Open-Vocabulary Calibration for Fine-tuned CLIP
0
✅
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Vision-language models (VLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in various tasks like image recognition and text-driven visual content generation.
- Recent research has focused on improving the downstream performance of VLMs, especially through prompt learning methods.
- However, a crucial aspect that has been overlooked is the confidence calibration problem in fine-tuned VLMs, which could impact their reliability when deployed in real-world scenarios.
Plain English Explanation
Vision-language models are powerful AI systems that can understand and generate text based on visual information. They have shown impressive abilities in tasks like recognizing objects in images and creating text descriptions for visuals. In recent years, researchers have put a lot of effort into finding ways to fine-tune these models to perform even better on specific tasks, particularly by using prompt learning techniques.
However, one important issue that has largely been ignored is the problem of confidence calibration in these fine-tuned models. Confidence calibration refers to how well a model's predicted probabilities match the true likelihood of the predictions being correct. If a model is not well-calibrated, it may be overly confident in its predictions, which could be a problem when deploying the model in real-world applications where reliability is crucial.
This paper aims to address this confidence calibration problem in the context of vision-language models and prompt learning. The researchers present a simple and effective approach called Distance-Aware Calibration (DAC) that helps improve the confidence calibration of these models without sacrificing their speed or performance.
Technical Explanation
The paper systematically investigates the confidence calibration problem in the context of prompt learning for vision-language models. The researchers reveal that existing calibration methods, such as temperature scaling and gradient-based approaches, are insufficient to address this problem, especially in the open-vocabulary setting.
To solve the issue, the authors present a simple and effective approach called Distance-Aware Calibration (DAC). This method scales the temperature of the model's output based on the distance between the predicted text labels and the base classes. The intuition is that predictions closer to the base classes should have higher confidence, while those further away should have lower confidence.
The researchers evaluate the effectiveness of DAC across 7 distinct prompt learning methods and 11 diverse downstream datasets. The results show that DAC can significantly improve the confidence calibration of fine-tuned vision-language models without compromising their inference speed or performance.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable contribution by bringing attention to the overlooked issue of confidence calibration in fine-tuned vision-language models. The proposed DAC method appears to be a simple yet effective solution, as demonstrated by the extensive experiments.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the potential limitations or caveats of the approach. For example, it would be interesting to understand how the DAC method performs in scenarios where the base classes and the fine-tuning tasks are significantly different, or when dealing with out-of-distribution samples.
Additionally, the paper could have explored the overconfidence problem in more depth, as it is a critical concern in many real-world applications of vision-language models.
Overall, the research presented in this paper is a valuable step towards improving the reliability and trustworthiness of fine-tuned vision-language models, and the DAC method seems promising. However, further investigation into the limitations and potential extensions of this approach would be beneficial for the research community.
Conclusion
This paper tackles the important issue of confidence calibration in fine-tuned vision-language models, which is crucial for the reliable deployment of these powerful AI systems in real-world applications. The proposed Distance-Aware Calibration (DAC) method offers a simple yet effective solution to this problem, as demonstrated by the comprehensive experiments.
The findings of this research have the potential to significantly impact the field of vision-language AI, as they highlight the need for careful consideration of confidence calibration, not just performance optimization. By improving the reliability of these models, the DAC approach can contribute to the development of more trustworthy and transparent AI systems that can be safely deployed in a wide range of applications, from image recognition to visual chatbots.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
✅
0
Open-Vocabulary Calibration for Fine-tuned CLIP
Shuoyuan Wang, Jindong Wang, Guoqing Wang, Bob Zhang, Kaiyang Zhou, Hongxin Wei
Vision-language models (VLMs) have emerged as formidable tools, showing their strong capability in handling various open-vocabulary tasks in image recognition, text-driven visual content generation, and visual chatbots, to name a few. In recent years, considerable efforts and resources have been devoted to adaptation methods for improving downstream performance of VLMs, particularly on parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods like prompt learning. However, a crucial aspect that has been largely overlooked is the confidence calibration problem in fine-tuned VLMs, which could greatly reduce reliability when deploying such models in the real world. This paper bridges the gap by systematically investigating the confidence calibration problem in the context of prompt learning and reveals that existing calibration methods are insufficient to address the problem, especially in the open-vocabulary setting. To solve the problem, we present a simple and effective approach called Distance-Aware Calibration (DAC), which is based on scaling the temperature using as guidance the distance between predicted text labels and base classes. The experiments with 7 distinct prompt learning methods applied across 11 diverse downstream datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of DAC, which achieves high efficacy without sacrificing the inference speed. Our code is available at https://github.com/ml-stat-Sustech/CLIP_Calibration.
Read more6/17/2024
0
An Empirical Study Into What Matters for Calibrating Vision-Language Models
Weijie Tu, Weijian Deng, Dylan Campbell, Stephen Gould, Tom Gedeon
Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have emerged as the dominant approach for zero-shot recognition, adept at handling diverse scenarios and significant distribution changes. However, their deployment in risk-sensitive areas requires a deeper understanding of their uncertainty estimation capabilities, a relatively uncharted area. In this study, we explore the calibration properties of VLMs across different architectures, datasets, and training strategies. In particular, we analyze the uncertainty estimation performance of VLMs when calibrated in one domain, label set or hierarchy level, and tested in a different one. Our findings reveal that while VLMs are not inherently calibrated for uncertainty, temperature scaling significantly and consistently improves calibration, even across shifts in distribution and changes in label set. Moreover, VLMs can be calibrated with a very small set of examples. Through detailed experimentation, we highlight the potential applications and importance of our insights, aiming for more reliable and effective use of VLMs in critical, real-world scenarios.
Read more6/17/2024
0
Robust Calibration of Large Vision-Language Adapters
Balamurali Murugesan, Julio Silva-Rodriguez, Ismail Ben Ayed, Jose Dolz
This paper addresses the critical issue of miscalibration in CLIP-based model adaptation, particularly in the challenging scenario of out-of-distribution (OOD) samples, which has been overlooked in the existing literature on CLIP adaptation. We empirically demonstrate that popular CLIP adaptation approaches, such as Adapters, Prompt Learning, and Test-Time Adaptation, substantially degrade the calibration capabilities of the zero-shot baseline in the presence of distributional drift. We identify the increase in logit ranges as the underlying cause of miscalibration of CLIP adaptation methods, contrasting with previous work on calibrating fully-supervised models. Motivated by these observations, we present a simple and model-agnostic solution to mitigate miscalibration, by scaling the logit range of each sample to its zero-shot prediction logits. We explore three different alternatives to achieve this, which can be either integrated during adaptation or directly used at inference time. Comprehensive experiments on popular OOD classification benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approaches in mitigating miscalibration while maintaining discriminative performance, whose improvements are consistent across the three families of these increasingly popular approaches. The code is publicly available at: https://github.com/Bala93/CLIPCalib
Read more7/19/2024
0
Vision-Language Model Fine-Tuning via Simple Parameter-Efficient Modification
Ming Li, Jike Zhong, Chenxin Li, Liuzhuozheng Li, Nie Lin, Masashi Sugiyama
Recent advances in fine-tuning Vision-Language Models (VLMs) have witnessed the success of prompt tuning and adapter tuning, while the classic model fine-tuning on inherent parameters seems to be overlooked. It is believed that fine-tuning the parameters of VLMs with few-shot samples corrupts the pre-trained knowledge since fine-tuning the CLIP model even degrades performance. In this paper, we revisit this viewpoint, and propose a new perspective: fine-tuning the specific parameters instead of all will uncover the power of classic model fine-tuning on VLMs. Through our meticulous study, we propose ClipFit, a simple yet effective method to fine-tune CLIP without introducing any overhead of extra parameters. We demonstrate that by only fine-tuning the specific bias terms and normalization layers, ClipFit can improve the performance of zero-shot CLIP by 7.27% average harmonic mean accuracy. Lastly, to understand how fine-tuning in CLIPFit affects the pre-trained models, we conducted extensive experimental analyses w.r.t. changes in internal parameters and representations. We found that low-level text bias layers and the first layer normalization layer change much more than other layers. The code is available at url{https://github.com/minglllli/CLIPFit}.
Read more9/26/2024