Neyman-Pearson Multi-class Classification via Cost-sensitive Learning
0
🏷️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Existing classification methods aim to minimize the overall misclassification error rate, but in some applications like loan default prediction, different types of errors can have varying consequences.
- To address this asymmetry issue, two popular paradigms have been developed: the Neyman-Pearson (NP) paradigm and the cost-sensitive (CS) paradigm.
- Previous studies on the NP paradigm have primarily focused on the binary case, while the multi-class NP problem poses a greater challenge due to its unknown feasibility.
- This work tackles the multi-class NP problem by establishing a connection with the CS problem via strong duality and proposes two algorithms.
- The proposed algorithms satisfy the NP oracle properties under certain conditions and can offer practitioners the landscape of a multi-class NP problem with various target error levels.
Plain English Explanation
When making decisions based on classification models, such as predicting whether someone will default on a loan, some types of errors can be more costly than others. For example, incorrectly approving a loan for someone who ends up defaulting may be more harmful than incorrectly denying a loan to someone who would have repaid it.
To address this issue, researchers have developed two main approaches: the Neyman-Pearson (NP) paradigm and the cost-sensitive (CS) paradigm. The NP paradigm focuses on minimizing one type of error (e.g., loan defaults) while constraining the other type of error (e.g., denying loans to good borrowers) to a specific level. The CS paradigm, on the other hand, tries to directly minimize the overall cost of errors, with different costs assigned to different types of errors.
Previous work on the NP paradigm has mostly looked at the simpler case of binary classification (e.g., defaulting or not defaulting). This new research tackles the more complex problem of multi-class classification (e.g., predicting different types of loan outcomes), which is more challenging because it's not clear if a feasible solution even exists.
The researchers in this study establish a connection between the NP and CS problems, and then propose two algorithms to solve the multi-class NP problem. These algorithms have certain theoretical guarantees, and can also help practitioners understand the trade-offs between different types of errors in their multi-class classification problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper establishes a connection between the Neyman-Pearson (NP) paradigm and the cost-sensitive (CS) paradigm for multi-class classification problems via strong duality. The NP paradigm aims to minimize one type of error (e.g., loan defaults) while constraining the other type of error (e.g., denying loans to good borrowers) to a specific level. The CS paradigm, on the other hand, tries to directly minimize the overall cost of errors, with different costs assigned to different types of errors.
The researchers propose two algorithms to solve the multi-class NP problem. These algorithms satisfy the NP oracle properties, which are crucial for providing theoretical guarantees. The NP oracle properties extend the concept of NP oracle inequalities, which have been well-studied in the binary classification case, to the multi-class context.
Furthermore, the researchers develop practical algorithms to assess the feasibility and strong duality in multi-class NP problems. These algorithms can offer practitioners the landscape of a multi-class NP problem with various target error levels, allowing them to make informed decisions about the trade-offs between different types of errors.
The effectiveness of the proposed algorithms is validated through simulations and real-data studies. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first study to address the multi-class NP problem with theoretical guarantees.
Critical Analysis
The researchers have made a significant contribution by tackling the multi-class Neyman-Pearson (NP) problem, which is a more challenging extension of the well-studied binary NP problem. By establishing a connection with the cost-sensitive (CS) paradigm through strong duality, the authors have provided a novel approach to solving the multi-class NP problem.
One potential limitation of the study is the assumption of certain conditions required for the proposed algorithms to satisfy the NP oracle properties. It would be interesting to investigate the performance of these algorithms under more relaxed assumptions or in scenarios where the conditions are not fully met.
Additionally, the paper does not provide extensive real-world applications or case studies to demonstrate the practical implications of the proposed methods. Further research could focus on applying these algorithms to specific domains, such as loan default prediction or medical diagnosis, to showcase their benefits and limitations in realistic settings.
Another area for future research could be exploring the trade-offs between the NP and CS paradigms, and investigating whether there are scenarios where one approach might be more suitable than the other. A related paper on this topic is "Awareness of Uncertainty in Classification Using a Multivariate Model".
Overall, this work represents an important step forward in addressing the multi-class NP problem and provides a solid foundation for further research in this area. The proposed algorithms and their theoretical guarantees are valuable contributions to the field of machine learning and classification.
Conclusion
This research paper tackles the challenging problem of multi-class Neyman-Pearson (NP) classification, which is an important extension of the well-studied binary NP problem. By establishing a connection with the cost-sensitive (CS) paradigm, the authors have developed two algorithms that satisfy the NP oracle properties under certain conditions.
The proposed methods can help practitioners navigate the trade-offs between different types of classification errors, which is particularly relevant in applications where the consequences of errors vary. The ability to assess the feasibility and strong duality in multi-class NP problems can also offer valuable insights to users.
While the study has some limitations, such as the specific assumptions required for the theoretical guarantees, it represents a significant contribution to the field of machine learning and classification. The insights and algorithms presented in this work can pave the way for further research and practical applications in domains where nuanced error handling is crucial, such as loan default prediction, medical diagnosis, or multi-objective optimization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
0
Neyman-Pearson Multi-class Classification via Cost-sensitive Learning
Ye Tian, Yang Feng
Most existing classification methods aim to minimize the overall misclassification error rate. However, in applications such as loan default prediction, different types of errors can have varying consequences. To address this asymmetry issue, two popular paradigms have been developed: the Neyman-Pearson (NP) paradigm and the cost-sensitive (CS) paradigm. Previous studies on the NP paradigm have primarily focused on the binary case, while the multi-class NP problem poses a greater challenge due to its unknown feasibility. In this work, we tackle the multi-class NP problem by establishing a connection with the CS problem via strong duality and propose two algorithms. We extend the concept of NP oracle inequalities, crucial in binary classifications, to NP oracle properties in the multi-class context. Our algorithms satisfy these NP oracle properties under certain conditions. Furthermore, we develop practical algorithms to assess the feasibility and strong duality in multi-class NP problems, which can offer practitioners the landscape of a multi-class NP problem with various target error levels. Simulations and real data studies validate the effectiveness of our algorithms. To our knowledge, this is the first study to address the multi-class NP problem with theoretical guarantees. The proposed algorithms have been implemented in the R package texttt{npcs}, which is available on CRAN.
Read more8/2/2024
0
Provably Robust Cost-Sensitive Learning via Randomized Smoothing
Yuan Xin, Michael Backes, Xiao Zhang
We study the problem of robust learning against adversarial perturbations under cost-sensitive scenarios, where the potential harm of different types of misclassifications is encoded in a cost matrix. Existing approaches are either empirical and cannot certify robustness or suffer from inherent scalability issues. In this work, we investigate whether randomized smoothing, a scalable framework for robustness certification, can be leveraged to certify and train for cost-sensitive robustness. Built upon the notion of cost-sensitive certified radius, we first illustrate how to adapt the standard certification algorithm of randomized smoothing to produce tight robustness certificates for any binary cost matrix, and then develop a robust training method to promote certified cost-sensitive robustness while maintaining the model's overall accuracy. Through extensive experiments on image benchmarks, we demonstrate the superiority of our proposed certification algorithm and training method under various cost-sensitive scenarios. Our implementation is available as open source code at: https://github.com/TrustMLRG/CS-RS.
Read more5/31/2024
0
An Adaptive Cost-Sensitive Learning and Recursive Denoising Framework for Imbalanced SVM Classification
Lu Jiang, Qi Wang, Yuhang Chang, Jianing Song, Haoyue Fu, Xiaochun Yang
Category imbalance is one of the most popular and important issues in the domain of classification. Emotion classification model trained on imbalanced datasets easily leads to unreliable prediction. The traditional machine learning method tends to favor the majority class, which leads to the lack of minority class information in the model. Moreover, most existing models will produce abnormal sensitivity issues or performance degradation. We propose a robust learning algorithm based on adaptive cost-sensitiveity and recursive denoising, which is a generalized framework and can be incorporated into most stochastic optimization algorithms. The proposed method uses the dynamic kernel distance optimization model between the sample and the decision boundary, which makes full use of the sample's prior information. In addition, we also put forward an effective method to filter noise, the main idea of which is to judge the noise by finding the nearest neighbors of the minority class. In order to evaluate the strength of the proposed method, we not only carry out experiments on standard datasets but also apply it to emotional classification problems with different imbalance rates (IR). Experimental results show that the proposed general framework is superior to traditional methods in accuracy, recall and G-means.
Read more5/17/2024
🏷️
0
One-Shot Strategic Classification Under Unknown Costs
Elan Rosenfeld, Nir Rosenfeld
The goal of strategic classification is to learn decision rules which are robust to strategic input manipulation. Earlier works assume that these responses are known; while some recent works handle unknown responses, they exclusively study online settings with repeated model deployments. But there are many domains$unicode{x2014}$particularly in public policy, a common motivating use case$unicode{x2014}$where multiple deployments are infeasible, or where even one bad round is unacceptable. To address this gap, we initiate the formal study of one-shot strategic classification under unknown responses, which requires committing to a single classifier once. Focusing on uncertainty in the users' cost function, we begin by proving that for a broad class of costs, even a small mis-estimation of the true cost can entail trivial accuracy in the worst case. In light of this, we frame the task as a minimax problem, aiming to minimize worst-case risk over an uncertainty set of costs. We design efficient algorithms for both the full-batch and stochastic settings, which we prove converge (offline) to the minimax solution at the rate of $tilde{mathcal{O}}(T^{-frac{1}{2}})$. Our analysis reveals important structure stemming from strategic responses, particularly the value of dual norm regularization with respect to the cost function.
Read more6/24/2024