Oh, Behave! Country Representation Dynamics Created by Feedback Loops in Music Recommender Systems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Examines how feedback loops in music recommender systems can create biases in the representation of different countries
- Proposes a methodology to identify and analyze these feedback loops
- Provides insights into the dynamics and implications of these biases
Plain English Explanation
Music recommender systems are designed to suggest new songs and artists to listeners based on their past preferences. However, these systems can inadvertently create biases in the representation of different countries, as a result of feedback loops.
A feedback loop occurs when the recommendations made by the system influence the listening behavior of users, which in turn affects the data used to train the system. Over time, this can lead to certain countries being underrepresented or overrepresented in the recommendations, creating a self-reinforcing cycle.
The researchers in this paper propose a methodology to identify and analyze these feedback loops. By understanding how they work, they aim to help music streaming platforms optimize their systems for more balanced and inclusive representation of different countries and cultures.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a mathematical model to simulate the dynamics of country representation in music recommender systems. Their model incorporates factors such as user preferences, artist popularity, and the recommender system's algorithm.
Through simulations, they were able to observe the emergence of feedback loops that led to the over- or under-representation of certain countries. For example, if the system initially recommends more music from a popular country, users may engage more with those recommendations, further reinforcing the system's bias towards that country.
The researchers also conducted qualitative analyses to understand how users perceive and react to these biases in the recommendations they receive.
Critical Analysis
The paper acknowledges that the proposed model is a simplified representation of the complex dynamics in real-world music recommender systems. Factors such as user demographics, marketing strategies, and changes in music trends over time could also influence the feedback loops and biases observed.
Additionally, the researchers note that their study focuses on country-level representation, while the dynamics may vary for more nuanced cultural or linguistic distinctions within a country. Further research is needed to explore these more granular aspects of bias in music recommendations.
Conclusion
This paper provides valuable insights into the hidden feedback loops that can perpetuate biases in music recommender systems. By understanding these dynamics, music streaming platforms can develop more inclusive and equitable recommendation algorithms that better represent the diversity of musical cultures and artists from around the world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Oh, Behave! Country Representation Dynamics Created by Feedback Loops in Music Recommender Systems
Oleg Lesota, Jonas Geiger, Max Walder, Dominik Kowald, Markus Schedl
Recent work suggests that music recommender systems are prone to disproportionally frequent recommendations of music from countries more prominently represented in the training data, notably the US. However, it remains unclear to what extent feedback loops in music recommendation influence the dynamics of such imbalance. In this work, we investigate the dynamics of representation of local (i.e., country-specific) and US-produced music in user profiles and recommendations. To this end, we conduct a feedback loop simulation study using the standardized LFM-2b dataset. The results suggest that most of the investigated recommendation models decrease the proportion of music from local artists in their recommendations. Furthermore, we find that models preserving average proportions of US and local music do not necessarily provide country-calibrated recommendations. We also look into popularity calibration and, surprisingly, find that the most popularity-calibrated model in our study (ItemKNN) provides the least country-calibrated recommendations. In addition, users from less represented countries (e.g., Finland) are, in the long term, most affected by the under-representation of their local music in recommendations.
Read more8/22/2024
0
Do Recommender Systems Promote Local Music? A Reproducibility Study Using Music Streaming Data
Kristina Matrosova, Lilian Marey, Guillaume Salha-Galvan, Thomas Louail, Olivier Bodini, Manuel Moussallam
This paper examines the influence of recommender systems on local music representation, discussing prior findings from an empirical study on the LFM-2b public dataset. This prior study argued that different recommender systems exhibit algorithmic biases shifting music consumption either towards or against local content. However, LFM-2b users do not reflect the diverse audience of music streaming services. To assess the robustness of this study's conclusions, we conduct a comparative analysis using proprietary listening data from a global music streaming service, which we publicly release alongside this paper. We observe significant differences in local music consumption patterns between our dataset and LFM-2b, suggesting that caution should be exercised when drawing conclusions on local music based solely on LFM-2b. Moreover, we show that the algorithmic biases exhibited in the original work vary in our dataset, and that several unexplored model parameters can significantly influence these biases and affect the study's conclusion on both datasets. Finally, we discuss the complexity of accurately labeling local music, emphasizing the risk of misleading conclusions due to unreliable, biased, or incomplete labels. To encourage further research and ensure reproducibility, we have publicly shared our dataset and code.
Read more8/30/2024
0
Negative Feedback for Music Personalization
M. Jeffrey Mei, Oliver Bembom, Andreas F. Ehmann
Next-item recommender systems are often trained using only positive feedback with randomly-sampled negative feedback. We show the benefits of using real negative feedback both as inputs into the user sequence and also as negative targets for training a next-song recommender system for internet radio. In particular, using explicit negative samples during training helps reduce training time by ~60% while also improving test accuracy by ~6%; adding user skips as additional inputs also can considerably increase user coverage alongside slightly improving accuracy. We test the impact of using a large number of random negative samples to capture a 'harder' one and find that the test accuracy increases with more randomly-sampled negatives, but only to a point. Too many random negatives leads to false negatives that limits the lift, which is still lower than if using true negative feedback. We also find that the test accuracy is fairly robust with respect to the proportion of different feedback types, and compare the learned embeddings for different feedback types.
Read more6/10/2024
0
Advancing Cultural Inclusivity: Optimizing Embedding Spaces for Balanced Music Recommendations
Armin Moradi, Nicola Neophytou, Golnoosh Farnadi
Popularity bias in music recommendation systems -- where artists and tracks with the highest listen counts are recommended more often -- can also propagate biases along demographic and cultural axes. In this work, we identify these biases in recommendations for artists from underrepresented cultural groups in prototype-based matrix factorization methods. Unlike traditional matrix factorization methods, prototype-based approaches are interpretable. This allows us to directly link the observed bias in recommendations for minority artists (the effect) to specific properties of the embedding space (the cause). We mitigate popularity bias in music recommendation through capturing both users' and songs' cultural nuances in the embedding space. To address these challenges while maintaining recommendation quality, we propose two novel enhancements to the embedding space: i) we propose an approach to filter-out the irrelevant prototypes used to represent each user and item to improve generalizability, and ii) we introduce regularization techniques to reinforce a more uniform distribution of prototypes within the embedding space. Our results demonstrate significant improvements in reducing popularity bias and enhancing demographic and cultural fairness in music recommendations while achieving competitive -- if not better -- overall performance.
Read more5/29/2024