Out-of-Distribution Detection using Maximum Entropy Coding
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel approach for out-of-distribution (OOD) detection using maximum entropy coding.
- The method aims to identify samples that are significantly different from the training data, which is an important challenge in machine learning.
- The authors explore the connection between OOD detection and entropy-based objectives, demonstrating how their approach can be applied to a variety of models.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning models are often trained on a specific set of data, like images of dogs and cats. However, in the real world, models may encounter data that is very different from what they were trained on, such as images of horses or birds. This "out-of-distribution" data can cause the model to perform poorly or make incorrect predictions.
The researchers in this paper developed a new technique to help models better identify when they are seeing something unexpected or out-of-distribution. Their key idea is to use a concept called "maximum entropy coding" to analyze the model's predictions. Essentially, they look at how "surprised" the model is by the input data, and use that as a signal to detect when the data is out-of-distribution.
By connecting out-of-distribution detection to this idea of maximum entropy, the researchers were able to create a versatile approach that can be applied to many different types of machine learning models. This is an important advance, as reliably detecting out-of-distribution data is a longstanding challenge in the field.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel approach for out-of-distribution (OOD) detection that leverages the connection between OOD detection and entropy-based objectives. The authors demonstrate how their maximum entropy coding (MEC) method can be applied to a variety of models, including deep learning models, sparse coding models, and Bayesian neural networks.
The key insight is that OOD samples tend to have higher entropy (i.e., the model is more "surprised" by them) compared to in-distribution samples. By optimizing the model to have maximum entropy on OOD data during training, the authors show that the model can learn to better detect OOD samples at test time.
The paper also explores gradient-based regularization techniques to improve the model's ability to distinguish in-distribution and OOD data. Through extensive experiments on benchmark datasets, the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their MEC approach compared to prior OOD detection methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to the important problem of out-of-distribution detection. By connecting this challenge to the concept of maximum entropy, the authors have developed a versatile and principled solution that can be applied to a variety of model architectures.
One potential limitation is that the method relies on having access to OOD data during training, which may not always be feasible in real-world scenarios. The authors acknowledge this and suggest using synthetic or adversarially-generated OOD samples as an alternative. Further research could explore ways to relax this requirement and make the approach more generally applicable.
Additionally, while the experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the MEC method, it would be valuable to see how it performs on larger-scale, real-world datasets and applications. Exploring the method's robustness to distributional shift and its performance in safety-critical domains could also be fruitful areas for future work.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for out-of-distribution detection using maximum entropy coding. By optimizing the model to have maximum entropy on OOD data during training, the authors show that the model can learn to better identify samples that are significantly different from the training distribution at test time.
The authors' insights into the connection between OOD detection and entropy-based objectives, as well as their versatile approach that can be applied to a variety of models, represent an important contribution to the field of machine learning. As models are increasingly deployed in the real world, the ability to reliably detect and handle out-of-distribution data will only become more crucial. This work takes a significant step forward in addressing this challenge.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Out-of-Distribution Detection using Maximum Entropy Coding
Mojtaba Abolfazli, Mohammad Zaeri Amirani, Anders H{o}st-Madsen, June Zhang, Andras Bratincsak
Given a default distribution $P$ and a set of test data $x^M={x_1,x_2,ldots,x_M}$ this paper seeks to answer the question if it was likely that $x^M$ was generated by $P$. For discrete distributions, the definitive answer is in principle given by Kolmogorov-Martin-L{o}f randomness. In this paper we seek to generalize this to continuous distributions. We consider a set of statistics $T_1(x^M),T_2(x^M),ldots$. To each statistic we associate its maximum entropy distribution and with this a universal source coder. The maximum entropy distributions are subsequently combined to give a total codelength, which is compared with $-log P(x^M)$. We show that this approach satisfied a number of theoretical properties. For real world data $P$ usually is unknown. We transform data into a standard distribution in the latent space using a bidirectional generate network and use maximum entropy coding there. We compare the resulting method to other methods that also used generative neural networks to detect anomalies. In most cases, our results show better performance.
Read more4/29/2024
🏅
0
Sourcerer: Sample-based Maximum Entropy Source Distribution Estimation
Julius Vetter, Guy Moss, Cornelius Schroder, Richard Gao, Jakob H. Macke
Scientific modeling applications often require estimating a distribution of parameters consistent with a dataset of observations - an inference task also known as source distribution estimation. This problem can be ill-posed, however, since many different source distributions might produce the same distribution of data-consistent simulations. To make a principled choice among many equally valid sources, we propose an approach which targets the maximum entropy distribution, i.e., prioritizes retaining as much uncertainty as possible. Our method is purely sample-based - leveraging the Sliced-Wasserstein distance to measure the discrepancy between the dataset and simulations - and thus suitable for simulators with intractable likelihoods. We benchmark our method on several tasks, and show that it can recover source distributions with substantially higher entropy than recent source estimation methods, without sacrificing the fidelity of the simulations. Finally, to demonstrate the utility of our approach, we infer source distributions for parameters of the Hodgkin-Huxley model from experimental datasets with thousands of single-neuron measurements. In summary, we propose a principled method for inferring source distributions of scientific simulator parameters while retaining as much uncertainty as possible.
Read more5/16/2024
⚙️
0
The Principle of Uncertain Maximum Entropy
Kenneth Bogert, Matthew Kothe
The principle of maximum entropy is a well-established technique for choosing a distribution that matches available information while minimizing bias. It finds broad use across scientific disciplines and in machine learning. However, the principle as defined by is susceptible to noise and error in observations. This forces real-world practitioners to use relaxed versions of the principle in an ad hoc way, negatively impacting interpretation. To address this situation, we present a new principle we call uncertain maximum entropy that generalizes the classic principle and provides interpretable solutions irrespective of the observational methods in use. We introduce a convex approximation and expectation-maximization based algorithm for finding solutions to our new principle. Finally, we contrast this new technique with two simpler generally applicable solutions theoretically and experimentally show our technique provides superior accuracy.
Read more9/12/2024
0
Learning to Embed Distributions via Maximum Kernel Entropy
Oleksii Kachaiev, Stefano Recanatesi
Empirical data can often be considered as samples from a set of probability distributions. Kernel methods have emerged as a natural approach for learning to classify these distributions. Although numerous kernels between distributions have been proposed, applying kernel methods to distribution regression tasks remains challenging, primarily because selecting a suitable kernel is not straightforward. Surprisingly, the question of learning a data-dependent distribution kernel has received little attention. In this paper, we propose a novel objective for the unsupervised learning of data-dependent distribution kernel, based on the principle of entropy maximization in the space of probability measure embeddings. We examine the theoretical properties of the latent embedding space induced by our objective, demonstrating that its geometric structure is well-suited for solving downstream discriminative tasks. Finally, we demonstrate the performance of the learned kernel across different modalities.
Read more8/2/2024