CONFIDERAI: a novel CONFormal Interpretable-by-Design score function for Explainable and Reliable Artificial Intelligence
0
📈
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Explores the need for trustworthy and reliable artificial intelligence (AI) systems
- Proposes a new "conformity" pillar as an essential aspect of safe and trustworthy AI, in addition to the existing pillars of explainability, robustness, transparency, fairness, and privacy
- Presents a methodology to link conformal prediction with explainable machine learning for rule-based classifiers
- Addresses the problem of defining regions in the feature space where conformal guarantees are satisfied
Plain English Explanation
As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes more prevalent in our daily lives, it's crucial that these systems are designed to be reliable and trustworthy for everyone. Researchers have identified five key pillars that make an AI system safe and trustworthy: explainability, robustness, transparency, fairness, and privacy.
In this paper, the authors propose a sixth fundamental aspect: conformity. Conformity means that the AI system will behave in the way the machine learning model expects, with a high degree of probability.
The researchers present a new methodology that combines conformal prediction (a technique for providing reliable predictive uncertainty estimates) with explainable machine learning for rule-based classifiers. This approach defines a new score function that considers the predictive ability of rules, their geometric position, and the overlap between rules.
Additionally, the paper addresses the problem of identifying regions in the feature space where the conformal guarantees are satisfied. This is done by exploiting the concept of a "conformal critical set," which can be used to create new rules with improved performance on the target class.
The overall methodology is tested on several real-world datasets, such as detecting domain name server tunneling and predicting cardiovascular disease, with promising results.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new "conformity" pillar as an essential aspect of safe and trustworthy AI, in addition to the existing pillars of explainability, robustness, transparency, fairness, and privacy.
The authors present a methodology that links conformal prediction with explainable machine learning for rule-based classifiers. They define a new score function that considers the predictive ability of rules, their geometric position, and the overlap between rules. This score function is used to identify rules that are both predictive and interpretable.
Additionally, the paper addresses the problem of defining regions in the feature space where conformal guarantees are satisfied. This is done by exploiting the concept of a "conformal critical set," which can be used to create new rules with improved performance on the target class.
The proposed methodology is tested on several real-world datasets, including domain name server tunneling detection and cardiovascular disease prediction. The results are promising, demonstrating the potential of this approach to create trustworthy and reliable AI systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and important contribution to the field of trustworthy AI by proposing a "conformity" pillar as an essential aspect of safe and reliable systems. However, the authors do not provide a clear definition or formal characterization of this new pillar, which could make it challenging to implement or evaluate in practice.
Additionally, the paper focuses primarily on rule-based classifiers, which may limit the broader applicability of the proposed methodology. While the results on the tested datasets are promising, it would be valuable to see how the approach performs on a wider range of machine learning models and problem domains.
The paper also does not address potential issues related to the fairness and privacy of the proposed methodology, which are crucial considerations for trustworthy AI systems. Further research is needed to ensure that the methodology does not introduce or exacerbate biases or privacy concerns.
Conclusion
This paper makes an important contribution to the field of trustworthy AI by proposing a new "conformity" pillar as an essential aspect of safe and reliable systems. The authors present a methodology that combines conformal prediction with explainable machine learning for rule-based classifiers, which shows promise in addressing the need for trustworthy AI.
While the paper focuses on a specific type of machine learning model, the underlying ideas and principles could be extended to a wider range of AI systems. Further research is needed to fully define the conformity pillar, address potential issues related to fairness and privacy, and explore the broader applicability of the proposed methodology.
Overall, this work highlights the critical importance of designing AI systems that are not only accurate but also reliable, transparent, and trustworthy for everyone who interacts with them.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
0
CONFIDERAI: a novel CONFormal Interpretable-by-Design score function for Explainable and Reliable Artificial Intelligence
Sara Narteni, Alberto Carlevaro, Fabrizio Dabbene, Marco Muselli, Maurizio Mongelli
Everyday life is increasingly influenced by artificial intelligence, and there is no question that machine learning algorithms must be designed to be reliable and trustworthy for everyone. Specifically, computer scientists consider an artificial intelligence system safe and trustworthy if it fulfills five pillars: explainability, robustness, transparency, fairness, and privacy. In addition to these five, we propose a sixth fundamental aspect: conformity, that is, the probabilistic assurance that the system will behave as the machine learner expects. In this paper, we present a methodology to link conformal prediction with explainable machine learning by defining a new score function for rule-based classifiers that leverages rules predictive ability, the geometrical position of points within rules boundaries and the overlaps among rules as well, thanks to the definition of a geometrical rule similarity term. Furthermore, we address the problem of defining regions in the feature space where conformal guarantees are satisfied, by exploiting the definition of conformal critical set and showing how this set can be used to achieve new rules with improved performance on the target class. The overall methodology is tested with promising results on several datasets of real-world interest, such as domain name server tunneling detection or cardiovascular disease prediction.
Read more6/6/2024
0
Trustworthy Classification through Rank-Based Conformal Prediction Sets
Rui Luo, Zhixin Zhou
Machine learning classification tasks often benefit from predicting a set of possible labels with confidence scores to capture uncertainty. However, existing methods struggle with the high-dimensional nature of the data and the lack of well-calibrated probabilities from modern classification models. We propose a novel conformal prediction method that employs a rank-based score function suitable for classification models that predict the order of labels correctly, even if not well-calibrated. Our approach constructs prediction sets that achieve the desired coverage rate while managing their size. We provide a theoretical analysis of the expected size of the conformal prediction sets based on the rank distribution of the underlying classifier. Through extensive experiments, we demonstrate that our method outperforms existing techniques on various datasets, providing reliable uncertainty quantification. Our contributions include a novel conformal prediction method, theoretical analysis, and empirical evaluation. This work advances the practical deployment of machine learning systems by enabling reliable uncertainty quantification.
Read more7/8/2024
0
CONFINE: Conformal Prediction for Interpretable Neural Networks
Linhui Huang, Sayeri Lala, Niraj K. Jha
Deep neural networks exhibit remarkable performance, yet their black-box nature limits their utility in fields like healthcare where interpretability is crucial. Existing explainability approaches often sacrifice accuracy and lack quantifiable measures of prediction uncertainty. In this study, we introduce Conformal Prediction for Interpretable Neural Networks (CONFINE), a versatile framework that generates prediction sets with statistically robust uncertainty estimates instead of point predictions to enhance model transparency and reliability. CONFINE not only provides example-based explanations and confidence estimates for individual predictions but also boosts accuracy by up to 3.6%. We define a new metric, correct efficiency, to evaluate the fraction of prediction sets that contain precisely the correct label and show that CONFINE achieves correct efficiency of up to 3.3% higher than the original accuracy, matching or exceeding prior methods. CONFINE's marginal and class-conditional coverages attest to its validity across tasks spanning medical image classification to language understanding. Being adaptable to any pre-trained classifier, CONFINE marks a significant advance towards transparent and trustworthy deep learning applications in critical domains.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Conformal Validity Guarantees Exist for Any Data Distribution
Drew Prinster, Samuel Stanton, Anqi Liu, Suchi Saria
As artificial intelligence (AI) / machine learning (ML) gain widespread adoption, practitioners are increasingly seeking means to quantify and control the risk these systems incur. This challenge is especially salient when such systems have autonomy to collect their own data, such as in black-box optimization and active learning, where their actions induce sequential feedback-loop shifts in the data distribution. Conformal prediction is a promising approach to uncertainty and risk quantification, but prior variants' validity guarantees have assumed some form of ``quasi-exchangeability'' on the data distribution, thereby excluding many types of sequential shifts. In this paper we prove that conformal prediction can theoretically be extended to textit{any} joint data distribution, not just exchangeable or quasi-exchangeable ones. Although the most general case is exceedingly impractical to compute, for concrete practical applications we outline a procedure for deriving specific conformal algorithms for any data distribution, and we use this procedure to derive tractable algorithms for a series of AI/ML-agent-induced covariate shifts. We evaluate the proposed algorithms empirically on synthetic black-box optimization and active learning tasks.
Read more6/6/2024