New User Event Prediction Through the Lens of Causal Inference

Read original: arXiv:2407.05625 - Published 7/12/2024 by Henry Shaowu Yuchi, Shixiang Zhu, Li Dong, Yigit M. Arisoy, Matthew C. Spencer
Total Score

0

New User Event Prediction Through the Lens of Causal Inference

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper explores how causal inference techniques can be used to improve the prediction of new user events, even when information is incomplete.
  • The authors propose a novel framework that leverages causal relationships to make better predictions about the actions and behaviors of new users on a platform.
  • By modeling the causal mechanisms underlying user behavior, the approach can make more accurate predictions compared to traditional machine learning methods.
  • The research has implications for a variety of applications, such as event prediction, recommendation systems, and uplift modeling.

Plain English Explanation

When a new user joins a platform (like a social network or online store), it can be challenging to predict how they will behave and what actions they might take. Traditional machine learning methods often struggle with this problem, especially when there is incomplete information about the user.

The researchers in this paper propose a new approach that uses causal inference to make better predictions about new user behavior. Causal inference is a set of techniques that try to understand the underlying reasons and relationships that drive certain outcomes.

By modeling the causal mechanisms that influence user actions, the researchers' framework can make more accurate predictions about what a new user is likely to do. This is because the model is based on the actual drivers of user behavior, rather than just statistical patterns in the data.

The benefits of this causal inference approach include:

  • Improved prediction accuracy for new user events, even with limited information
  • The ability to identify the key factors that influence user behavior
  • Potential applications in areas like recommendation systems and uplift modeling

Overall, the research demonstrates how causal reasoning can enhance our understanding of user behavior and lead to more effective predictive models, even in situations with incomplete data.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by highlighting the challenges of new user event prediction, where traditional machine learning methods often struggle due to the lack of historical data on new users. To address this, the authors propose a causal inference-based framework that models the underlying causal relationships influencing user behavior.

The key elements of the framework include:

  1. Causal graph construction: The authors construct a causal graph that represents the hypothesized causal relationships between various factors (user attributes, platform features, user actions, etc.).
  2. Causal effect estimation: Using techniques like backdoor adjustment and propensity score matching, the framework estimates the causal effects of different factors on the target user events.
  3. Prediction model: The estimated causal effects are then incorporated into a prediction model, which can make more accurate forecasts about the likelihood of new user events.

The authors evaluate their approach on real-world datasets from various online platforms. The results show that the causal inference-based model outperforms traditional machine learning baselines, particularly in scenarios with limited information about new users.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a compelling approach to new user event prediction, leveraging causal inference to enhance predictive performance. However, there are a few caveats and areas for further research worth considering:

  1. Causal graph construction: The authors acknowledge that the quality of the causal graph is crucial for the framework's performance. Constructing an accurate causal graph can be challenging, especially in complex, real-world settings. Further research could explore automated or semi-automated methods for causal graph construction.

  2. Generalizability: The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of the causal inference approach on specific datasets from online platforms. Additional research is needed to assess the generalizability of the framework to other domains and use cases.

  3. Interpretability: While the causal inference approach can provide insights into the underlying drivers of user behavior, the resulting models may be more complex and less interpretable than some traditional machine learning techniques. Balancing predictive performance and model interpretability is an ongoing challenge in this area.

  4. Ethical considerations: The use of causal inference for user behavior prediction raises potential ethical concerns, such as issues related to privacy, fairness, and the potential for manipulation. Future research should carefully consider the ethical implications of this type of technology.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach to new user event prediction that leverages causal inference to overcome the limitations of traditional machine learning methods. By modeling the underlying causal relationships that influence user behavior, the framework can make more accurate predictions, even in the face of incomplete information about new users.

The research has significant implications for a variety of applications, including recommendation systems, uplift modeling, and event prediction. As the field of causal inference continues to advance, we can expect to see more innovative applications that leverage this powerful set of techniques to enhance our understanding and prediction of complex human behaviors.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

New User Event Prediction Through the Lens of Causal Inference
Total Score

0

New User Event Prediction Through the Lens of Causal Inference

Henry Shaowu Yuchi, Shixiang Zhu, Li Dong, Yigit M. Arisoy, Matthew C. Spencer

Modeling and analysis for event series generated by heterogeneous users of various behavioral patterns are closely involved in our daily lives, including credit card fraud detection, online platform user recommendation, and social network analysis. The most commonly adopted approach to this task is to classify users into behavior-based categories and analyze each of them separately. However, this approach requires extensive data to fully understand user behavior, presenting challenges in modeling newcomers without historical knowledge. In this paper, we propose a novel discrete event prediction framework for new users through the lens of causal inference. Our method offers an unbiased prediction for new users without needing to know their categories. We treat the user event history as the ''treatment'' for future events and the user category as the key confounder. Thus, the prediction problem can be framed as counterfactual outcome estimation, with the new user model trained on an adjusted dataset where each event is re-weighted by its inverse propensity score. We demonstrate the superior performance of the proposed framework with a numerical simulation study and two real-world applications, including Netflix rating prediction and seller contact prediction for customer support at Amazon.

Read more

7/12/2024

Event prediction and causality inference despite incomplete information
Total Score

0

Event prediction and causality inference despite incomplete information

Harrison Lam, Yuanjie Chen, Noboru Kanazawa, Mohammad Chowdhury, Anna Battista, Stephan Waldert

We explored the challenge of predicting and explaining the occurrence of events within sequences of data points. Our focus was particularly on scenarios in which unknown triggers causing the occurrence of events may consist of non-consecutive, masked, noisy data points. This scenario is akin to an agent tasked with learning to predict and explain the occurrence of events without understanding the underlying processes or having access to crucial information. Such scenarios are encountered across various fields, such as genomics, hardware and software verification, and financial time series prediction. We combined analytical, simulation, and machine learning (ML) approaches to investigate, quantify, and provide solutions to this challenge. We deduced and validated equations generally applicable to any variation of the underlying challenge. Using these equations, we (1) described how the level of complexity changes with various parameters (e.g., number of apparent and hidden states, trigger length, confidence, etc.) and (2) quantified the data needed to successfully train an ML model. We then (3) proved our ML solution learns and subsequently identifies unknown triggers and predicts the occurrence of events. If the complexity of the challenge is too high, our ML solution can identify trigger candidates to be used to interactively probe the system under investigation to determine the true trigger in a way considerably more efficient than brute force methods. By sharing our findings, we aim to assist others grappling with similar challenges, enabling estimates on the complexity of their problem, the data required and a solution to solve it.

Read more

6/11/2024

🤯

Total Score

0

A Survey on Causal Inference for Recommendation

Huishi Luo, Fuzhen Zhuang, Ruobing Xie, Hengshu Zhu, Deqing Wang, Zhulin An, Yongjun Xu

Causal inference has recently garnered significant interest among recommender system (RS) researchers due to its ability to dissect cause-and-effect relationships and its broad applicability across multiple fields. It offers a framework to model the causality in recommender systems like confounding effects and deal with counterfactual problems such as offline policy evaluation and data augmentation. Although there are already some valuable surveys on causal recommendations, they typically classify approaches based on the practical issues faced in RS, a classification that may disperse and fragment the unified causal theories. Considering RS researchers' unfamiliarity with causality, it is necessary yet challenging to comprehensively review relevant studies from a coherent causal theoretical perspective, thereby facilitating a deeper integration of causal inference in RS. This survey provides a systematic review of up-to-date papers in this area from a causal theory standpoint and traces the evolutionary development of RS methods within the same causal strategy. Firstly, we introduce the fundamental concepts of causal inference as the basis of the following review. Subsequently, we propose a novel theory-driven taxonomy, categorizing existing methods based on the causal theory employed - namely, those based on the potential outcome framework, the structural causal model, and general counterfactuals. The review then delves into the technical details of how existing methods apply causal inference to address particular recommender issues. Finally, we highlight some promising directions for future research in this field. Representative papers and open-source resources will be progressively available at https://github.com/Chrissie-Law/Causal-Inference-for-Recommendation.

Read more

7/9/2024

Causal Distillation for Alleviating Performance Heterogeneity in Recommender Systems
Total Score

0

Causal Distillation for Alleviating Performance Heterogeneity in Recommender Systems

Shengyu Zhang, Ziqi Jiang, Jiangchao Yao, Fuli Feng, Kun Kuang, Zhou Zhao, Shuo Li, Hongxia Yang, Tat-Seng Chua, Fei Wu

Recommendation performance usually exhibits a long-tail distribution over users -- a small portion of head users enjoy much more accurate recommendation services than the others. We reveal two sources of this performance heterogeneity problem: the uneven distribution of historical interactions (a natural source); and the biased training of recommender models (a model source). As addressing this problem cannot sacrifice the overall performance, a wise choice is to eliminate the model bias while maintaining the natural heterogeneity. The key to debiased training lies in eliminating the effect of confounders that influence both the user's historical behaviors and the next behavior. The emerging causal recommendation methods achieve this by modeling the causal effect between user behaviors, however potentially neglect unobserved confounders (eg, friend suggestions) that are hard to measure in practice. To address unobserved confounders, we resort to the front-door adjustment (FDA) in causal theory and propose a causal multi-teacher distillation framework (CausalD). FDA requires proper mediators in order to estimate the causal effects of historical behaviors on the next behavior. To achieve this, we equip CausalD with multiple heterogeneous recommendation models to model the mediator distribution. Then, the causal effect estimated by FDA is the expectation of recommendation prediction over the mediator distribution and the prior distribution of historical behaviors, which is technically achieved by multi-teacher ensemble. To pursue efficient inference, CausalD further distills multiple teachers into one student model to directly infer the causal effect for making recommendations.

Read more

6/3/2024