PATIENT-{Psi}: Using Large Language Models to Simulate Patients for Training Mental Health Professionals

Read original: arXiv:2405.19660 - Published 6/21/2024 by Ruiyi Wang, Stephanie Milani, Jamie C. Chiu, Jiayin Zhi, Shaun M. Eack, Travis Labrum, Samuel M. Murphy, Nev Jones, Kate Hardy, Hong Shen and 2 others
Total Score

0

PATIENT-{Psi}: Using Large Language Models to Simulate Patients for Training Mental Health Professionals

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This research paper explores the use of large language models (LLMs) to simulate patients for training mental health professionals.
  • The authors conducted a formative study to understand the needs and perspectives of mental health professionals regarding the use of simulated patients.
  • The paper presents the technical details of the Patient-Ψ system, which leverages LLMs to generate realistic patient dialogues for training purposes.
  • The researchers also performed a critical analysis of the potential limitations and areas for further research in this domain.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers in this study wanted to explore how large language models could be used to help train mental health professionals. They started by talking to mental health professionals to understand what kind of tools and technologies they would find useful for training.

Based on this feedback, the researchers developed a system called Patient-Ψ that uses large language models to generate realistic dialogues that simulate patient conversations. The idea is that mental health professionals could use these simulated patient interactions to practice their skills, like assessing mental health conditions and providing appropriate therapy, without needing to work with real patients.

The researchers tested their Patient-Ψ system and found that it could generate fairly natural-sounding patient dialogues. They also discussed some of the potential limitations and challenges of using this approach, such as ensuring the simulated patients accurately represent the diversity of real-world patients. Overall, the goal is to use AI-generated patient simulations to improve the training and preparation of mental health professionals.

Technical Explanation

The researchers conducted a formative study to understand the needs and perspectives of mental health professionals regarding the use of simulated patients for training purposes. They interviewed clinicians and trainees to identify key requirements, such as the ability to generate diverse patient profiles, customize dialogue scripts, and provide feedback on trainee performance.

Based on these insights, the researchers developed the Patient-Ψ system, which leverages large language models (LLMs) to simulate patient conversations. The system uses a prompt-engineering approach to fine-tune the LLM on a curated dataset of mental health-related dialogues, allowing it to generate personalized patient responses that align with specific mental health conditions and scenarios.

The researchers evaluated the technical capabilities of Patient-Ψ through a series of experiments, assessing the system's ability to generate coherent, contextually appropriate, and emotionally nuanced patient dialogues. They also explored strategies for improving the realism and diversity of the simulated patients, such as incorporating demographic information, personality traits, and conversational patterns.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research in their work. One key concern is the potential for bias and lack of diversity in the training data used to fine-tune the LLM, which could lead to simulated patients that do not accurately represent the full range of mental health experiences and backgrounds.

Additionally, the researchers note the challenges of ensuring the clinical validity and fidelity of the simulated patient dialogues, as well as the need for more extensive evaluation of the system's usefulness and impact on trainee learning outcomes. Integrating feedback mechanisms and iterative refinement based on user interactions could help address these limitations.

While the Patient-Ψ system shows promise, the researchers emphasize the importance of continued research and collaboration with mental health professionals to ensure the responsible and effective deployment of such AI-powered simulation tools in clinical training environments.

Conclusion

This research paper presents a novel approach to leveraging large language models for the generation of simulated patient dialogues to support the training of mental health professionals. The formative study and technical development of the Patient-Ψ system demonstrate the potential for AI-powered patient simulation to enhance clinical training and preparation.

However, the researchers also highlight the need to carefully address issues of bias, diversity, and clinical validity to ensure the responsible and effective use of these technologies. Ongoing collaboration between researchers, clinicians, and trainees will be crucial in refining and validating the capabilities of systems like Patient-Ψ to improve the quality and accessibility of mental health care.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

PATIENT-{Psi}: Using Large Language Models to Simulate Patients for Training Mental Health Professionals
Total Score

0

PATIENT-{Psi}: Using Large Language Models to Simulate Patients for Training Mental Health Professionals

Ruiyi Wang, Stephanie Milani, Jamie C. Chiu, Jiayin Zhi, Shaun M. Eack, Travis Labrum, Samuel M. Murphy, Nev Jones, Kate Hardy, Hong Shen, Fei Fang, Zhiyu Zoey Chen

Mental illness remains one of the most critical public health issues. Despite its importance, many mental health professionals highlight a disconnect between their training and actual real-world patient practice. To help bridge this gap, we propose PATIENT-{Psi}, a novel patient simulation framework for cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) training. To build PATIENT-{Psi}, we construct diverse patient cognitive models based on CBT principles and use large language models (LLMs) programmed with these cognitive models to act as a simulated therapy patient. We propose an interactive training scheme, PATIENT-{Psi}-TRAINER, for mental health trainees to practice a key skill in CBT -- formulating the cognitive model of the patient -- through role-playing a therapy session with PATIENT-{Psi}. To evaluate PATIENT-{Psi}, we conducted a comprehensive user study of 13 mental health trainees and 20 experts. The results demonstrate that practice using PATIENT-{Psi}-TRAINER enhances the perceived skill acquisition and confidence of the trainees beyond existing forms of training such as textbooks, videos, and role-play with non-patients. Based on the experts' perceptions, PATIENT-{Psi} is perceived to be closer to real patient interactions than GPT-4, and PATIENT-{Psi}-TRAINER holds strong promise to improve trainee competencies. Our code and data are released at url{https://github.com/ruiyiw/patient-psi}.

Read more

6/21/2024

Leveraging Large Language Model as Simulated Patients for Clinical Education
Total Score

0

Leveraging Large Language Model as Simulated Patients for Clinical Education

Yanzeng Li, Cheng Zeng, Jialun Zhong, Ruoyu Zhang, Minhao Zhang, Lei Zou

Simulated Patients (SPs) play a crucial role in clinical medical education by providing realistic scenarios for student practice. However, the high cost of training and hiring qualified SPs, along with the heavy workload and potential risks they face in consistently portraying actual patients, limit students' access to this type of clinical training. Consequently, the integration of computer program-based simulated patients has emerged as a valuable educational tool in recent years. With the rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs), their exceptional capabilities in conversational artificial intelligence and role-playing have been demonstrated, making them a feasible option for implementing Virtual Simulated Patient (VSP). In this paper, we present an integrated model-agnostic framework called CureFun that harnesses the potential of LLMs in clinical medical education. This framework facilitates natural conversations between students and simulated patients, evaluates their dialogue, and provides suggestions to enhance students' clinical inquiry skills. Through comprehensive evaluations, our approach demonstrates more authentic and professional SP-scenario dialogue flows compared to other LLM-based chatbots, thus proving its proficiency in simulating patients. Additionally, leveraging CureFun's evaluation ability, we assess several medical LLMs and discuss the possibilities and limitations of using LLMs as virtual doctors from the perspective of their diagnostic abilities.

Read more

4/26/2024

Are Large Language Models Possible to Conduct Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?
Total Score

0

Are Large Language Models Possible to Conduct Cognitive Behavioral Therapy?

Hao Shen, Zihan Li, Minqiang Yang, Minghui Ni, Yongfeng Tao, Zhengyang Yu, Weihao Zheng, Chen Xu, Bin Hu

In contemporary society, the issue of psychological health has become increasingly prominent, characterized by the diversification, complexity, and universality of mental disorders. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), currently the most influential and clinically effective psychological treatment method with no side effects, has limited coverage and poor quality in most countries. In recent years, researches on the recognition and intervention of emotional disorders using large language models (LLMs) have been validated, providing new possibilities for psychological assistance therapy. However, are LLMs truly possible to conduct cognitive behavioral therapy? Many concerns have been raised by mental health experts regarding the use of LLMs for therapy. Seeking to answer this question, we collected real CBT corpus from online video websites, designed and conducted a targeted automatic evaluation framework involving the evaluation of emotion tendency of generated text, structured dialogue pattern and proactive inquiry ability. For emotion tendency, we calculate the emotion tendency score of the CBT dialogue text generated by each model. For structured dialogue pattern, we use a diverse range of automatic evaluation metrics to compare speaking style, the ability to maintain consistency of topic and the use of technology in CBT between different models . As for inquiring to guide the patient, we utilize PQA (Proactive Questioning Ability) metric. We also evaluated the CBT ability of the LLM after integrating a CBT knowledge base to explore the help of introducing additional knowledge to enhance the model's CBT counseling ability. Four LLM variants with excellent performance on natural language processing are evaluated, and the experimental result shows the great potential of LLMs in psychological counseling realm, especially after combining with other technological means.

Read more

7/26/2024

Interactive Agents: Simulating Counselor-Client Psychological Counseling via Role-Playing LLM-to-LLM Interactions
Total Score

0

Interactive Agents: Simulating Counselor-Client Psychological Counseling via Role-Playing LLM-to-LLM Interactions

Huachuan Qiu, Zhenzhong Lan

Virtual counselors powered by large language models (LLMs) aim to create interactive support systems that effectively assist clients struggling with mental health challenges. To replicate counselor-client conversations, researchers have built an online mental health platform that allows professional counselors to provide clients with text-based counseling services for about an hour per session. Notwithstanding its effectiveness, challenges exist as human annotation is time-consuming, cost-intensive, privacy-protected, and not scalable. To address this issue and investigate the applicability of LLMs in psychological counseling conversation simulation, we propose a framework that employs two LLMs via role-playing for simulating counselor-client interactions. Our framework involves two LLMs, one acting as a client equipped with a specific and real-life user profile and the other playing the role of an experienced counselor, generating professional responses using integrative therapy techniques. We implement both the counselor and the client by zero-shot prompting the GPT-4 model. In order to assess the effectiveness of LLMs in simulating counselor-client interactions and understand the disparities between LLM- and human-generated conversations, we evaluate the synthetic data from various perspectives. We begin by assessing the client's performance through automatic evaluations. Next, we analyze and compare the disparities between dialogues generated by the LLM and those generated by professional counselors. Furthermore, we conduct extensive experiments to thoroughly examine the performance of our LLM-based counselor trained with synthetic interactive dialogues by benchmarking against state-of-the-art models for mental health.

Read more

8/29/2024