Peer-to-Peer Deep Learning for Beyond-5G IoT

Read original: arXiv:2310.18861 - Published 5/7/2024 by Srinivasa Pranav, Jos'e M. F. Moura

🤿

Overview

Presents P2PL, a new peer-to-peer deep learning algorithm for beyond-5G computing environments
Avoids the coordination issues of federated learning approaches
Enables on-device training while leveraging local peer-to-peer communication for distributed consensus

Plain English Explanation

P2PL is a new way for devices like smartphones or IoT sensors to collaboratively train deep learning models without relying on a central server. Unlike federated learning approaches, P2PL allows devices to directly communicate with each other to share and combine their model parameters.

This is particularly useful for large-scale computing environments like smart cities, where federated learning can run into issues with things like network latency, bandwidth limitations, and single points of failure. With P2PL, devices can work together locally to train models without needing coordination from central servers or the cloud.

P2PL works by having each device alternate between two phases: 1) training the deep learning model on local data, and 2) communicating with nearby devices to merge their model parameters. This peer-to-peer cooperation allows the devices to collectively converge on a shared model, even if they have non-identical data distributions.

The key innovations in P2PL are the use of "max norm synchronization" to speed up training, and the leveraging of local device-to-device communication to implement a distributed consensus process. This allows P2PL to match the performance of centralized and federated training approaches, while being more scalable and robust to network issues.

Technical Explanation

P2PL introduces a new approach to distributed deep learning that avoids the coordination challenges of federated learning by enabling direct peer-to-peer collaboration between devices.

The algorithm operates in two alternating phases. In the first phase, each device independently trains a deep learning model on its local data. In the second phase, the devices communicate with their peers to combine their model parameters. This peer-to-peer cooperation allows the collective model to converge, even when the data on each device is non-identical (non-IID).

P2PL introduces a technique called "max norm synchronization" to accelerate the training process. It also leverages local device-to-device communication to implement a distributed consensus mechanism, without requiring coordination from edge servers or the cloud.

The authors empirically evaluate P2PL across a range of settings, including 100 devices, diverse network topologies, sparse and intermittent communication, and non-IID data distributions. They show that P2PL can match the test performance of both centralized and federated training approaches, making it well-suited for large-scale, beyond-5G computing environments like smart cities.

Critical Analysis

The P2PL paper presents a compelling approach to distributed deep learning that addresses several limitations of federated learning. By enabling direct peer-to-peer collaboration, P2PL avoids the need for centralized coordination, which can be a bottleneck in large-scale, resource-constrained environments.

One potential concern is the assumption of reliable local device-to-device communication. In real-world settings, such connectivity may be intermittent or unreliable, which could impact the convergence and stability of the P2PL algorithm. The authors do explore some scenarios with sparse communication, but further research may be needed to understand the algorithm's robustness under more challenging network conditions.

Additionally, while P2PL preserves on-device training to protect user privacy, the paper does not delve deeply into the privacy implications of the peer-to-peer parameter sharing. Privacy-enhanced approaches could be an interesting area for future exploration.

Overall, the P2PL algorithm represents an innovative step forward in distributed deep learning, with the potential to enable more scalable and resilient machine learning in large-scale computing environments. However, further research may be needed to address potential limitations and expand the real-world applicability of the approach.

Conclusion

The P2PL paper presents a novel peer-to-peer deep learning algorithm that overcomes several limitations of federated learning, making it well-suited for large-scale, beyond-5G computing environments. By enabling direct collaboration between devices, P2PL avoids the need for centralized coordination, which can be a bottleneck in resource-constrained settings.

The key innovations in P2PL are the use of max norm synchronization to accelerate training and the leveraging of local device-to-device communication to implement a distributed consensus process. These techniques allow P2PL to match the performance of centralized and federated training approaches, while being more scalable and robust to network issues.

While the paper demonstrates the effectiveness of P2PL across a range of experimental settings, further research may be needed to address potential concerns around the reliability of peer-to-peer communication and the privacy implications of the parameter sharing process. Nonetheless, the P2PL algorithm represents an exciting step forward in the field of distributed deep learning, with the potential to enable more scalable and resilient machine learning in the context of smart cities and other large-scale computing environments.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤿

Peer-to-Peer Deep Learning for Beyond-5G IoT

Srinivasa Pranav, Jos'e M. F. Moura

We present P2PL, a practical multi-device peer-to-peer deep learning algorithm that, unlike the federated learning paradigm, does not require coordination from edge servers or the cloud. This makes P2PL well-suited for the sheer scale of beyond-5G computing environments like smart cities that otherwise create range, latency, bandwidth, and single point of failure issues for federated approaches. P2PL introduces max norm synchronization to catalyze training, retains on-device deep model training to preserve privacy, and leverages local inter-device communication to implement distributed consensus. Each device iteratively alternates between two phases: 1) on-device learning and 2) peer-to-peer cooperation where they combine model parameters with nearby devices. We empirically show that all participating devices achieve the same test performance attained by federated and centralized training -- even with 100 devices and relaxed singly stochastic consensus weights. We extend these experimental results to settings with diverse network topologies, sparse and intermittent communication, and non-IID data distributions.

5/7/2024

P4: Towards private, personalized, and Peer-to-Peer learning

Mohammad Mahdi Maheri, Sandra Siby, Sina Abdollahi, Anastasia Borovykh, Hamed Haddadi

Personalized learning is a proposed approach to address the problem of data heterogeneity in collaborative machine learning. In a decentralized setting, the two main challenges of personalization are client clustering and data privacy. In this paper, we address these challenges by developing P4 (Personalized Private Peer-to-Peer) a method that ensures that each client receives a personalized model while maintaining differential privacy guarantee of each client's local dataset during and after the training. Our approach includes the design of a lightweight algorithm to identify similar clients and group them in a private, peer-to-peer (P2P) manner. Once grouped, we develop differentially-private knowledge distillation for clients to co-train with minimal impact on accuracy. We evaluate our proposed method on three benchmark datasets (FEMNIST or Federated EMNIST, CIFAR-10 and CIFAR-100) and two different neural network architectures (Linear and CNN-based networks) across a range of privacy parameters. The results demonstrate the potential of P4, as it outperforms the state-of-the-art of differential private P2P by up to 40 percent in terms of accuracy. We also show the practicality of P4 by implementing it on resource constrained devices, and validating that it has minimal overhead, e.g., about 7 seconds to run collaborative training between two clients.

6/3/2024

Decentralized Personalized Federated Learning

Salma Kharrat, Marco Canini, Samuel Horvath

This work tackles the challenges of data heterogeneity and communication limitations in decentralized federated learning. We focus on creating a collaboration graph that guides each client in selecting suitable collaborators for training personalized models that leverage their local data effectively. Our approach addresses these issues through a novel, communication-efficient strategy that enhances resource efficiency. Unlike traditional methods, our formulation identifies collaborators at a granular level by considering combinatorial relations of clients, enhancing personalization while minimizing communication overhead. We achieve this through a bi-level optimization framework that employs a constrained greedy algorithm, resulting in a resource-efficient collaboration graph for personalized learning. Extensive evaluation against various baselines across diverse datasets demonstrates the superiority of our method, named DPFL. DPFL consistently outperforms other approaches, showcasing its effectiveness in handling real-world data heterogeneity, minimizing communication overhead, enhancing resource efficiency, and building personalized models in decentralized federated learning scenarios.

6/11/2024

🚀

Decentralized Directed Collaboration for Personalized Federated Learning

Yingqi Liu, Yifan Shi, Qinglun Li, Baoyuan Wu, Xueqian Wang, Li Shen

Personalized Federated Learning (PFL) is proposed to find the greatest personalized models for each client. To avoid the central failure and communication bottleneck in the server-based FL, we concentrate on the Decentralized Personalized Federated Learning (DPFL) that performs distributed model training in a Peer-to-Peer (P2P) manner. Most personalized works in DPFL are based on undirected and symmetric topologies, however, the data, computation and communication resources heterogeneity result in large variances in the personalized models, which lead the undirected aggregation to suboptimal personalized performance and unguaranteed convergence. To address these issues, we propose a directed collaboration DPFL framework by incorporating stochastic gradient push and partial model personalized, called textbf{D}ecentralized textbf{Fed}erated textbf{P}artial textbf{G}radient textbf{P}ush (textbf{DFedPGP}). It personalizes the linear classifier in the modern deep model to customize the local solution and learns a consensus representation in a fully decentralized manner. Clients only share gradients with a subset of neighbors based on the directed and asymmetric topologies, which guarantees flexible choices for resource efficiency and better convergence. Theoretically, we show that the proposed DFedPGP achieves a superior convergence rate of $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{sqrt{T}})$ in the general non-convex setting, and prove the tighter connectivity among clients will speed up the convergence. The proposed method achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) accuracy in both data and computation heterogeneity scenarios, demonstrating the efficiency of the directed collaboration and partial gradient push.

5/29/2024