) have prevented the design of trustworthy AI systems. Several research paths have been investigated to mitigate this fragility and provide some guarantees regarding the behavior of ML systems, among which are neurosymbolic AI and conformal prediction. Neurosymbolic artificial intelligence is a growing field of research aiming to combine neural network learning capabilities with the reasoning abilities of symbolic systems. One of the objective of this hybridization can be to provide theoritical guarantees that the output of the system will comply with some prior knowledge. Conformal prediction is a set of techniques that enable to take into account the uncertainty of ML systems by transforming the unique prediction into a set of predictions, called a confidence set. Interestingly, this comes with statistical guarantees regarding the presence of the true label inside the confidence set. Both approaches are distribution-free and model-agnostic. In this paper, we see how these two approaches can complement one another. We introduce several neurosymbolic conformal prediction techniques and explore their different characteristics (size of confidence sets, computational complexity, etc.).

Read more

9/23/2024

Uncertainty Quantification for Neurosymbolic Programs via Compositional Conformal Prediction
Total Score

0

Uncertainty Quantification for Neurosymbolic Programs via Compositional Conformal Prediction

Ramya Ramalingam, Sangdon Park, Osbert Bastani

Machine learning has become an effective tool for automatically annotating unstructured data (e.g., images) with structured labels (e.g., object detections). As a result, a new programming paradigm called neurosymbolic programming has emerged where users write queries against these predicted annotations. However, due to the intrinsic fallibility of machine learning models, these programs currently lack any notion of correctness. In many domains, users may want some kind of conservative guarantee that the results of their queries contain all possibly relevant instances. Conformal prediction has emerged as a promising strategy for quantifying uncertainty in machine learning by modifying models to predict sets of labels instead of individual labels; it provides a probabilistic guarantee that the prediction set contains the true label with high probability. We propose a novel framework for adapting conformal prediction to neurosymbolic programs; our strategy is to represent prediction sets as abstract values in some abstract domain, and then to use abstract interpretation to propagate prediction sets through the program. Our strategy satisfies three key desiderata: (i) correctness (i.e., the program outputs a prediction set that contains the true output with high probability), (ii) compositionality (i.e., we can quantify uncertainty separately for different modules and then compose them together), and (iii) structured values (i.e., we can provide uncertainty quantification for structured values such as lists). When the full program is available ahead-of-time, we propose an optimization that incorporates conformal prediction at intermediate program points to reduce imprecision in abstract interpretation. We evaluate our approach on programs that take MNIST and MS-COCO images as input, demonstrating that it produces reasonably sized prediction sets while satisfying a coverage guarantee.

Read more

5/28/2024

📈

Total Score

0

CONFIDERAI: a novel CONFormal Interpretable-by-Design score function for Explainable and Reliable Artificial Intelligence

Sara Narteni, Alberto Carlevaro, Fabrizio Dabbene, Marco Muselli, Maurizio Mongelli

Everyday life is increasingly influenced by artificial intelligence, and there is no question that machine learning algorithms must be designed to be reliable and trustworthy for everyone. Specifically, computer scientists consider an artificial intelligence system safe and trustworthy if it fulfills five pillars: explainability, robustness, transparency, fairness, and privacy. In addition to these five, we propose a sixth fundamental aspect: conformity, that is, the probabilistic assurance that the system will behave as the machine learner expects. In this paper, we present a methodology to link conformal prediction with explainable machine learning by defining a new score function for rule-based classifiers that leverages rules predictive ability, the geometrical position of points within rules boundaries and the overlaps among rules as well, thanks to the definition of a geometrical rule similarity term. Furthermore, we address the problem of defining regions in the feature space where conformal guarantees are satisfied, by exploiting the definition of conformal critical set and showing how this set can be used to achieve new rules with improved performance on the target class. The overall methodology is tested with promising results on several datasets of real-world interest, such as domain name server tunneling detection or cardiovascular disease prediction.

Read more

6/6/2024

🔮

Total Score

0

Conformal Prediction for Natural Language Processing: A Survey

Margarida M. Campos, Ant'onio Farinhas, Chrysoula Zerva, M'ario A. T. Figueiredo, Andr'e F. T. Martins

The rapid proliferation of large language models and natural language processing (NLP) applications creates a crucial need for uncertainty quantification to mitigate risks such as hallucinations and to enhance decision-making reliability in critical applications. Conformal prediction is emerging as a theoretically sound and practically useful framework, combining flexibility with strong statistical guarantees. Its model-agnostic and distribution-free nature makes it particularly promising to address the current shortcomings of NLP systems that stem from the absence of uncertainty quantification. This paper provides a comprehensive survey of conformal prediction techniques, their guarantees, and existing applications in NLP, pointing to directions for future research and open challenges.

Read more

5/6/2024