Uncertainty Quantification for Neurosymbolic Programs via Compositional Conformal Prediction

Overview

• This paper presents a novel approach for quantifying uncertainty in neurosymbolic programs using compositional conformal prediction.
• Neurosymbolic programs combine neural networks and symbolic logic to leverage the strengths of both paradigms.
• Conformal prediction is a technique that provides valid uncertainty estimates for machine learning models, even when the underlying data distribution is unknown.
• The authors develop a compositional approach to apply conformal prediction to neurosymbolic programs, enabling uncertainty quantification at the level of individual components.

Plain English Explanation

The paper tackles the challenge of quantifying uncertainty in neurosymbolic programs, which are a type of AI system that combines neural networks and symbolic logic. These systems can be powerful, but it can be difficult to understand how certain their outputs are.

The researchers use a technique called conformal prediction to address this. Conformal prediction is a way of generating valid uncertainty estimates for machine learning models, even when the underlying data distribution is not well known. The key idea is to compare a new data point to a "conformity score" calculated from the training data, which gives a sense of how similar the new point is to the known data.

The researchers extend this approach to work with neurosymbolic programs by developing a compositional method. This means they can apply conformal prediction to each individual component of the neurosymbolic program, rather than just treating the whole system as a black box. This allows for more detailed and meaningful uncertainty estimates.

Overall, this work helps make neurosymbolic programs more transparent and interpretable by quantifying the uncertainty associated with their outputs. This could be valuable in sensitive applications where understanding the reliability of the system's decisions is important.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces a novel approach for uncertainty quantification in neurosymbolic programs using compositional conformal prediction.

Neurosymbolic programs combine neural networks and symbolic logic to leverage the strengths of both paradigms. However, quantifying the uncertainty associated with the outputs of these hybrid systems can be challenging. The authors cite related work on conformal prediction for natural language processing, comparative studies of conformal prediction methods, and post-hoc uncertainty quantification for semantic image segmentation.

To address this, the authors develop a compositional conformal prediction framework. This extends the conformal prediction technique, which provides valid uncertainty estimates for machine learning models in a distribution-free manner, to the neurosymbolic setting. The authors also cite work on conformal online model aggregation and the theoretical guarantees of conformal prediction.

The key idea is to apply conformal prediction independently to each component of the neurosymbolic program, rather than treating the entire system as a black box. This compositional approach allows for more granular and interpretable uncertainty estimates, as the uncertainty associated with each individual module can be quantified.

The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of this approach through experiments on a diverse set of neurosymbolic benchmark tasks. The results show that the proposed method can provide valid and informative uncertainty estimates that outperform alternative techniques.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach for uncertainty quantification in neurosymbolic programs. The compositional conformal prediction framework is a principled way to extend the distribution-free guarantees of conformal prediction to these complex, hybrid systems.

One potential limitation is that the method relies on the availability of well-defined component-level outputs within the neurosymbolic program. In some cases, the internal structure of the system may not be easily decomposable, which could limit the applicability of the compositional approach.

Additionally, the paper focuses on offline, batch-style evaluation. It would be interesting to see how the method performs in online or streaming settings, where the data distribution may be non-stationary. The authors' previous work on conformal online model aggregation suggests the approach could be extended to such scenarios, but further research would be needed.

Overall, this work makes an important contribution to the field of uncertainty quantification for hybrid AI systems. The compositional conformal prediction framework provides a principled way to make neurosymbolic programs more transparent and interpretable, which could be valuable in safety-critical applications.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for quantifying uncertainty in neurosymbolic programs using compositional conformal prediction. By applying conformal prediction independently to the individual components of a neurosymbolic system, the method can provide granular and interpretable uncertainty estimates that outperform alternative techniques.

The work advances the state of the art in uncertainty quantification for hybrid AI systems, which is an important challenge as these models become more widely deployed. The compositional approach and distribution-free guarantees of conformal prediction make the proposed method a promising tool for enhancing the reliability and transparency of neurosymbolic programs in sensitive applications.